View more on these topics

Triple lock criticised for increasing intergenerational unfairness

Pension-pot-700.jpgA Centre for Policy Studies report claims former deputy primer minister Nick Clegg’s insistence on the state pension triple lock policy was a driver in increasing intergenerational unfairness.

The report says that, since 2010, welfare spending on pensioners has increased by 10 per cent in real terms but is down by 5 per cent for workers and children. It says that on a per-household basis welfare spending is up by 4 per cent per pensioner household and down by 10 per cent for children and people of working age.

The triple lock, introduced by the Conservative and Liberal Democrat coalition government, means guarantees that the basic state pension will rise by a minimum of either 2.5 per cent, the rate of inflation or average earnings growth, whichever is largest.

Following the snap election in June the Conservatives and DUP agreed to maintain the triple lock.

The CPS report says that if the state pension had been uprated in line with consumer price index inflation instead of the triple lock the Treasury would now be around £8.6bn a year better off.

CPS economic research head Daniel Mahoney says: “Nick Clegg’s insistence on the triple lock policy during the coalition negotiations has increased intergenerational unfairness and caused huge fiscal problems for the Government.”

Mahoney says: “Had the state pension’s purchasing power stayed the same since 2010, the Government could have implemented a series of growth-promoting tax cuts for all demographic and income groups, as well as giving additional funds to areas that require more resources – all the while being in a similar, if not better, fiscal position.”

He adds that the guarantee in the triple lock should be dropped to 1.5 per cent.

Mahoney says: “This would still be a triple lock but would guard the Treasury from additional fiscal burdens arising from a situation where inflation and earnings growth hover at around 2 per cent.”



Govt ducks the question on state pension triple lock

Prime Minister Theresa May and Chancellor Philip Hammond have both refused to commit to maintaining the state pension triple lock as the election campaign gets underway. The Daily Mail reports at a campaigning event in her Maidenhead constituency, May avoided giving a firm answer on whether the triple lock, which sees pensions rise by wages, […]


Labour backs Waspi and triple lock in pension manifesto

Labour has promised to give more support to Waspi women affected by increases in their state pension age in its “pensioner’s pledge card” published today. Labour Chancellor John McDonnell published the party’s promises today on his Twitter account. The pledges also include keeping the state pension triple lock until 2025, protecting the state pensions of overseas pensioners, and keeping […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 2 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Why not leave the Triple Lock alone and focus on replacing the Govt, Local Govt and EURO DB Schemes that are costing the tax payer a ‘fortune’ and no Commercial company can now afford these schemes, no matter how much profit they make.

    No chance, that is like asking turkeys to vote for Christmas, I suppose.

    No politician is in it for the people, only for the power and the glory and keeping their seat at the next election!

    • Yes Ted, but don’t forget their generous pensions that thy get for a minimal amount of work (yrs) and with that is the Frozen pension where 550,000 pensioners abroad , mostly in the Commonwealth, get no increases ever to their pension from the day that they leave or qualify if abroad already !

Leave a comment