View more on these topics

Will spike in high LTI loans force FPC to revisit cap?


Economists are backing the Financial Policy Committee’s cap on lending at higher income multiples after the Council of Mortgage Lenders poured scorn on the policy, saying it puts pressure on mortgage affordability.

In June 2014 the FPC announced lenders had to make sure no more than 15 per cent of new lending was at income multiples of 4.5 or more.

The macro-regulator said the measure was meant to curb high future levels of household debt by stopping borrowers from taking out overly expensive mortgages with high income multiples. But CML  chief economist Bob Pannell says these loans help tackle the problem of average household incomes falling behind average house prices.

Pannell says: “Mounting affordability pressures, as house prices outpace earnings growth across much of the UK, provide the most plausible explanation for the change of direction.”

The knee-jerk reaction from lenders in 2014 was to restrict this type of lending. In mid-2014 around 10 per cent of new loans were at high income multiples, but this fell to below 7 per cent the following year.

But CML figures released last week show lender appetite for high income multiple loans is bouncing back rapidly, showing strong underlying demand for this type of lending (see graph).

Pannell says many borrowers struggle with mortgage affordability, and the cap is not helping.

He says: “If the impact is now showing through as upwards pressure on income multiples, then the FPC’s 15 per cent limit risks becoming a progressively harder cap over time, and we should expect to see a build-up of lending just below the 4.5 times threshold.

“Looking forward, the macro-prudential tools may help the housing market to cool. But if house price pressures persist, then the FPC may find itself subject to much closer public scrutiny as it exerts a more visible effect on the pace of housing activity and generates headwinds to the Government’s pro-home-ownership policies.”

John Charcol senior technical manager Ray Boulger says he agrees with the CML and believes the FPC and the FCA are at loggerheads with affordability policy.

He says: “The FCA introduces the Mortgage Market Review, which basically says income multiples are bad, affordability is good, so lenders should calculate the maximum on affordability. Then you had the FPC saying only a few months later that the emphasis is on income multiples.

“We are at a place now where there are too many regulators putting their finger in the pie. I absolutely agree with the CML. The regulators are doing things that impede the Government’s policy.”

But housing economists say the cap is necessary and its current level is appropriate, despite growing affordability pressures on UK homebuyers.

Capital Economics chief property economist Ed Stansfield says: “The FPC’s role is to be the party pooper and to stop the collective actions of individuals who might, in their own terms, be acting entirely responsibly and rationally, but having adverse consequences for the wider financial sector and economy.

“If at some point that rule doesn’t become restrictive, then there isn’t a lot of point in having it, or in having the FPC.”

GPS Economics director Gary Styles says there is no need to change the cap level. He says: “There is a natural limit to these things. Arguing for people to be leveraging even further on the basis that house prices have gone ever higher is not going to win you a lot of friends with the regulator, to be honest.”

Stansfield says the cap leaves lenders looking to increase mortgage affordability in the future with no choice but to extend terms.

He says: “There has been substantial movement in that direction already with mortgage terms going up past 20 to 25 years, and some even going past 30 years.”

But the Money Advice Service warns the trend towards longer mortgage periods has a sting in the tail for borrowers.

MAS money expert Andrew Johnson says: “Although this could make it more affordable for first time buyers to achieve their ambition of becoming a homeowner, it will cost them considerably more in interest repayments over the term of the mortgage.”

However, Stansfield says the FPC might take a dim view of increasing mortgage terms. “If the FPC sees that firms or borrowers are just trying to circumvent that by spreading the mortgage payments over a longer period, I’d expect them to act.”



Tax relief reform could spark more ‘cash for pension’ bribes

Government plans to reform tax relief could result in more employers following the NHS and tempting staff with deals that lead them to give up pension contributions in favour of high salaries. Last week it was revealed the Oxleas NHS Foundation Trust in South-east London is giving newly-qualified band five nurses the choice of being paid […]

FCA logo new 3 620x430

NAO: FCA lacks evidence on whether it is tackling misselling

The National Audit Office has found the FCA has no clear way of knowing whether its actions are successful in curbing misselling in financial services. In a report on regulation and redress, published today, the NAO says while increased fines and compensation have reduced the incentives for firms to missell products, the FCA “lacks good […]


Nic Cicutti: Garry Heath’s Libertatem is sinking into oblivion

For anyone who rides a motorbike or a scooter, February is one of those exciting times as you start to prepare for the long-distance journeys you hope to be making over the next few months. As a vintage scooter owner who carries out most of his own spanner work, I am often in a dilemma: do I […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm