View more on these topics

Who will be casualties of mortgage regulation?

The nightmare for the mortgage industry is that lenders, besides selling mortgages, may have to turn themselves into mini regulators.

With the FSA in little mood to compromise, lenders are distinctly unhappy.

This was particularly evident at last week&#39s Council of Mortgage Lenders conference, where chairman Philip Will iamson asked providers to raise their hands to signify they are happy with the way mortgage regulation is shaping up.

Not a hand was raised. This could be an indication that lenders are nervous of mortgage regulation, which inc ludes FSA proposals to charge lenders with the task of monitoring the disclosure regime for mortgage intermediaries.

It perhaps came as no surprise when CML director general Michael Coogan criticised these proposals at the conference, warning of dramatic changes if mortgage advice is brought under the regulatory radar of lenders rather than the FSA.

Arguably, the most controversial part of the speech was on the percentage of market shrinkage predicted by Coogan.

He claimed that up to three-quarters of intermediaries and up to half of lenders could fall out of the market if lenders are forced effectively to become the regulator.

Chase de Vere Mortgage Management managing director Simon Tyler says the figures are slightly alarmist but does not doubt the validity of Coogan&#39s argument. He says the move to turn lenders into regulators would be time-consuming and impractical.

Some intermediaries fear they will have to deal with excessive paperwork and endless compliance visits from lenders keen to ensure disclosure requirements are met.

Tyler says: “It could raise questions of who is running the company.”

This could be a major headache for the bigger intermediaries who may be forced to cope with disclosure monitoring from dozens of lenders.

John Charcol (Guildford) sales manager Colin Bell says: “It is not right for the lenders to be responsible and it will cause brokers to leave the market. It should be regulated by a separate body, not necessarily the FSA.”

But it is not only bigger intermediaries which are likely to feel the strain but also smaller firms which complete only a handful of mortgages a month. It is possible lenders will not be able to afford to monitor low levels of business, meaning small firms will be marginalised out of the market.

Riach Independent Financial Advisers sole trader Bob Riach says: “The small IFAs will be the most affected. They will not have the time to go through all the procedures involved with selling a mortgage. I cannot see how lenders can be responsible for these small firms. How will they be able to monitor them?” The FSA says the key purpose of its mortgage regulation strategy is to increase transparency and give consumers greater choice by increasing the levels of information.

In the regulator&#39s view, consumers do not shop around enough for the best deal and end up tied to a mortgage which is not necessarily the most suitable product for them.

FSA head of mortgage regulation Sarah Wilson told the CML conference of the high number of complaints the banking ombudsman has rec eived recently about mortgage misselling.

She said the best way to combat this is to increase the amount of up-front information available to the consumer. Wilson argues this will put borrowers in a better position to make informed choices and that the only route for this is to “get to intermediaries through lenders”.

But Allied Dunbar franchise support director and board member of the mortgage code compliance board David Seviour says: “It is not viable for lenders to ensure compliance every time. The MCCB is a ready-made non-partisan platform for monitoring disclosure. Allowing the mortgage code to fail in this way will be an act of irresponsibility.”

Some brokers consider Coogan&#39s belief that 50-75 per cent of intermediaries will be forced out of the market is an exaggeration but they do not dispute the fact that there will be casualties.

Riach says: “All intermediaries dealing with less than 20 mortgage transactions a month will have to come out of the market. I think the CML should be the regulator. The FSA will go over the top as they usually do and over-regulate. IFAs will ask themselves if it is worth doing the business.”

Some lenders are less con-cerned about the consequences of being forced to monitor disclosure and are calling for the industry to be patient. Legal & General marketing manager (housing) Rich ard Verdin says: “It is a bit early to make any sort of assessment with only a small amount of detail on how the activities that take place bet ween lenders and IFAs will be catered for and how they will be monitored.”

But others see the market going down a different path than the numbers of brokers and lenders dropping and instead predict an increase in takeovers and merger activities.

Scottish Amicable national mortgage manager John Malone says: “There will probably be some form of convergence. Within five years, there will be less mainstream players standing alone, very much like the life industry. The big lenders will end up doing more business.”

Whether making lenders take responsibility for regulating intermediaries leads to a contracting or a consolidating market, both lenders and brokers are hoping the FSA is prepared to take their concerns on board but the signs are not good.


FSA calls off watchdog on investment trusts

The AITC is claiming victory following an FSA climbdown on planned changes to the remit of the Financial Omb udsman Ser vice. The FSA is not going ahead with proposals it outlined in May which would have allowed investment trust shareholders to make complaints to the FOS. The AITC has been in regular contact with […]

IFA bids to edge out estate agents with net service

A Hartlepool-based IFA plans to push estate agents out of the housing market by establishing a network of IFAs capable of fulfilling the role of est ate agents. The new venture, 1st4PropertySales, is headed by Jim Gillespie, a director of three IFA firms. Gillespie says he intends to smash the dominance of est ate agents […]

JRA, Virgin and networks pick over the salesforce

IFA networks and direct salesforces, including J Rothschild Assurance and Virgin Direct, are preparing to snap up Equi table Life&#39s salesforce. JRA has already app ro ached individual members of the 400-strong salesforce and is looking to continue its cherry-picking approach. Virgin Direct says it expects to be taking on a number of Equitable Life […]

RJ Temple will finish purchase by end of year

RJ Temple has confirmed it will complete the acquisition of a small specialist IFA before the end of the year. The national IFA with almost 250 advisers two further acquisitions in the pipeline for January. It says it is currently considering a number of firms in England and Scotland and is locking to use the […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm