View more on these topics

Will Bellpenny’s ambitious independence play pay off?


The words “independent advice” don’t normally conjure up images of a £3.5bn national behemoth acquiring other firms at a rate of roughly ten a year.

That’s why consolidator Bellpenny’s decision to launch an independent advice arm will come as a surprise for many. The traditional notion of independent advice seems at complete odds with the model often associated with well-funded restricted firms: purchase lots, acquire assets and run a profitable centralised investment proposition.

With scale does come the promise of efficiency though. If Bellpenny can cut the cost of delivering independent advice by building a new national brand, then fair play to it.

There are a couple of outstanding questions that deserve attention, however.

First: are there really enough scale independents for Bellpenny to buy to be able to deliver a quality service at a reasonable price? FCA data shows that while 83 per cent of firms are still independent, they only bring in 38 per cent of adviser charges. That is, while there are fewer restricted firms, they do dominate the market by size.

Those many small independent firms remaining out there face temptations from plenty of other restricted bidders, many of whom will offer lucrative rewards for keeping business with them.

Second: will independent advice make the kind of margins to keep Bellpenny’s private equity owner Oaktree Capital happy?

When I spoke to Bellpenny chief executive Nigel Stockton earlier this week, he said Oaktree were “outstanding owners and investors” and starting an independent service is “not looking to change that.”

It really depends on the price Bellpenny pays for the firms. EFG Independent Financial Advisers turned a profit of £584,000 in 2015. Without a centralised investment proposition to make margin off, how long it takes Bellpenny to make a return for Oaktree reduces to a simple formula: purchase price divided by annual profit.

Perhaps moving clients on to a centralised investment proposition is not as profitable as everyone assumes. Or perhaps Bellpenny simply ran out of suitable firms that were willing to buy in to a restricted status.

A view to a sale?

In that case, does it put the ducks in a row for a float or sale, where Bellpenny could conceivably sell off its independent and restricted businesses separately to generate more value than buying the group as a whole? That would seem to be the strategy Old Mutual is taking in its “managed separation” right now.

I asked Stockton if the plan was still to float or sell in the end, and if the independent business might be hived off if so.

He responded: “Bellpenny is a group, that’s one entity of it, and nothing has changed about Bellpenny longer term. If we build a really strong, profitable business of national advice the future is going to look after itself. We are not at that point, and that’s not going to change in the short to medium term.”

On a more cynical interpretation, does that mean Bellpenny is going to have to start charging significantly higher fees for the privilege of independence and/or to get the group to a place where it is strong enough to float?

That’s unlikely, Stockton suggests.

He says: “It doesn’t mean we are going to move all our fees around. When the deal is completed we will have to look at what we are thinking about, but my initial reaction is that clients are comfortable where they are and we need to work with them.”

Clients can find plenty to reassure them in those words.

Amid the surprise, there must also be plenty willing to tip their cap to a company willing to go out on a limb and make a bold move into the independent space when so many industry veterans are warning cost pressures have made it unviable.

Justin Cash is news editor at Money Marketing



Profile: Bellpenny’s Nigel Stockton on acquiring advisers and serving the mass market

Nigel Stockton is annoyed. When he sits down with Money Marketing it is the day after the FCA announced a probe into advice firm consolidators’ acquisition processes. The regulator is concerned about the quality of suitability checks and whether acquired clients are being shunted into centralised investment propositions. And while the new Bellpenny chief executive […]

Bellpenny sales director exits

Consolidator Bellpenny’s sales director Simon Youlton has left the firm and moved to Australia. Youlton has been with the business since July 2013, and was national financial planning manager before rising to head of financial planning and ultimately being appointed sales director. A spokesman for the firm said: “We’ve always known that it has been […]


Bellpenny chief exec steps down

National wealth manager Bellpenny has appointed Countrywide financial services director Nigel Stockton as chief executive, replacing Kevin Ronaldson. Stockton, who has been a Bellpenny director since it was founded, will take over the role in September, while Ronaldson will become founder director. Prior to Countrywide, Stockton was mortgages sales director at Lloyds and managing director […]

Tree - thumbnail

The politics of healthcare

Healthcare is already one of the key battlefields in May’s general election, with each of the main parties committing to deliver improvements to the NHS and public health.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. The strategy is fairly simple, as it stands EFG would not fit comfortably in the Bellpenny restricted solution, but amongst those clients and for some of those advisers the restricted solution will work. Gradually both will be migrated to the centralised proposition which is possibly the best solution. This leaves the rump of IFA clients in a specialised proposition, which will potentially be more expensive but have the quality to match the cost. Surely this is what RFR was all about, clients getting explicit detail about the range of services they are being offered, with a detailed list of costs and them choosing the most appropriate service for them

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and thought leadership.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm