View more on these topics

What would a Corbyn win mean for financial services?

Mark Sands, photographed in their offices in central London. Photo by Michael Walter/Troika

With less than a week to go before voting closes in polls for Labour’s new leader, the potential implications of a victory for Jeremy Corbyn are beginning to crystalise.

Corbyn only squeezed into the leadership context by achieving the required support of 36 MPs when enough backed his position to broaden the debate.

But with polls closing at midday on 10 September, bookies are continuing to mark the Islington North MP as their favourite for a stunning victory.

A self-described socialist, Corbyn’s election could see the Labour party lurch deeper into the left of British politics.

Key promises from the Corbyn camp so far have included the nationalisation of energy companies and railways as well as the scrapping of the Trident nuclear deterrent, but what could his election mean for the world of financial services?

While Corbyn is yet to reveal a complete pensions policy, only last week he wrote in the Telegraph to suggest a flexible age of retirement, arguing that increases in the state pension age allowed those with well-paid jobs to take early retirement, while those with the least savings are forced to work into old age.

“We need a flexible pension age that allows people to work for as long as they want to, while also recognising that for many people the nature of their work, their health, or their disability may not allow that,” he says.

However, figures from Hargreaves Lansdown suggest slashing the state pension age could double the value of benefits some people receive in retirement.

Based on an assumed flat-rate state pension of £155 per week, Hargreaves estimates that if a person started to receive their state pension at 60, this would cost £303,463.

By contrast, if a person started to receive it at age 70 this would cost £150,260.

Hargreaves head of pensions research Tom McPhail says: “It turns out that if Corbyn wants to pay out the state pension at the age of 60 then it’s going to cost quite a lot of money.

“It does open an interesting opportunity for the Government to go to the likes of Just Retirement and ask how much it would cost to provide state pensions for a given worker, and they could then underwrite them and charge a nominal sum to pay his state pensions.

“You could use the private sector to underwrite but it would be potentially quite bureaucratic and costly and it doesn’t seem like Corbyn would want to use the sector in that way.”

Cicero director and chief corporate counsel Iain Anderson suggests Corbyn would also likely promote an agenda focused on consumer costs for the private savings sector, picking up on the lead of his predecessor Ed Miliband, who attempted to push the government to introduce a cap on drawdown charges.

Anderson says: “You could easily see a focus on charges and costs coming from a Jeremy Corbyn front bench. He has been putting forward some consumer friendly ideas.”

Corbyn has also been keen to tackle a lack of supply in the housing market, and has promised to expand the existing Right-to-Buy regime beyond the council and housing association tenants currently in remit to include those in privately rented accommodation.

The plans would see tenants offered subsidised mortgage rates, backed by the withdrawal of tax allowances given to buy-to-let landlords.

Details of discounts offered remain scarce and it remains unclear how workable any efforts would be. Economist Gary Styles suggests the policy would be ripe for legal challenge.

“It sounds like it would be pretty unworkable, but I could see that maybe large corporate landlords with thousands of units might be interested in getting involved,” Styles says.

“Other than that, I can’t see there being much appeal, and you could well end up with the same problems in the current market, where investors approach tenants to get them to buy their property, only to acquire it off them later.

“That’s already happening with public sector tenants, so it’s certainly a possibility if it gets expanded to private sector landlords.”

Underlying these policies is the divisive fundamental of “Corbynomics” – a state led investment programme that would see the Bank of England print new money for housing authorities and local councils to build infrastructure like housing and schools.

Over 50 academics wrote to the Financial Times to criticise the plans last week, while another 40 wrote to the Observer to hail them in late August.

Regardless of its merits, Financial Inclusion Centre director says a Corbyn leadership would see the role of the City of London in the UK’s economy drastically adjusted.

McAteer says: “It would probably be rebalanced, because he would also try to make sure the City works for the real economy and not the other way around.

“[Corbyn] gets the point that the primary function of the City of London is to allocate savers capital to the most effective investment schemes, and he says it’s not doing that at the moment.”

Of course, in opposition, Corbyn would not be able to put any of these plans into force, but Anderson notes Chancellor George Osborne has never been slow to incorporate the most popular ideas of his rivals into Conservative policy.

Most recently, Osborne seized upon Miliband’s proposal to ban non-dom status, putting it at the centre of his July Budget.

“However extreme these ideas are, what we have seen is a tendency from those in government to steal some of the most popular ideas,” Anderson says.

“Since the election George Osborne has taken huge amounts from Labour for the Budget, so the backdrop of a left leaning Labour front bench doesn’t necessarily mean that all of those ideas will end up on the cutting room floor.”

Mark Sands is politics reporter for Money Marketing



Corbyn backs flexible state pension age

Labour leadership favourite Jeremy Corbyn has pledged to introduce a flexible state pension age in the UK to address concerns the existing rules could create a “two-tier” system. Writing in today’s Daily Telegraph, Corbyn warns current increases in the pension age are unfair on workers with physically demanding jobs. The Islington North MP calls for […]


Budget: Labour backs personal allowance reforms

Labour interim leader Harriet Harman has backed Chancellor George Osborne’s plans to cut taxes for working people but cautioned that Britons will still be worse off. Responding to Osborne’s Summer Budget today, Harman said Labour would support the Chancellor in his efforts to raise the personal allowance to £11,000 and increase the 40p threshold to […]


Labour pension freedoms report pushed to end of 2015

An independent report into the pension freedoms commissioned by Labour before the general election will not be published until the end of 2015. The findings of the pensions market study, being carried out by Cass Business School professor David Blake, were initially due to be unveiled in the summer. However, Blake now says the report […]


Labour: 45p tax rate cut would be ‘crass and unjust’

Shadow chancellor Chris Leslie has warned any reductions in taxes for the richest would represent “gross irresponsibility and unfairness”. Speaking earlier today at KPMG, the Labour MP warned Chancellor George Osborne against slashing the top rate of tax from 45p to 40p ahead of the 8 July Budget. He said: “George Osborne has form when […]

The Downsizing Delusion: Why relying exclusively on your home to fund your retirement may end in tears

By Steve Webb, director of policy The British obsession with homeownership can have dangerous consequences. A recent survey by Barings¹ found that up to three million people of working age were planning to rely wholly on the value of their home to fund their retirement. We are not talking about people investing in buy-to-let or […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 5 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. In next week’s instalment, we’ll be looking at what Lenin rising from his mausoleum, eating David Cameron’s brains and becoming Supreme Zombie Chairman of Britain would mean for financial services.

    “From each according to his ability – to each according to his brrraaaaiiinnnsss.”

  2. The Right Honorable Member for Islington North has come up with a special brand of moronomics that will exacerbate housing supply still further through discouraging the private rented sector. Excellent work.

  3. At least the whole thing will be thought through, contrasting with the off the hoof budget and pension reforms of Mr Osborne. Just saying .

  4. This is the same person who wants to negotiate away the Falkland Isles, says the IRA are an OK organisation, wants to scrap our nuclear deterrent. If he gets in we as a nation will be seen as weak and defenceless. Renationalising power and railways what next, who will want to invest in UK when the Labour Government may decide to renationalise there investment? We would be better off with the Monster Raving Loony Party. He will probably have a coalition with ISIS. If he is labour leader and the unions get him into power God help us all

  5. He has no more chance of forming the next government than me (or, as Sascha so eloquently puts it, Lenin). If he does get in, the party will rapidly rewrite its electoral rules and vote him out again next year.

Leave a comment