View more on these topics

Tony Wickenden: Tax changes of the past providing a guide to the future

Tony Wickenden

For a recent round of presentations I was asked to look back 20 years at what I considered to be the key developments of relevance to the financial planning process in taxation and pensions. The broad reason for doing this was to see if the past could be used as any guide to the future.

My, how time flies. My journey down memory lane from its 1996 starting point reminded me of just what a “journey” we have been on.

So what did this time travel adventure reveal? Well, for both tax and pensions, the amount and pace of change has been relentless. The detail has also been impressive: pages and pages of legislation, regulation, reported litigation, observation and consultation.

And on the last point, by the way, the trend to consult before creating legislation is one to be applauded. It seems to be an embedded process now for the bigger and more complex areas of change, and that should increase the chances of better outcomes.

For me, the most fundamentally important development in tax (which will come as no surprise to regular readers of my column) is the effective ending of the market in aggressive tax avoidance schemes: those designed to be within the letter of the law while defeating the intent of legislation.

The development and success of “purposive interpretation” in litigation to help HM Revenue & Customs to victory was one started more than 20 years ago in standout cases like WT Ramsay Ltd v CIR [1981] and Furniss v Dawson [1984].

Clearly, HMRC was unhappy with leaving the application of this principle to the courts and needed to “up its game” in light of the financial pressures and increased public sector debt brought upon the Government as a result of the global crisis. As such, we have seen the relentless surge of targeted anti-avoidance provisions, even more (successful) litigation and, of course, the 2013 introduction of the potentially powerful (but to our knowledge as yet unused) general anti-abuse rule.

In the last three years, we have also seen the development of the accelerated payment notice and the accompanying (and continuing) expansion of the “universe” of schemes requiring a disclosure of tax avoidance scheme reference number. The next “frontier” for Dotas is inheritance tax, though it seems likely most schemes founded on financial products – for example, loan trusts and discounted gift trusts  – are to be spared.

All this has led to the pretty much complete drying up of any demand for aggressive avoidance schemes. The war has been won. And the boundaries will continue to be maintained through multi-faceted action, including, where necessary, international collaboration to combat large scale global profit shifting and tax base erosion.

Meanwhile, on inheritance tax, the big ticket highlights have to be:

  • The introduction of the transferable nil rate band in 2007, reducing the need for “use it or lose it” first death trust planning
  • The freezing of the nil rate band in 2009 and the radical change to trust taxation in March 2006 from which point we saw the end (or at least dramatically reduced use) of the flexible interest in possession trust as the trust of choice for IHT planning with retail investment products.
  • Other important tax developments include the reduction in the rate of corporation tax.

All these changes remind me how easy it is for advisers to miss or not spend the time understanding new legislation, especially in an ever-demanding and time-constrained world. If this becomes the norm, the cumulative effect of getting gradually out of date is that your risk of giving less-than-perfect advice increases.

But do the changes offer a guide to the future? Well, yes, actually. I do not see the financial pressure on “UK plc” reducing any time soon and it is this (as well as the political need to be seen to be doing something about it) that will continue to put high-cost tax relief and losses through tax planning under the microscope.

The result will be a continued focus on past-established norms in tax and pensions with, if necessary, radical but meaningful change in place to reduce tax outflow and increase tax inflow. Next week, pensions.

Tony Wickenden is joint managing director of Technical Connection. Follow him on Twitter @tecconn


FCA interior logo 620x430

Half of FCA staff unhappy with leadership

Half of the FCA’s staff are dissatisfied with the leadership at the regulator, according to a survey of employees. A Freedom of Information request from the Financial Times found that just 50 per cent of the more than 2,000 staff who took part in the survey are happy with the leaders. The survey was carried out […]

AFH Alan Hudson 700

AFH abandons Lighthouse takeover deal

IFA consolidator AFH Financial Group has pulled out of a potential deal to buy advice network Lighthouse Group saying it is “disappointed” by Lighthouse’s approach to the bid. In a scathing statement published today, AFH sys it does not now intend to make an offer for Lighthouse, after Lighthouse rejected a £17.4m takeover bid last […]


Should new advisers aim for level six qualification?

Ever since the RDR lifted the minimum qualification for advisers to QCF level four at the end of 2012 there has been talk of level six eventually becoming the new benchmark. The compulsory requirement has not changed since and some say any potential increase is a long way off. However, many advisers have still opted to […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm