View more on these topics

Trade marks

This week, I would like to focus on the relatively complex taper relief trap for company owners who make investments through their company. In considering the relative merits of investment bonds and collectives as corporate investments, I have referred to the negative impact on business assets taper relief that such investments can have. It is time to look at how the rules can operate.

Where a company has cash which will not be needed in the short to medium term, there may be an opportunity to consider its investment.

Subject to investment considerations and assuming the underlying funds reflect the investor&#39s attitude to risk and requirements for income and growth, an asset-backed investment bond can offer tax advantages. As a non-income-producing asset, it does not provide a regular stream of taxable income and is relatively easy to administer. As it is asset-backed, it is likely to produce growth over the medium to long term and control can be exercised over the date of encashment and time of the tax charge.

But as corporate investors receive no credit for tax suffered by the life fund on income and gains when determining tax due on any chargeable event gains arising under UK bonds, these will not be appropriate from a tax standpoint. Offshore bonds offer more tax-efficiency.

Will such an investment have any impact on business assets taper relief? Two questions need to be asked. Will the investment have a substantial effect on the company&#39s activities? Will it begin to carry on a business of holding investments? I will look at these in turn.

In broad terms, business assets taper relief is available for the appropriate period of ownership on all shareholdings in unquoted trading companies and all employee shareholdings in quoted trading companies in which they work. Shareholdings held by outside investors in quoted trading companies which carry at least 5 per cent of the voting rights also qualify.

For periods of ownership from April 6, 1998 to April 5, 2000, the test for shares is more restrictive but, as with the test for shares owned after April 5, 2000, a common theme is that the company must be trading. To complicate matters, from April 6, 2000, employees who own shares in a non-trading company in which they work can benefit from business assets taper relief provided that, broadly speaking, they do not own more than 10 per cent of the shares in the company.

Disregarding certain employees who hold shares in a non-trading company, for full business assets taper relief to be available, it is vital that the company is a trading company. This is defined in paragraph 22 of schedule A1 of the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992. A trade is anything which is a trade for income tax purposes and includes a profession or vocation. It must be conducted on a commercial basis with a view to the realisation of profits.

A trading company is either a company existing wholly for the purpose of carrying on one or more trades or a company that would fall within that definition apart from any purposes capable of having no substantial effect on the extent of the company&#39s activities.

The Inland Revenue&#39s June 2001 tax bulletin gives guidance as to the meaning of “wholly” as follows: “In the context of the definition of a trading company, we would take &#39wholly&#39 to mean that the company had no purpose other than to trade. Wholly therefore means solely. Whether something is wholly for a trading purpose can only be considered in light of the requirements of the company&#39s trade. One common situation is where a company sets aside funds and receives investment income. The fact that investment income is generated does not automatically lead to the conclusion that a company&#39s purpose is not wholly trading.

“Whether the generation of income from investments is or is not evidence of a non-trading purpose must ultimately depend on the nature of the company&#39s trade and whether the holding of the investment is closely related to the conduct of that trade. If it can be shown that holding any investment is integral to the conduct of the trade or is a short-term lodgement of surplus funds held to meet demonstrable trading liabilities, this is unlikely to be taken as evidence of non-trading purposes. For example, if a company has surplus funds which it intends to use for an expansion of the trading business in the near future, and it invests these in equities in the short term, it may be that the company&#39s purpose continues to be wholly trading during the period those equities are held.”

If the purpose of the investment is to realise further cash that can be used to meet the company&#39s trading requirements, including future expansion, it should not be regarded as having a substantial effect on its activities. What if the investment is not made to fund such a requirement? It is necessary to determine if the investment has a substantial effect on the company&#39s activities.

The Revenue adopts a 20 per cent test which is explained by the bulletin: “The word substantial is used…to provide some flexibility in interpreting a section without opening the door to widespread abuse of a relieving provision. We consider that substantial here means more than 20 per cent. It is therefore necessary to consider what should form the basis for measuring whether a company&#39s non-trading purposes are capable of having a substantial effect. We consider this will vary according to the facts in each case but some or all of the following might be taken into account in reviewing a particular company&#39s status.” The Revenue lists three measures:

Turnover receivable from non-trading activities.

The company&#39s asset base.

Expenses incurred by or time spent by officers and employees in undertaking its activities.

The Revenue has confirmed to us that cash is included in an asset base test so falling foul of the test cannot be avoided by leaving funds on deposit.


Independent view

The industry has been asking itself a lot of questions recently. As the Sandler consultation period closes, the ever-topical issues surrounding IFA remuneration have been given a good airing. But have we come up with any answers? My opinion (and one which is widely reflected in Charcol&#39s business strategy) is that there is, and should […]

Norwich Union cuts rate on equity release loans

Norwich Union is reducing the interest rate on its equity release loans in line with the recent fall in long term interest rates.The new rate on NU’s Flexible Cash Release plan is 7.79 per cent from 8.25 per cent. The rate for its Flexible Income Release plan is now 7.94 per cent from 8.4 per […]

Money Marketing this week relaunches…

Money Marketing this week relaunches the Money Marketing Focus surveys to concentrate on comment and analysis on product issues. Money Marketing Focus lists new pension, protection, investment and mortgage products launched each month with a comprehensive overview of each market sector. The Focus will look in depth at a major product issue. This month we […]

Myners quits after taking Gartmore into top league

The man who paved the way for the Sandler review, Paul Myners, has stepped down from his role as Gartmore chairman after 16 years at the company. During an illustrious career at Gartmore, Myners saw the firm rise to become one of the UK&#39s top fund management businesses, with assets growing from £1.8bn in 1985 […]

A tough start for 2017 consensus trades

By Kacper Brzezniak Every year, starting around November, investment banks (and fund managers) begin to drip out their outlooks for currencies, rates, economies, you name it, for the following year. The consensus has been largely wrong for the past four or five years; those multiple rate hikes never came, the bond market is still alive […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm