Why artificial intelligence won’t replace advisers anytime soon

The robots are coming and they are after our jobs, so we’ve been told.

Huge advances in artificial intelligence mean machines are now capable of doing many of the tasks once carried out by humans.

That’s good news for employers, who will benefit from greater efficiencies, but it could potentially mean bad news for less skilled workers.

By the mid-2030s as many as one in three jobs – both skilled and unskilled roles – could be lost to automation, according to consultancy PwC.

While manual positions such as factory workers and waiters are most at risk, automation does present a credible threat to more highly-skilled professions – including financial advisers.

And in a way, that threat is already very real, with robo-propositions making some inroads into parts of the advice process in the past few years, albeit we’re starting to see some high-profile failures here too.

Robo-adviser claims to be first fully regulated automated holistic financial planner

Some believe that threat will only get greater as AI improves. After all, computers are better than humans at analysing large sets of data, can carry out tasks much quicker and make data-centric decisions, rather than on human instinct and experience, which is often fallible.

Nevertheless, we believe technology has a long way to go before it replaces human advisers.

Perhaps the biggest barrier to widespread use of AI is regulation. Trying to explain why a machine learning model has behaved in a certain way is difficult, even if we are confident it has produced the right outcome.

Ex-Coutts banker launches robo-advice offering

Therefore, we are asking the customer to trust the outcome it produces. It is highly unlikely that will go down well with the Financial Conduct Authority, which will no doubt be keeping a close eye on the adoption of AI in the financial advice industry.

Then there is the question of data – something you need a lot of for a successful AI model. All but the biggest advice firms have the sort of data needed to create successful AI models.

Platforms could aid smaller advice firms, by using AI to ‘nudge’ advisers to review certain portfolios, to help them stay on top of things and ensure better customer outcomes. Of course, this comes with its own regulatory challenges, namely: whose data is it, and could these nudges amount to a personal recommendation?

Moreover, data is by no means perfect and can contain biases. An AI model’s behaviour is defined by the data that feeds it. If that data set contains biases, then it will taint the model and there is the potential for bad client outcomes.

On a more basic level, people are typically suspicious of new technology, which can slow down adoption. It is questionable whether financial advice firms will be comfortable basing a recommendation on algorithms they don’t fully understand themselves.

That suspicion also stretches to the general public. While younger, less-wealthy customers may be willing to interact with a chatbot or a robo-adviser, older clients may be less willing to do so.

And even if attitudes change, there is a very good chance that people – young or old – will still want the peace of mind of speaking to a human when it comes to more complex transactions.

Therefore, we believe that rather than threaten advisers’ existence, AI will instead be used to better equip advisers to provide quality advice, potentially by using it to improve operational efficiency and gather better information about their clients.

For example, machine learning could help advisers to understand and predict customer behaviour, such as how they are likely to react in a market downturn. This would allow the adviser to intervene before clients take steps that could lead to bad outcomes.

Machines learning’s ability to categorise indicators and predict likely behaviours means it lends itself well to risk-profiling. As well as a client questionnaire, there might also be demographic information, such as their age and where they live, that is relevant.

So, while we will undoubtedly see AI used more and more in the provision of advice, we believe it will be used primarily in speeding up information collection and to automate tasks that take humans several hours to complete.

The robots are coming. But they’re not coming for financial advisers – not yet.

Simon Clare is head of technology and innovation (wealth) at Bravura Solutions 


Is value investing still a viable option?

RWC Partners’ Ian Lance looks into what investors are doing wrong when it comes to value, and whether now is the time to look at growth or value stocks. Why has value done so badly for the last few years? I suspect a large part of the answer is the environment that we have been […]


FSCS deems LC&F liable for advice given by marketing firm

The Financial Services Compensation Scheme has deemed that “mini-bond” provider London Capital & Finance has liability for the advice given to investors by the unregulated marketing firm it used. Online marketing company Surge acted on behalf of LC&F to target investors and made millions of pounds in the process. An FSCS investigation found a “number […]

Current multi asset positioning

2018 has brought particular challenges for the global economic backdrop, providing the potential for greater than usual volatility over the summer. Nersen Pillay, Investment Director explains that this is not necessarily a bad thing for active managers, sharing the importance of diversification and tactical asset allocation in weathering these conditions. Read the article here Past […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 2 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Rahul Panicker 17th July 2019 at 6:26 am

    I think that there is still a lot of work that has to be done when it comes to chatbots in terms of business process integrations, better NLP engine, user experience… and bots are going to be the defacto interaction channel on the de facto personal device, the smartphone. The technology and potential are still in its infancy with the immediate solves being in interaction design, business cases to apply, removing interaction constraints and acceptance. The big win is that the technology has inherent automation, machine learning, and 24 x 7 intelligent availability. We at Engati http://www.engati.com have started the journey and have been rated one of the best open platforms for building bots by Techworld, Analytics India Magazine and more. Do visit us and provide us with your valuable feedback as we strive for more mainstream acceptance of this technology of the future.

  2. […] This article originally appeared on Money Marketing on 16th July 2019. You can view the article here. […]

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and thought leadership.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm

Email: customerservices@moneymarketing.com