View more on these topics

Treasury committee demands answers on FSCS levy reform


Treasury committee chairman Andrew Tyrie has challenged the FCA’s smaller business practitioner panel to provide solutions to rocketing adviser bills for the Financial Services Compensation Scheme.

Tyrie’s comments came after Citywide Financial Partners director Clinton Askew, who also chairs the FCA’s smaller business panel, said his own firm’s FSCS bill increased by 300 per cent this year.

He said: “We had [FSCS chief executive] Mark Neale in front of the panel in September, and our view at the time was that the FSCS was insurance cover priced without reference to the underlying risk.

“There is an opportunity to step back and begin to think more widely about how consumers can be protected in these sort of circumstances.

“There are some structural issues [with the FSCS]. One of the problems [FSCS chief executive] Mark Neale has is that he can’t make recoveries from professional indemnity insurers because their contracts specifically write out claims from the FSCS, so in a way there are mechanisms that could alleviate some of the problems for advisers.”

However, Tyrie challenged Askew to develop specific reform options for policymakers to consider.

He said: “We are hearing the moaning and we can be sympathetic, but what we need is to hear some answers. You don’t need to answer that now, but that’s what we’re in the market for.”

FCA practitioner panel chairman and HSBC UK and Europe chief executive Antonio Simoes said his panel has primarily focused on the broader cost of regulation.

He said: “As a panel we have not discussed the FSCS as much, what we have discussed is the overall cost.” He said this year’s 7.9 per cent increase in FCA costs is “unsustainable”

The comments come after FCA chairman John Griffith-Jones told MPs the regulator would put the cost of the FSCS to advisers at the centre of an upcoming review.



TSC chair Andrew Tyrie intervenes on challenger bank levy

Treasury select committee chairman Andrew Tyrie has written to the Prudential Regulation Authority urging it to reconsider a new tax that could hit challenger banks. In the Summer Budget the Chancellor announced a new 8 per cent charge on banks’ UK profits above £25m from, due to come into force from 2016. At the same […]

Andrew Tyrie Tory conf 2013.jpg

Tyrie demands MPC code of conduct overhaul

Treasury select committee chairman Andrew Tyrie has written to the Bank of England to demand a review of its code of conduct for monetary policy committee members. In a letter to Bank governor Mark Carney today, Tyrie says the appointment of Gertjan Vlieghe to the committee suggested the need for an overhaul. Vlieghe was appointed […]


MPs to probe ‘moving goalposts’ of state pension reform

The Work and Pensions committee is to follow its investigation of the retirement freedoms with a new inquiry into the state pension reforms. The committee says it is worried those close to retirement in particular may not understand the new system, having done most of their planning under the previous rules. It also raises concerns […]


MPs push for two-year FCA fee freeze

Three MPs have launched a motion in Parliament to call for a two-year freeze on FCA fee increases in a bid to improve access to advice. In an early day motion filed this morning, Labour MP Alan Meale, Conservative MP Peter Bottomley and Northern Ireland’s SDLP MP Mark Durkan argue any further increases in regulatory […]

Can you put a hat on?

By Sarah Scott, marketing consultant You might think the question in the title is a strange one. Perhaps even more so when you learn that it’s one of several asked as part of an assessment for Employment Support Allowance eligibility in the opening scenes of the 2016 film, ‘I, Daniel Blake’. Daniel is a carpenter […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 3 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. What a pathetic reflection on all those regulatory bodies and committees who are charged with coming up with suitable suggestions. The Consumer Panel, the Small Business Panel etc. etc. all failed to even make suggestions to the Regulator when requested to give some sort input concerning the vexed question of the FSCS levy.

    It rather does underline what most of us already know – that these taking shops are populated by disengaged do-gooders who are happy to accept a pretty reasonable stipend for doing bugger all.

  2. It’s really not that difficult. Use the FCA fines to meet the cost before they are syphoned to the Treasury or wherever they go.

    That way poor behaviour pays for poor behaviour/outcomes (not all FSCS claims are as a result of poor behaviour on the part of advisers).

  3. A risk-graded product levy (payable to the FSCS, a bit like VAT) wouldn’t be an overnight solution (as Mark Neale seems to be suggesting intermediaries as asking for) but such levies would surely accumulate gradually and offset costs to the adviser community.

    Product levies might well also render high risk products considerably more difficult to justify for those wishing to sell them and make consumers much more wary of buying into them.

    So that’s one solution (answer). Next ~

    Kick the FCA firmly up the backside to make it ask (as part of its RMA Returns process) and actually look at the responses to simple questions relating to whether or not firms are transacting any high risk types of business, what DD procedures they undertake to justify the sale of such products and ~ CRUCIALLY ~ do they have in place appropriate PII cover? The fact that the FCA just demands ever more data that it doesn’t bother actually to examine is SO typical of the many things fundamentally wrong with it and polite words cannot express my utter contempt for JG-J’s description of the purpose of demanding all this data as “pragmatic”.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm