View more on these topics

We must resist the quick fix and fight our corner

No win-no fee, no fightno win. This is indicative of why the mortgage endowment misselling allegations are spiralling out of all proportion.

On the one hand, we see a company jumping on the bandwagon of a no win-no fee approach for complainants. On the other hand, our industry continues to capitulate on a culture of won&#39t fight, give them the compensation.

The culprits are the banks and insurance companies who consider that the cost of attempting to defend their position outweighs the cost of capitulation or, alternatively, they fear the wrath of the regulator or the ombudsman and the ensuing bad press.

Indeed, we recently read of a decision by a major insurance company upholding a complaint despite their disputing all five of the complainant&#39s points at issue.

Of course, they are under pressure from the FSA to speed up their handling of complaints or face fines. This directive apparently results from a recent appearance by insurance bosses before a Treasury select committee.

It is a pity these chief executives did not appear to have any answers other than for one of them to insist that they were confident of meeting the FSA deadline. Did any of them question why the ombudsman is taking between eight to 10 months to deal with each of these very same complaints? Is it not high time that the ombudsman was instructed to speed up?

This firm, while not currently involved in the mortgage market, did write some mortgage endowment business in the early 90s, most of it prior to our joining a network. We have to date had 15 complaints, all of which we can identify as being fuelled by the Consumers Association&#39s propaganda.

We have successfully defended 12 of these cases in house. The remaining three cases have been referred to the ombudsman, taking six, eight, and 10 months respectively to bring to a conclusion. None of these has been upheld.

Our defence was simple. We had an illustration and fact-find in every case. Not every illustration was a comparative illustration and not every fact-find was signed but these documents, together with our vigorous defence, were sufficient to prove that our record-keeping was adequate and the complainant&#39s memory defective. Nevertheless, it has cost us £1,800 in ombudsman fees for the privilege of winning.

What is most galling is that the 12 cases we have successfully defended in house are not reflected in any statistics. If all IFAs were required to submit such figures and all banks and insurance companies resisted the pressure for a quick fix and looked to defend their positions instead of capitulating, the likes of the Consumers&#39 Association and the bandwagon merchants would soon be silenced.

The pension review, flawed from inception, has proved to be a bigger scandal than the scandal it was supposed to address as some final-salary schemes are wound up and many other company schemes are under severe pressure.

IFAs have been robbed of millions of pounds in review and compensation costs. It must not be allowed to happen in the endowment arena and to ensure it cannot, our industry must be prepared to defend its position at all costs. It is time to stand up and be counted.

M Dickinson

David Kneale Financial Management,

Church Street,



BAM takes new direction

Baring Asset Management&#39s directional global bond trust is a unit trust set up to take advantage of the European directive Ucits III. Ucits III allows fund managers of onshore funds to use mixed asset classes and go short, whereas previously shorting was only available offshore without the safety net of FSA regulation. This fund&#39s unit […]

McGinn says only Abbey can drive wrap market

Abbey director of intermediaries Ambrose McGinn has hit out at suggestions that its wrap platform is struggling, claiming that its rivals do not have the experience and res-ources to make their propositions succeed. Dismissing the firm&#39s competitors as “pretenders”, McGinn says only Abbey has pockets deep enough – and the requisite critical mass – to […]

Pensions simplification will go ahead says Standard Life

Chancellor Gordon Brown is expected to proceed with pensions simplification after the National Audit Office has not fundamentally disagreed with the Government&#39s proposals, says Standard Life. It believes that given the NAO failed to significantly challenge the Inland Revenue&#39s numbers, the Chancellor will push ahead with the full package of reforms. Standard senior technical manager […]

Commentary Palatable menu

Over the coming weeks, I am sure that Money Marketing is going to carry some starkly contrasting views on the latest FSA proposals for a menu approach to disclosing the cost of advice. I think that good intermediaries should be giving three cheers while firms that offer an indifferent service should start to worry. The […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and thought leadership.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm