Tony Mudd: Are supercharged business relief schemes worth it?

Advisers must tread carefully with arrangements that integrate life assurance and business relief

Any adviser operating in the estate planning market will be aware of gifts that are immediately exempt from inheritance tax. That is, outside the donor’s estate from the date of gift. However, what is required is just that – a gift.

Advisers will be equally aware of the value of business relief: investments in qualifying shares, including those on the Alternative Investment Market, that are broadly exempt once held for two years.

Of course, where funds have come from previously qualifying assets – say, the sale of a business – they may be immediately exempt, having already surpassed the two-year qualifying period. However, where new monies are invested in business relief qualifying shares, funds will not be exempt until they have been held for two years.

What exactly qualifies for business property relief?

Perhaps in recognition of this, there are now a plethora of “supercharged” business relief arrangements with integrated life cover that will pay out a sum equal to 40 per cent of the initial investment.

In this way, should the investor fail to survive two years, the sum assured will pay out a sum equal to the IHT that will become payable. In simple terms, these supercharged business relief investments are effectively exempt from day one.

This can be an ideal solution – and the value of simplicity should not be underestimated.

However, an adviser should not overvalue simplicity either and while these can represent excellent estate planning vehicles, they are not a panacea solution.

Clearly, the life assurance integrated within the business relief arrangement needs to be paid for.

The cost varies with provider but is broadly taken by an increase in the annual management charge.

So before looking at this area, advisers should first assess the true value – specifically, the need for life assurance. There are two important considerations here:

  • While the average age of business relief investors varies, according to information provided by promoters of schemes, between late 70s and early 80s, life expectancy will comfortably exceed two years for these ages. The increased AMC will, in many cases, wipe out the first two-year returns;
  • If the investor is married or in a civil partnership and the business relief asset is to be gifted to the spouse or civil partner, then only one of them has to survive for the two-year period. So does the need for cover exist?

We then need to look at the value from a different perspective. Does the cost of the cover, represented by increased AMCs, deliver value for money when considering viable alternatives? In other words, could the life cover be purchased separately from the business relief provider?

Tony Wickenden: Is IHT in line for a shake up?

In reality, this is not a nice-to-have. Under Mifid II rules, when an adviser recommends “bundled” products, which this clearly is, they are required to tell the client whether it is possible to buy different components separately and must provide information on the costs and charges of each component.

There are providers that offer two-year term policies and some, unsurprisingly, are designed specifically to run alongside the business relief investments. Where a potential investor has a spouse or civil partner, a second death two-year term assurance policy will invariably be cheaper than the provider’s increased AMC costs.

Whether premiums are competitive against AMCs where there is not a spouse or civil partner will depend on the age and health of the investor. Irrespective of this, though, consideration needs to be part of the advice process.

Tony Mudd: The critical reviews being missed by advisers

I have heard it argued that integrating life assurance with business relief is not something HM Revenue & Customs will like and is another potential nail in its coffin.

This is not an argument I have ever bought, on the basis that HMRC gets its money if the client dies within two years either way.

What is clear to me, however, is that while there is absolutely a place for integrated business relief – which for the right client offers a simple, good-value solution – it is imperative advisers offer viable alternatives or discount them as part of the advice process.

Tony Müdd is the divisional director for development and technical consultancy at St James’s Place



Quilter director Porteous exits business

Quilter retail customer solutions director John Porteous has left the company just over a year from when he took on the role. Porteous (pictured) joined Quilter in September 2017, after two and a half years at national advice firm Towry. Towry was acquired by Tilney in April 2016 and Porteous was subsequently appointed head of […]


Advice firm linked to collapsed DFM goes into liquidation

An advice firm with ties to collapsed discretionary fund manager Greyfriars Asset Management has gone into liquidation. Consumer Wealth based in Gateshead went into voluntary liquidation on 14 January with RSM administering the wind up. It has 13 Financial Ombudsman Service complaints against it dating from 1 April 2018 to the end of December 2018. One […]

JP Morgan takes stake in pensions technology company

JP Morgan has taken a minority equity stake in workplace pensions and technology company Smart Pensions. The investment comes as part of a new funding round for the company, which has now raised £50m. JP Morgan global head of retirement solutions Anne Lester will take a non-executive seat on Smart’s board. The move follows Legal […]


State pension court showdown set for summer

A judicial review about changes to the state pension age for millions of women born in the 1950s will take place from 5 to 6 June. The Department for Work and Pensions has confirmed that last November’s decision by the High Court to grant permission for a judicial review will go ahead in the summer. […]


Investment research and our Tactical Asset Allocation process

David Shairp, Head of Research at the Prudential Portfolio Management Group (PPMG), investigates the range of factors that multi- asset investors use to derive market insights and views that inform portfolio decisions. These would typically include valuation, macro factors, and behavioural or market timing factors. Many investors usually separate strategic and tactical asset allocation decisions. […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and thought leadership.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm