View more on these topics

Threadneedle fuses bonds with equities



Type: Unit trust

Aim: Growth and income by investing in Threadneedle funds

Minimum investment: Lump sum £2,000

Investment split: Bonds 75%, equities 25%

Yield: 4.27%

Isa link: Yes

Pep transfers: Yes

Charges: Initial 3.75%, annual 0.25%

Commission: Initial 3%, renewal 0.5%

Tel: 0800 06840005

The panel: Bruce Bulgin, partner, Chadney Bulgin,
Alan Lakey, partner, Highclere Financial Services,
Philip Milton, managing director, Philip J Milton & Co.

Suitability to market 4.4

Investment strategy 5.4

Past performance 6.0

Company&#39s reputation 8.4

Charges 4.4

Commission 6.0

Product literature 5.0

The Threadneedle defensive bond and equity fund that consists of a defensively managed portfolio of funds managed by Threadneedle Investments. It will invest mainly in bonds, with a small percentage in equities.

Looking at the market suitability of the fund Lakey says: “It is a marketing-driven product aimed at the cautious market.” Bulgin says:: “It is another lowish risk income or growth fund with a small amount of equity exposure.”

Milton says: “At the present time, with low interest rates creating a relatively high risk premium for products backed to a large degree by government bonds. I would say that this type of product is not really suitable in the current market at all. As investment advisers, we are of the opinion that yields are at an all time high at the moment and that with the present level of management buy backs, there is considerable value in shares and that future levels of the UK stockmarket should improve.”

Identifying the type of client the fund could suit Milton says: “It is important to consider the current economic situation and the levels of interest rates at present. Although the product is deemed low risk, as an adviser I would suggest that this is probability not the case. Consequently I would not recommend this as an investment for clients at all.”

Bulgin says: “Relatively cautious income seeking investor. It is also for growth investor using reinvested income to boost growth.” Lakey says: “One who has been scared by recent market falls. This looks like a direct sales force product rather than something that would appeal to an independent adviser.”

Assessing the fund&#39s marketing potential Bulgin says: “There are some possibilities for direct mail but this is a crowded sector so opportunities are limited.” Lakey says: “None for me. However, I can envisage the bucket shop brigade pushing the defensive concept.” Milton says: “I would not propose to market this product in any way at the present time.”

Highlighting the main useful features and strong points of the product, Lakey says: “The low equity content is a major focus, although the astute may be returning to equities. The 4.27 per cent yield will also appeal within an Isa.” Bulgin says: “It is useful to combine a range of bonds with a small equity underpin. Most of Threadneedle&#39s underlying bond funds are top performers in their sectors.”

Milton says: “The ability to use the fund for Pep and Isa transfers and the high proportion of UK bonds and fixed interest securities which provides extra security of capital. There is also the ability to gain exposure to both UK and international investment markets as well as fixed interest investments.”

Evaluating the fund&#39s investment strategy Lakey says: “It is structured around the defensive nature of bonds and fits the current mood. However, following the fad is never as profitable as anticipating it.” Bulgin says: “It appears entirely sound for the type of fund and its objectives.”
Milton says: “Our view of an investment strategy based largely on UK corporates and Government bonds is that this is a high-risk strategy, despite being marketed as lower risk. The yields from such a strategy can be equalled by yields currently available through investment into equities. The risk in the investment is largely dependent on the type of bonds that comprise the majority of the bond holdings.”

Considering the fund&#39s drawbacks Milton says: “The company is well established and has a strong market presence in the market sectors of investment and pensions and I have no concerns on using certain of the company&#39s products as such.” Lakey mentions the generally below average performance of Threadneedle funds. Bulgin says: “The fact that it&#39s neither a bond fund nor an equity fund could be considered a disadvantage.”

Turning to the company&#39s reputation Lakey thinks it is generally well thought of and believes its image is improving. Bulgin says: “Threadneedle has a strong reputation for its bond funds, many of which are top performers in their sectors.” Milton says: “The company is well established and has a strong market presence in investment and pensions. I have no concerns about using some of the company&#39s products.”

Moving to Threadneedle&#39s investment past performance record Milton says: “Having looked at various past performance tables, I was impressed by the appearance of the emerging markets bond, the dollar bond and the American growth fund which appear in Standard & Poor&#39s top 10 funds over the last five years. The funds are also four-star rated which is encouraging.” Bulgin says: “A number of Threadneedle&#39s bond funds are Standard & Poor&#39s AA and AAA rated, as are the UK equity funds.” Lakey says: “Two or three funds are standout performers, such as the cash fund. But others, like the European bond fund, are struggling.”

Identifying which products could provide the main competition, Lakey says: “In the hybrid bond and equity sector, Jupiter high income and Edinburgh monthly income.” Bulgin says: “Henderson&#39s managed income fund has a similar make-up and allows the investor to select levels of income.” Milton says: “More direct stock exchange linked investments such as Isas and fund of funds. Also, if proposing the use of bonds as an investment, defensively managed insurance bonds.”

Assessing the charges Milton says: “When compared to that of an Isa, I should say that the charges seem rather high.” Bulgin regards the charges as mid range to a little on the high side. Lakey thinks the charges appear on the high side for a fund limited to just one investment house.
The panel view the commission as the industry standard.

Casting an eye over the product literature, Bulgin says: “It could give much more detail, it&#39s really rather basic.” Lakey says: “The specific fund brochure is brief to the point of uselessness whereas the key features document is very detailed. Milton says: “Normally I would expect to see information on the underlying components and the security grading of the bonds concerned, something ore enlightening than no exposure to below investment grade bonds.”

Summing up, Lakey says: “It is unlikely to be a big hit with the discerning adviser but a good one for the postal boys. Bulgin concludes: “The fact that the underlying funds are so good means that many advisers may risk this fund.”


Hathaway enters unit trust market

Hathaway Investment Management has created its first unit trust, the MFM Hathaway unit trust in conjunction with Marlborough Fund Managers. Hathaway is an investment management firm which usually manages portfolios for private clients and institutions. It was formerly part of Birmingham-based solicitors Shakespeare and has been operating independently for the past two years. It will […]

FSA fines Abbey Life £1m for endowment misselling and other failings

The FSA has fined Abbey Life Assurance Company £1 million for mortgage endowment misselling and other deficiencies in compliance procedures and controls between 1995 and 1999.Between 42,000 and 46,000 mortgage endowment and 3,000 to 4,000 other customers may be due compensation currently estimated to be between £120m and £160m.Abbey Life closed to new business in […]

Cap Gemini Ernst & Young appoints financial services industry specialist

Cap Gemini Ernst & Young has appointed Martin Barber as vice president of its financial services team. Barber joins from KMPG Consulting where he held the position of partner within the financial services sector consulting group.He has 17 years experience of working within the financial services sector and specialises in business change programmes.

Legal & General – Global 100 Index Trust

Monday, 2 December 2002 Type: Unit trust Aim: Growth by tracking the global 100 index Minimum investment: Lump sum £500, monthly £25 Investment split: 100% tracking the global 100 index Isa link: Yes Pep transfers: Yes Charges: Annual 1% Commission: Lump sum initial 1% or 0.25% renewal, monthly 0.75% Tel: 020 7528 6773

Abe and Modi

India: Modi, reform and the oil price fall

Nearly 12 months since sweeping to power, prime minister Narendra Modi has overseen a significant turnaround in India, which is now on track to become one of the most pro-growth, pro-investment economies in Asia. While the market has rallied 48 per cent over the last year in response to Modi’s reform agenda, what is the potential for further progress?


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm