View more on these topics

Trading body blows

Two of the financial services industry&#39s leading trade associations are involved in a running battle over a number of issues seriously affecting the IFA community.

The ABI represents 98 per cent of the insurance industry while Autif is the mouthpiece for the vast majority of unit trust and Oeic providers. In targeting financial services consumers, they are essentially vying for pieces of the same pie.

One commentator says: “Trade associations spend all their time trying to differentiate themselves from groups in the same sector.

“The ABI and Autif are roughly in the same market and are fighting for prominence in that market.”

Both the ABI and Autif deny any dispute exists, preferring to say they are simply debating issues in public and, in fact, the two organisations get along just fine.

ABI spokesman Malcolm Tarling says: “The ABI and Autif talk about a whole range of issues. We regularly have public debates. No two organisations are going to agree on everything 100 per cent of time but it would be wrongto say that there is anydegree of hostility between our associations.”

Autif director of communications Anne McMeehan says: “Constructive criticism is a good thing – no one will dispute that. Our differencesover individual issues are not indicative of the relationship between Autif and the ABI.”

But looking at recent comments from outgoing Autif director general Philip Warland, one cannot help but come away with a different impression.

In a speech two weeks ago, Warland said: “I was astonished to see the comments of my opposite number at the ABI the other day, when Mary Francis apparently said to the economic secretary that the Government should stop interfering in product manufacture and let the industry get on with it.

“If her industry had a 10-year pristine record, then she might have a point.

“I, too, am a believer in the Government only interfering where it is strictly necessary for it to do so but it is difficult to think of a clearer public policy case for Government intervention than in the area of pensions where so much public confidence has been lost.”

Francis took an aggressive stance in her challenge to Treasury economic secretary Melanie Johnson when she said the Government must remove itself from the design of financial products.

In a speech at the Labour Conference in Brighton, Francis said: “The lesson of the Millennium Dome is that Governments are not experts at designing and selling and marketing.

“Yet our Government has got pretty deeply into designing financial products – Isas, IPAs and stakeholders.

“Governments too often succumb to complexity and overdesign, especially where tax is concerned. The lesson for the Government is now to stand back and let the ind-ustry take forward the task of designing simple, access-ible products.”

Tarling points out that Francis also said Government intervention in the past had been a good thing.

He maintains Government involvement has been beneficial and has served as a necessary spur to the industry.

But only a year ago, Warland slammed Cat standards as being “breathtakingly irresponsible”. Now he appearsto have reversed his stance and is supportive of Government standards.

But since then his tone towards Government initiatives has been much more conciliatory, and perhaps not without reason.

The latest twists to the argument come hot on the heels of the Government&#39s proposals for Individual Pension Accounts.

IPAs have been designed to provide unit trust managers with greater access to the pension market by giving them tax breaks with a concession on stamp duty reserve tax.

But while the Government has tried to give Autif members an equal footing with insurers in the market, the ABI has criticised the taxconcession on IPAs, saying it creates an uneven playing field. Autif says the move does not go far enough and wants more.

McMeehan says: “This is a very competitive industry. Such is the desire to protect market share, the entry that might be deemed imminent by the unit trust industry into the pension industry might be a cause of concern to some.”

The IPA regulations are yet to be finalised. Clearly, the ABI wants changes to be made and, just as evidently, Autif is going to dig in its heels, resist any changes and, more likely, lobby for more concessions.

Tarling says: “We believe there should be a level playing field. We are not asking for preferential terms. We do not want to see one form of savings vehicle having an advantage over another.”

Another bone of contention has been the ABI&#39s Savings and Long Term Risk initiative launched under the Raising Standards banner. The move is an attempt to improve standards across the insurance industry but has received mixed reviews from industry observers and some product providers.

While applauding the motivation behind Saltr, Autif has been unwilling to endorse the initiative publicly.

McMeehan says this is because, while the association represents the interests of companies supporting Saltr and will help them take the steps towards acquiring accreditation through it, there are also Autif members which are firmly opposed to the idea.

There is not necessarily anything wrong with the two trade associations airing differences of opinion in public. For members, it is a sign of them acting vigorously on their behalf.

It also forces the Government to sit up and listen to the concerns of the industry.

And it provides the rest of the industry with ongoing entertainment. The ball is now in Francis&#39 court. What will she come up with next?


Fairplay and Crowe launch cash life assurance plan

Fairplay Insurance Services and Crowe Life are launching a life assurance product aimed at people who do not have a bank account. The life assurance plan can be paid monthly in cash through any Post Office in the UK, as well as annually by cheque or postal order. Fairplay managing director Chris Jordan says: “There […]

M&G expands offshore

M&G, the UK&#39s largest unit trust manager, is to expand offshore by launching a new fund range. The M&G Offshore Fund Range makes six of its most popular unit trust funds available offshore as from November 13. M&G director of group product development Bill Vasilieff says: “All six offshore funds act as feeder funds into […]

Pump up pension volume

Traded endowment policies are an ideal instrument to accumulate capital for particular financial needs at a specific date in the future. Pension funds and retirement investment are some of the many financial planning uses for Teps.Our research shows 33 per cent of policy sales relate to saving for retirement. The market in Teps has grown […]

AITC shelves supermartto link with Transact

The AITC has confirmed it is shelving plans to develop its own fund supermarket and will endorse the consolidated portfolio management service Transact.The Transact service is designed exclusively for IFAs and acts as a back office for the adviser. Oeics, unit trusts, investment trusts, Peps, Isas and personal pensions can be transacted through the service […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm