View more on these topics

We need to talk

Since the FSA issued its risk and suitability paper, it is clear that some see risk and suitability a bit like a mathematical proof – there is only one correct answer. It is like an expansion of the efficient frontier graph where the object is to select an asset allocation that plops it right on the curve.

For me, risk is the central conversation where investment forms part of the financial plan. Filling questionnaires or determining capacity leaves too many aspects uncovered. I know this makes online advice problematic but that should not block us moving towards a more effective process.

I had a client who registered as an aggressive investor despite having only six years to retirement. His bullishness was more a reflection of his impatient personality than his wish to take benefits in six years. By having a dialogue with him, we arrived at a more appropriate risk profile, so when I see major providers launch questionnaires as if they are the risk equivalent of a silver bullet I despair.

This is part of a trend to try to automate the advice process, reducing the need for the adviser and the risk or possibility of miselling.

This has one major flaw, if the client’s circumstances and preferences do not fit the matrix, then the process fails or it compromises. This is a problem irrespective of client type but is magnified when the client is a couple and not an individual.

I am certain that disciples of “software can do anything” will reject my concerns but they are prepared to deliver advice that is closest to someone’s needs and not aligned with their needs. This is very similar to transactional models where advice is not provided or where advice is confused with product selection.

Once we pass to 2013, a common discussion with clients will be on the value that the process adds. This process could be one-to-one advice or using a web interface. Either way, the costs for an off-the-peg solution will need to be far less than a bespoke approach.

Software is a tool, not a one-for-one replacement of a professional adviser. It can sort and calculate but can it reflect the conflicting requirements of a couple and bring them to a solution that works for both? Watching how people react to questions or statements of their partners is not easily replicated electronically. The amount of effort expended on cutting corners on simplifying advice processes has been colossal. If one-tenth of this had been expended on behavioural research, basic financial education or due diligence on products, I suspect we would not have the current level of bills from the FSCS. Instead of looking for the easier way to do business, more effort could have been directed at providing high quality advice.

Advice and risk are difficult, which is why the risk conversation is so important. The regulator provided the catalyst to this discussion and it is important it keeps its focus and does not compromise with less than adequate approaches to the issue of risk and suitability.

Perhaps efficient frontier was not a truly analogous example maybe spot the ball is more appropriate. Don’t forget the random nature of that competition it was never one of skill.Defining risk profiles is more conversation than anything else.

Robert Reid is managing director of Syndaxi Chartered Financial Planners


Grim and bear it

This year promises a grim outlook for pension advice – workplace pension reform, the RDR and the stumbling UK economy. Depending on the size of an employer’s workforce, their obligations to notify their employees under the auto-enrolment reforms come into effect from September 1. Starting a month later is a four-year programme in which employees […]


“Fake Lord” jailed for mortgage fraud

Nine men have been jailed after police in Durham broke up a mortgage fraud. Michael Robinson, 44, from Murton, admitted one charge of conspiracy to defraud and two of conspiracy to convert criminal property when he appeared before Teesside Crown Court on Friday. He was jailed for six years three months. Eight other defendants pleaded guilty to similar offences and were jailed […]

Labour’s “shareholder activism” not the silver bullet, say lawyers

Labour proposals to give shareholders more say over the appointment of board members are unlikely to improve the quality of non-executive members or their ability to challenge company chiefs, according to law firm CMS Cameron McKenna. Yesterday, Shadow business secretary Chuka Umunna (pictured) called for a shake up of the way executives and non-executives are […]

Sesame poaches new technology chief from Avelo

Sesame Bankhall Group has appointed Avelo head of financial planning and wealth management James Stevenson as head of adviser technology. Stevenson will help develop the adviser technology which underpins Sesame’s new investment and adviser services, including design and implemen-tation of the group’s new client and practice management system being developed with software firm Iress. He […]

Inheritance tax when it is relevant

Neil Jones is Technical Support Manager with Canada Life’s ican Technical Services Team. Canada Life offers a range of wealth management solutions, including retirement income planning, estate planning and investment solutions from a choice of jurisdictions, including the UK, Isle of Man and Republic of Ireland. A trust can offer significant advantages when an individual is […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm