View more on these topics

UK equity funds ‘no better than FTSE tracker blend’


Small and mid-cap companies have driven the performance of UK active funds over the past five years, and these managers have done little to differentiate themselves from a blend of tracker funds, research by online wealth manager SCM Direct suggests.

The findings show that more than 100 per cent of the outperformance of funds in the UK All Companies sector was due to a bias to small and mid-cap stocks.

These outperforming funds had an average of 53 per cent in UK large caps, significantly lower than the 70 per cent of the UK stockmarket they represent, and 47 per cent invested in small and mid-caps, which account for 30 per cent of the UK market.

Effectively the performance of the UK All Companies sector was equivalent to an investment of 55 per cent in a FTSE 100 tracker and 45 per cent in a FTSE 250 tracker over the five years to the end of June, the research suggests.

Meanwhile, in the UK Equity Income sector 85 per cent of the outperformance of UK equity income funds over the past five years was due to a similar size bias.

SCM Direct co-founder Gina Miller says: “Our research is yet another nail in the coffin of the majority of active funds. Simply buying a combination of a FTSE 100 tracker with a FTSE 250 tracker, closely resembles the performance of a typical actively managed UK equities fund.”

She adds that using blended trackers would also save more than 80 per cent of the annual cost, based on a trackers charging approximately 0.15 per cent annually compared to a typical UK active fund charging approximately 0.85 per cent.

Miller also warns the bull run of small and mid-cap stocks has pushed prices up compared to large caps, which could affect fund managers’ returns in the UK All Companies sector.

She says: “Following the outperformance of small and mid-cap stocks, many of these stocks now command a premium valuation, compared to their larger peers.

“This may negatively impact the future returns of many active funds in these two major sectors.”

SCM Direct analysed all of the funds in the UK All Companies and UK Equity Income sectors, reviewing monthly data to ascertain the percentages invested in large caps, mid caps and small caps, as well as conducting an in-depth study into 179 funds in the two sectors with a five-year track record.

The wealth manager found that when the effects of the small and mid-cap bias was stripped out the outperformance for UK All Companies funds disappeared entirely and nearly disappears for UK Income funds, while just four of the funds beat the market cap adjusted returns of their fund over five years.



MM leader: The next big money spinner for providers

Non-advised drawdown is fast becoming the next big money spinner for providers left bereft of the wall of annuity cash to which they were accustomed. In typically humble terms, providers talk of non-advised drawdown being their “fastest selling solution ever”, with thousands of customers flocking to the products since they came to the market over […]


What would a Corbyn win mean for financial services?

With less than a week to go before voting closes in polls for Labour’s new leader, the potential implications of a victory for Jeremy Corbyn are beginning to crystalise. Corbyn only squeezed into the leadership context by achieving the required support of 36 MPs when enough backed his position to broaden the debate. But with […]


Blinded by China: Why advisers shouldn’t write off emerging markets

The pressure on emerging markets caused by the Chinese stockmarket crisis, on top of recent underperformance, is leading many investors to consider abandoning the once very attractive asset class. Assets rushing out of emerging markets rose to $1trn (£650bn) over the past year while, last week alone, following the worsening market data coming from China, […]

Lighthouse secures teachers’ union advice referral contract

National advice firm Lighthouse has agreed a deal to become the preferred adviser for members of the Association of Teachers and Lecturers. The contract will run for three years and means Lighthouse will provide savings, investments, pensions, protection and mortgage advice to up to 170,000 union members. These include headteachers, teachers, lecturers and support staff. […]


DB transfer shouldn’t be all-or-nothing

By Steve Webb, director of policy In my recent discussions with advisers, a hot topic has been the growing number of people interested in transferring their defined benefit pension rights into a defined contribution pension scheme. With many pension schemes offering eye-watering transfer values, this is likely to be an area of increasing interest. Yet […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 2 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. “Our research is yet another nail in the coffin of the majority of active funds. Simply buying a combination of a FTSE 100 tracker with a FTSE 250 tracker, closely resembles the performance of a typical actively managed UK equities fund.”

    Ah, so somebody was responsible for selecting the split between large cap and small & mid cap companies (which provided the outperformance) ….. that’ll be the active manager won’t it!

  2. I’m not sure what Gina is suggesting here. Did active managers randomly select those weights, or choose to be overweight in those areas without Gina’s benefit of hindsight? If the latter, then the tracker argument is weak – you had to have the asset allocation foresight, then the selection of trackers. Does she have evidence that a cohort of portfolio managers indeed made those calls and bought trackers accordingly? I’d like to see who did and their results if she wouldn’t mind sharing it. Is she suggesting that asset allocation calls are easy and hence you don’t need stock selection? You’d need a deeper analysis than is implied in the piece above to illustrate that.

    Finally, be careful with data. It is true that the FTSE 250 and Small cap indices have outperformed large cap (ie FTSE 100) for the last 5 years. But the FTSE 250 has been doing that since 1999. Hardly a revelation.

    It’s easy to appear smart after the fact.

Leave a comment