View more on these topics

Will exodus from policy guarantees reach critical mass?

The announcement by Swiss Re that it plans to stop underwriting critical-illness guarantees has left product providers and IFAs wondering what the future holds for guaranteed business.

Currently representing 98 per cent of CI sales, policies sold with guaranteed rather than reviewable premiums have been the mainstay of the individual market since their introduction eight years ago.

But now Swiss Re, one of the two biggest underwriters in the UK protection market, has decided it is no longer willing to take the risk involved with guaranteed premiums.

It will continue to offer guarantees of up to five years and then policies will be subject to a review and face the possibility of rising premiums. The move will not affect existing policyholders, whose policies will be allowed to continue with a guarantee attached.

Swiss Re says constantly advancing medical technology and changing definitions of cover mean it is costly to tie itself in to policies which do not allow for premium reviews.

It cites recent changes to the ABI&#39s code of practice for CI, which saw the definition of what constitutes a heart attack broadened and the removal of prostate cancer cover from many new policies, as an example of why it is no longer prudent to work on a guaranteed basis.

Deputy chief executive Stephen McArthur says: “We will no longer provide guarantees. We do not think it is prudent to offer long-term guarantees of that nature because of the changing medical technology affecting instances of claims.”

All eyes are now turned to Swiss Re&#39s main rival in the protection underwriting arena, GE Frankona, to see if it will follow suit. If it does, the end could be nigh for CI policies with guarantees as it is unlikely that any of the smaller protection reinsurers will continue offering guarantees.

GE Frankona head of pricing and product development Azim Dinani says: “The issues in the marketplace make forecasting of claims extremely difficult, particularly when you are looking at forecasting 25 to 30 years forward.

“In this environment, while guarantees are still offered in the market, the future for guaranteed rates is obviously difficult to predict. It is quite possible that insurers will have to look at reviewing the basic product design and the benefit structure, together with the CI definitions, to limit the potential viability and make it more viable to offer guarantees.”

Swiss Re concedes that if other reinsurers do not follow its lead it could lose significant market share in the protection underwriting business.

But Winful Associates principal John Winful says: “I think other reinsurers will follow. I do not see how one reinsurer will remain offering guarantees, shouldering all the risk.”

One concern of the industry is likely to how the disappearance of guaranteed rates will affect sales, particularly where policies are attached to mortgages. But while some commentators suggest there will be a negative effect, others do not expect consumers to be worried.

Scottish Provident head of marketing and product development Nick Kirwan says: “If there is going to be change, it is clearly going to be an industrywide issue. What will not change, however, is the customer&#39s need to have the product and it will not change the customer&#39s desire to buy the product. I believe that customers will still buy CI without a guarantee.”

Portfolio Insurance consultancy principal Brian Lentz says: “The vast majority of CI that we sell is not based on a guaranteed premium, anyway.It is based on a whole-of-life structure, so we will not be that affected by this change. It will potentially change the sale of mortgage-related products and it is going to decimate the non-regulated discount brokers who will no longer be able to compete.”

Most product providers recognise that they may be forced to stop offering guaranteed policies in the future.

But Skandia protection brand manager Shelley Robertson says: “We intend to offer guarantees as long as possible on our CI policies. We are very keen for other reinsurers not to follow Swiss Re&#39s lead. The more we can do to offer customers guarantees in this uncertain world, the better.”

No one is sounding the death knell for critical illness but many believe that the market is facing a huge shake-up in the way that products are designed and marketed.


Faith, hope, strategy

It is now time to start to draw to a conclusion this latest series of articles in which I have discussed certain important aspects of financial planning based on establishing and reviewing target levels of future income for clients and providing recommendations as to how these targets may be met.Throughout these articles, I have contrasted […]

Selestia adding property

Multi-manager Selestia is introducing property as a new asset class after adding two property funds from Norwich Union and Edinburgh Fund Managers to its platform.The funds – the NU property trust and EFM property portfolio – can be accessed via Selestia&#39s collective investment account and collective and offshore bonds but not through Pep or Isa […]

Ilog to continue IFA subsidy

The Independent Life Offices Group has confirmed it will continue its financial support of IFAs by providing an 85 per cent subsidy of IFA contributions to the Financial Services Compensation Scheme. Aifa has been in negotiations with ILOG on the issue for some time, as originally reported in Money Marketing in May. The FSCS levy […]

New corporate comms director at Axa UK

Axa UK has announced the appointment of Christina Bowman as director of corporate communications, assuming responsibility for all the corporate affairs activities of Axa UK&#39s operations in the UK and Ireland.Bowman joins from public relations consultants Hill & Knowlton where she was a board director. She has also worked in the past at Scottish Mutual […]

9 October thumbnail

Johnson Fleming set to host webinar on auditing auto-enrolment schemes

With 23 auto-enrolment compliance notices issued by the Pensions Regulator, and an evolving legislative landscape meaning previously compliant schemes may now be in breach of regulation, now is the time to think about auditing your auto-enrolment scheme. Johnson Fleming is hosting a webinar on 9 October at 11:00 on how to audit your scheme to ensure compliance, avoid breaches and fines and overcome data issues.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and thought leadership.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm