View more on these topics

Your commission: should you choose to accept it?

I feel the need to rebuke Best Invest&#39s Mr Spiers&#39 comments in the Money Marketing issue of June10.

He says that despite the honesty of an IFA, the IFA will “favour products with the highest commission”.

I wish to know who he thinks he is, taking it upon himself to decide the business ethics of advisers, most of which he does not know, has not met and never will meet.

As IFAs predominantly investing in portfolio management, we undertake around 25-30 hours per month fund research to have a core of 30 fund managers from Oeic and unit trust houses to build and maintain a portfolio of such funds for our clients on an advisory basis.

We do not use insurance companies&#39 funds. We will use an investment bond for trusts but only if it has external fund links with funds that we use for our portfolios.

We use the investments that are of most benefit to the client, not to the adviser.We also do not take the easy route by using fund of funds, manager of manager, thus providing value for money.

Mr Spiers&#39 comments are not only irritating, they are extremely insulting.

He of all people should know (being in the position he is in) that this type of comment is just what a financial journalist from one of the daily newspapers is praying for.

While his success in restructuring Bestinvest into an adviser that does not accept initial commission should be applauded, given his comments above, one has to take a cynical approach and wonder if there is a hidden agenda?

He will know that a half to three-quarters of small IFAs could not survive without initial commission – there is nothing like getting rid of the competition. Fortunately,my practice would survive quite easily.

Colin Fogwill

Principal,Fogwill & Jones

Sheffield

Recommended

Talkback

“Projection rates have caused problems as they have to be based on information that is current and just look at the endowment problems. But I am unsure whether they should be scrapped.”Stewart Brooke,Brooke Christian & Co “The FSA should certainly do away with it. Projection rates are incredibly confusing and misleading. The 9 per cent […]

Don&#39t tar us all with same brush

Dear Financial Services Consumer panelConsumer confidence is being eroded on a daily basis by commentators who tar the entire industry with the same brush. The real culprits are Gordon Brown with his tax on pension funds, MPs in the Treasury select committee who are out to make a name for themselves, so-called consumer bodies who […]

Laying my cards on a reshuffle

I am going to take my life in my hands and make some political predictions. I believe we are less than a year away from a general election. Time for some reflection on a likely summer reshuffle, perhaps? Following last week&#39s local and European elections, it is highly likely that the Prime Minister will look […]

Kirwan quitting Abbey for Widows

Nick Kirwan has resigned as head of marketing and product development at Abbey for Intermediaries after nine years and is set to join Scottish Widows. Kirwan, who is well known for his work with Scottish Provident and ABI working parties, is joining Widows in the early autumn as its marketing director, protection, as part of […]

UK housebuilders remain a value trap – despite post-Brexit falls

Despite the sharp drop in housebuilders following the Brexit result, valuations in the highly illiquid market are still at elevated levels. And whilst some investors may take comfort from superficially low price/earnings multiples, are earnings sustainable over the long term, asks Holly Cassell, Assistant Manager of the Neptune UK Mid Cap Fund. Click here to […]

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up

Comments

    Leave a comment