View more on these topics

Wholesale changes

Paul Thomas reports on the Conservative proposals that have created major concern in the mortgage market.

The Conservative election manifesto includes promises to abolish the tripartite system of regulation for a consumer protection agency, transfer the role of prudential supervision to the Bank of England and set up a free financial advice service, which the sector would pay for through a “£50m social responsibility levy”.

The Conservatives would make the £250,000 stamp duty threshold for first-time buyers permanent and push ahead with a levy on banks regardless of whether there is support from the international community.

But perhaps the most concerning thing for the mortgage market was the Tories’ claim that they would lessen the UK’s dependence on wholesale funding, adding to the worries of the funding gap facing the industry.

Cicero Consulting director Iain Anderson says the announcement could add to the struggle that lenders face in trying to secure wholesale funding.

He says: “They really specifically ruled out stimulating wholesale funding. That is an interesting place to be, given the fact that the lending community is starting to think about ways to increase capacity.

“The fact that the Conservatives have ruled out public policy measures to increase wholesale funding means there is an uphill battle for the lending industry to make that case if the Conservatives win.”

Association of Mortgage Intermediaries director Robert Sinclair warns that a future Tory Government should not interfere with the wholesale structure that is in place.

He says: “I can understand that they do not want to do any more but they tere have to be careful to sustain what is out there.”

The document says the Budget rise in the stamp duty threshold for first-time buyers to £250,000 for two years would be made permanent.

A Council of Mortgage Lenders spokesman says: “It will be helpful to first-time buyers over a longer period but it does not address the key barrier for first-time buyers at the moment, which is the size of the deposit that they have to put down on a property.”

’It is interesting there is a willingness to stimulate the housing market through one policy lever, stamp duty, and not have a stimulant through another policy lever – wholesale funding’

Building Societies Association head of mortgage policy Paul Broadhead says: “We believe the stamp duty regime is in need of long overdue reform. The nature of the tax means buyers pay significantly more tax when they reach the thresholds, and this means there is a significant grouping of properties priced immediately below each thresholds.”

Anderson is intrigued by the conflict in the Tories’ views on stimulating the mortgage market.

He says: “It is interesting there is a willingness to stimulate the housing market through one policy lever, stamp duty, and not have a stimulant through another policy lever – wholesale funding.”

On the Tory initiative to scrap the tripartite system of regulation, Anderson is concerned the move could be a case of rebranding the FSA.
He says: “If it is purely about moving people around and putting a new brand on the FSA building, then that is not a good idea. It cannot just be cosmetic.”

However, Mac Consulting chief executive Mark Chilton believes the Tories are right to replace the FSA. He says: “It is a bold move and the right thing to do. Clearly, in what we have seen in the last two years, regulation and monitoring has fallen between too many stools. The FSA is the one who has underperformed.”

But Chilton argues that pressing on with a levy on the banks without international consensus would be wrong.

He says: “Britain is heavily reliant on financial services. Even if one other major power does not adopt the levy, then you are going to see the shift of banking away from the UK, and that would be damaging for the economy.”

Shadow Chancellor George Osborne announced plans to introduce a free financial advice service under a Tory Government in the economic manifesto. The £50m scheme would be paid for by a levy on the financial services sector.

Association of Mortgage Intermediaries director Robert Sinclair says: “Anything that moves the world forward so more people want to take advice is a good thing but we believe that is best served by people who are experts in that arena and that intermediary world.”

BSA director general Adrian Coles is concerned over the eventual cost to the industry.

He says: “We have concerns about the funding mechanism for such a service. Building society margins are under huge pressure. There will be an onus on the new provider of financial advice to operate in an extremely cost-effective manner to minimise further burdens on those institutions and their customers.”


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 4 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. IF the Tories secure sufficient majority.


  2. We as turkeys are going to vote for Christmas.

    Not Likely

  3. The problem is, th yo yo policies…whichever party is never can achieve anything.

    The present parties and their remit is too narrow for anyone to live by..let alone run a complex society..this coupeled with those in power…are the ones that want to be there..rather than those who are able…

    what is need is a new party with a broader remit so all sections of society are served, brought together to create wealth and security for all in happy balance…this is possible…

  4. Tory rhetoric on this topic will mean a huge cost for the industry with little or no benefit. Mistake on banks were made, it was Gordon’s fault, he admitted it, but don’t go ripping down something that is finally starting to work to weed out the undesirables in this industry. What the hell does the bank of England know or care about insurance or health products. The other proposed financial crimes initiative is also a waste of money that would be better spent else where.

    George Osbourn – Buffoon – out his depth standing in a shallow puddle

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm