View more on these topics

Will lenders follow lead of trailblazer Yorkshire?

Yorkshire Building Society&#39s pledge to introduce trail commission has reignited industry debate about how IFAs should be paid for selling mortgages.

The society is the first lender to stick its neck out and make a concrete promise to introduce renewal fees in a bid to retain mortgage business.

The obvious question for IFAs is what other lenders intend to do. Not for the first time, a herd mentality has taken hold and the industry is seeing a raft of responses from lenders singing from the same “wait and see” song sheet.

But, in this case, their reluctance to state a firm position has a certain logic to it. How IFAs are paid by providers has long been a thorny issue across the financial services industry but is one that taints the image of the mortgage industry more than most.

The reportedly high procuration fees in the sub-prime sector have often drawn allegations of broker bias towards the products sporting the fattest fees.

Bradford & Bingley felt compelled to equalise the commission it pays to its brokers when it converted its branches into IFA centres to pre-empt any charges of bias.

Yorkshire&#39s move could help clean up the image of the market but this is not the primary motivation for its decision. It believes paying IFAs on a dripfeed basis rather than by a one-off up-front fee will help stem the proliferation of rate-chasing borrowers switching mortgages every couple of years.

While most lenders admit this situation is unsustainable, many are remarkably quiet when it comes to doing something about it. One of the few to buck this trend is Skipton Building Society. Head of corporate communications Mark Smitheringale says: “We have talked about this for a long time. If introducing trail commission encourages brokers to stop churning business, then we would welcome it – anything that helps reduce the cannibalisation of lenders&#39 mortgage books.”

But although Skipton is prepared to talk to any big IFA or network about a bespoke trail commission agreement, Smitheringale says it will not impose a more wide-reaching arrangement until it has seen the market reaction to York-shire&#39s decision.

This waiting game is popular among lenders. Nationwide Building Society is effectively speaking for the whole market when it says it is “considering” a similar move but has no concrete plans or any kind of timescale. It will see how Yorkshire fares and act accordingly.

However, there are those who believe lenders should pay less attention to each other and look closer to home. Scottish Amicable national mortgage manager John Malone says the deciding factor for many lenders considering this approach should be the composition of their product range.

He says: “Those lenders with products with longevity, such as trackers and flexible mortgages, should be more likely to pay trail commission because their products lend themselves to this type of payment. Discounted shorter-term loans suit payment by up-front procuration fees, so I think the nature of lenders&#39 product ranges should play a crucial part in their decision.”

The success of Yorkshire&#39s move could hinge on such factors. If most lenders do not follow suit, it is likely that Yorkshire&#39s share of new business could dip as dramatically as Nationwide&#39s, which is suffering because its competitors have refused to take its long-term view in dropping discount mortgages.

Savills Private Finance director Mike Boles says: “If Yorkshire makes the move first, then I think some lenders may follow but not all. Those lenders would struggle to attract new business because brokers can get an up-front fee from other providers and remortgage the client in a few years for another fee.”

While Boles doubts that Yorkshire has the strength on its own to haul the market out of its current dilemma, others are not so sure. Pretty Technical Partnership partner Kim North welcomes the move and believes the society, while not among the biggest lenders, has enough quality in its products to make the move work.

She says: “The big procuration fees are undoubtedly dying, so now is a good time to try and be a pioneer as long as there are good products on offer, which Yorkshire has. I think lenders will follow because they know trail commission is the future but it is vitally important there is a second tranche of providers doing this, otherwise Yorkshire will find it very difficult to trade.”

A big factor for Yorkshire will be the level of renewal commission it pays and for how long. Even more important will be whether it decides to scrap up-front fees altogether and pay the whole commission over a few years or simply reduce procuration fees and pay less retrospectively.

Yorkshire says it is still ironing out such details, perhaps aware of the significance of its decision. Its move towards trail commission could either revolutionise the way IFAs are paid or prove to be a damp squib which damages its share of new business.

As much as Yorkshire holds its destiny – and potentially that of IFAs – in its own hands, ultimately, its success or failure hinge on its rivals being brave enough to follows its move.


Principality Building Society – Discount Option 5

Tuesday, 12 June 2001.Discounted term: Until August 31, 2006.Discount: 0.86 per cent.Payable rate: 5.59 per cent.Minimum loan: £5,000.Maximum loan: Up to 95 per cent of valuation subject to no maximum. Remortgages up to 90 per cent of valuation subject to no maximum.Income multiples: 3.5 times principal income plus second or 2.5 times joint.Arrangement fee: None.Redemption […]

Product Matters

Yorkshire Building Society is considering making a radical change to the way in which it pays procuration fees to mortgage introducers. Instead of the fee being paid in full on completion, Yorkshire proposes to reduce that amount and then pay smaller payments for each year the borrower remains with Yorkshire. The move is obviously designed […]

Inside Edge by Jim Gaskin

It appears to me that in the majority of cases there are two main issues affecting an IFA&#39s use of technology – time and money. This view is borne out of many discussions I have had with IFAs over the years but more recently optimum use of technology has become the must-have for IFAs. A […]

Towry Law launches extranet website for employers

Towry Law is launching an interactive website which will allow employers to offer employees a full support service of information, financial advisory services and transactions through an extranet link.Employees can buy Isas, take out a stakeholder pension and view information on generic mortgage types. The service, designed for large or small employers, is supported by […]

Johnson Fleming is a finalist at UK Pensions Awards 2016

The UK Pensions Awards shine the light on excellence and recognise the advisers, providers and investment managers that offer the highest level of innovation, performance and service to occupational pension schemes and their members. This year’s awards looked at advisers and providers across 31 different categories and were rigorously judged by a panel of senior […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm