View more on these topics

Top actuary in attack on commission

A 13-year old schoolboy has outperformed the UK&#39s top fund manager in a competition run by stock and shares website ADVFN.

Roy Nelson made a £108.81 on his £1,000 portfolio. The best-performing UK fund, the Axa ethical fund run by Stuart Fowler, returned 1.12 per cent between June 14 and July 2.

Steel giant Corus Group and gas exploration company Cairn Energy were two of Nelson&#39s successful stock picks.

Nelson, from Westbrook Hay School in Hemel Hempstead, Hertfordshire, was one of over 100 students from six schools who took part in this year&#39s ADVFN Schools Challenge. Each pupil had a notional £1,000 to invest in five UK-listed shares.

ADVFN chief executive officer Clem Chambers says the students learnt some valuable lessons about investing in the stockmarket, including how quickly they can make and lose money and that glamorous stocks such as BMW, Rolls Royce and football clubs are not necessarily the best performers.

The outgoing president of the Institute of Actuaries has attacked the commission structure and called for change.

In his valedictory address last week, Jeremy Goford identified a number of flawed structures in the UK financial services industry and commission was top of his list for change.

He suggested that real competition in financial services is to get intermediaries to sell a product, which increases commission to the ultimate detriment of the consumer.

Goford also criticised commission for being mismatched in timing with regular charging structures, causing annual management charges for regular savers to be too small at the outset of the contract and too big at the end.

He pointed to the fact that no commission is paid to help consumers use disposable income to pay off short-term debt on credit cards and personal loans, which leads to Citizens Advice Bureaux spending more than half their time trying to deal with the consequences of excessive personal borrowing.

Goford also believes there is confusion between financial products which carry guarantees and those where benefits are discretionary, which he says has been especially devastating in the pension area.

He believes employers must start communicating adequately to employees about what they can expect in the way of pensions, what is guaranteed and what is not and what will happen if the company fails or the stockmarket takes a sharp downturn.

He said: “The role of the actuarial profession is to speak out when we spot these flawed structures. Our responsibility is to research, inform and speak out so that those with the power to make changes understand the implications of those flawed structures and may mitigate or eliminate them if they so choose.”


Barclays wraps up deal for IFA sector

Barclays is setting up a wrap proposition for the IFA market that will allow advisers and investment managers access to its sharedealing service as well as its fund market. The service, which was originally being developed for the mass retail market but has now been extended to IFAs, allows advisers to wrap all their accounts […]

Provision priority

The Financial Ombudsman has concerns over reviewable premiums on critical-illness policies. What needs to be done to allay these concerns and what will be the effect on the market? McKie: Our plan offers five-yearly reviewable premiums where only the expectations of future morbidity experience can be reviewed. We appreciate the concerns that the FOS have […]

Credit Suisse roadshows target multi-managers

Credit Suisse Asset Manage-ment&#39s multi-manager team is marking its third anniversary by going on the road in Sept-ember to talk about multi-manager investing. Multi-manager services joint heads Gary Potter and Robert Burdett will be hosting roadshows throughout Sept-ember analysing performance, discussing the investment and market outlook and talking about which managers they think will be […]

Credit Agricole Asset Management – CA-Funds Global New Leaders

Type: Sicav Aim: Growth by investing globally in equities Minimum investment: £0.01 Investment split: 33.76% information technology, 18.16% consumer discretionary, 13.27 healthcare, 8.65% industrials, 7.35% energy, 6.99% telecom services, 2.51% financials, 1.5% utilities, 1.17% consumer staples, others & cash 6.43% Place of registration: Luxemburg Charges: Initial up to 4.5%, annual 1.6% Commission: Initial up to […]

A modern horror story

Every day a quick scan of the news reveals some new horror that will change the lives of those involved forever – the unlucky accident on the way to work, a tragic illness that cuts a young life short or the holiday accident that leaves more than just a scar to cope with. We barely […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment