View more on these topics

Tom Selby: The pension projects held back by Brexit

Taking a look at the potential casualties of an EU exit

Fans of interminably dull Twitter debates will have been relieved to learn the process of the UK extricating itself from the European Union could drag on until 31 October. Whoever picked Hallowe’en as the deadline for Brexit clearly has a sense of humour.

But the “flextension” agreed between the EU and UK prime minister Theresa May could prove a nightmare for retirement policy. Even in normal times, pensions have to battle with other public policy areas for legislative attention, and at the moment that is at a premium.

Until recently, the Department for Work and Pensions was holding out faint hopes of getting a pensions bill through the House of Commons. That now seems as likely as me being called up to replace Harry Kane.

This is the vehicle that will house Guy Opperman’s legacy as pensions minister – a legacy which, politics-depending, may never see the light of day.

So here, in no particular order, are the pensions casualties of Brexit.

Pensions dashboards
Pensions dashboards are set to become a reality later this year on a voluntary basis, although the DWP expects it to take three to four years for the majority of pensions details to be made available to savers. A key part of making dashboards useful and credible will be mandating that all schemes provide information.

While modern providers that are net receivers of pension transfers will have both the capability and incentive to offer up data voluntarily, other providers – particularly those administering older-style life policies – are likely to drag their feet.

Legislation is therefore crucial if dashboards are to provide a genuinely useful service to savers.

Collective defined contribution schemes
The DWP has given enthusiastic backing to CDCs – plans designed to offer a halfway house between defined benefit, where the sponsor takes on all the risk, and defined contribution, where the risk is entirely on the member.

The CDC design still leaves those investment risks on the shoulders of savers, although they are shared across the entire membership rather than being borne individually. Advocates of CDC point to the potential for reduced volatility this brings, although members will have to sacrifice flexibility and choice.

While demand for CDC appears relatively muted across the private sector, the fact Royal Mail is keen to adopt the structure for its 140,000 UK staff means getting the legislation passed is a key priority for the DWP.

DB consolidation
The government wants to bring forward legislation to allow DB “superfunds” to drive consolidation of sub-scale schemes. Although DB consolidation is possible, the DWP believes legislation is needed to ensure potential cost savings are maximised and members’ interests remain at the fore.

Pressure in this area has been ratcheted up by the failures of some pretty high-profile scheme sponsors – most notably BHS – and subsequent demand for action by the influential work and pensions committee.

The DWP has already committed to ensuring members of superfunds have equal protections to members of other DB schemes and addressing risks around the loss of employer covenant. All of this will require new legislation.

Midlife MOTs
The idea of midlife MOTs is simple – by requiring employers to facilitate a financial check-up for employees, the government hopes more people will be kicked into action and take greater responsibility for their financial futures.

There is debate about the point in time this intervention should happen. While the DWP suggests 45 might be the right age, there is an argument for ensuring people are given this nudge earlier so good financial habits are ingrained from a younger age. But without legislation, there is no guarantee employers with various competing priorities will offer midlife MOTs to their staff.

Pension scams
The government is still waiting for legislative time to get two important pension scams interventions on to the statute book.

While the cold-calling ban introduced in January was a welcome step, measures to make it easier for schemes to block suspect transfers and harder for scammers to establish dodgy schemes in the first place remain in the stocks. These are vital consumer protections and have already been delayed for too long.

Some of these ideas may well be pulped in the fullness of time. Others will survive. But all are currently stuck in the legislative nether zone created by Brexit.

Tom Selby is senior analyst at AJ Bell



Auditors at collapsed mini-bond firm questioned as compensation looms

Accountants and lawyers are among at least 30 people asked to hand over information about collapsed mini-bond provider London Capital & Finance, according to The Times. Before its collapse at the end of January, £237m had been invested in LCF by some 11,500 private investors. The firm had previously raised flags with the FCA for […]


How to become a financial adviser: diplomas, degrees and workplaces

Information on how to become a financial adviser is sparse. Money Marketing speaks to advisers about what the requirements really are and how best to meet them. Speaking to financial advisers and planners today, each will have a unique and varied story about how they entered the profession. There are more than a handful of pathways […]


Tony Mudd: Advisers are stifling protection innovation

The biggest reason new concepts are not being brought to market is a lack of confidence that advisers will change their behaviour. Having started life in the financial services industry as a clerk for one of the largest life assurance companies in the UK, protection has always been my first love. Unfortunately, it only takes […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Why should pension projects be any different? Everything is being held up by b….y Brexit.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm