View more on these topics

Thousands of ‘bogus’ self-employed missing out on pensions


Up to 460,000 people across the UK could be “bogusly self-employed” and missing out on benefits such as auto-enrolment pensions and holiday pay as a result, Citizens Advice warns.

Office for National Statistics figures show the number of people self-employed has grown rapidly since 2008, from around 3.8 million to 4.5 million today.

But in a report published last week Citizens Advice says there has been a sharp increase in the number of people asking for help on determining their employment status.

The charity says it is “very difficult” for employees to determine whether they are legally considered as employed or self-employed without going to an employment tribunal.

It also warns there is increasing evidence of “rogue employers” who “intentionally exploit the vagueness of the rules in order to take people on as self-employed when they should be employed”.

A survey of 491 Citizens Advice users found 10.4 per cent believed they were self-employed but could actually be classified as employees. Scaled up to a national level, around 460,000 people nationwide may be bogusly self-employed, the charity says.

These workers are not entitled to benefits such as holiday pay, sick pay, parental leave and pension contributions through auto-enrolment.

Citizens Advice says there needs to be more support for employers and employees so people are not wrongly categorised and calls for an investigation into bogus self-employment akin to the Government’s work on zero hours contracts.

It adds the Treasury is losing an average of £300 per person wrongly categorised as self-employed, totaling around £300m annually.

Pension Playpen founder Henry Tapper says: “Employers need to be more careful about their workforce assessments when enrolling employers. The rules around eligibility are clearly laid out at The Pension Regulator’s website.

“Excluding self-employed contractors from auto-enrolment is a real problem for the self-employed who rely on one source of income from one employer. They are missing out on contributions to a workplace pension and are likely to have a claim against the ’employer’ at some stage in the future.

“We would rather see employer’s get this right first time than risk being the subject of claims from ‘workers’ – typically stirred up by ambulance chasers.”



Kim North: Will Govt advice review finally tie up RDR loose ends?

The recent Financial Advice Market Review issued by the FCA and the Treasury was an interesting summer read. Here we have yet another potential shake-up of the provision of financial advice. I commented when the RDR was introduced that, although the intention was good, millions of those in middle Britain would no longer be able […]

Phoenix Group 480 Wythall office Birmingham

Phoenix profits halve following Ignis sale

Closed book insurer Phoenix Life has seen pre-tax profits fall by 45 per cent in the first six months of the year following the sale of Ignis Asset Management. Pre-tax profit fell from £256m to £141m, while group operating profits fell by 49 per cent from £266m in the first half of 2014 to £135m […]


Mark Barnett: Investing in unquoted companies

I am frequently asked about my intentions towards the unquoted companies held within my portfolios. While these look pretty large in absolute terms, in proportionate terms we are talking about some quite small segments of between 4.5 per cent and 6.5 per cent of the portfolio. I remain of the view holding unquoted stocks in […]


‘Tsunami’ of new HMRC powers to tackle tax evasion

The Government has handed HM Revenue & Customs new powers to help it meet tax evasion prosecution targets. In the Summer Budget, the Treasury pledged a £750m investment in HMRC. The Chancellor said the cash would be used to pursue offshore trusts and would triple the number of evaders the tax office targets. Osborne said […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Really. Who would have guessed? I have already seen micro employers making their 2 or 3 employees self-employed, with the enthusiastic agreement of those affected.

    There are innumerable reasons why people don’t want AE and will it ever sink in to those in Westminster that if they sincerely with the un-pensioned to be pensioned the only fool proof solution is to achieve this through the State Pension. Even if this means raising taxes and instituting some kind of Sovereign Wealth fund or ring fencing the contributions.

    Perhaps some illustration of the Government not bailing them out if they end up living in penury might do wonders to encourage people to improve their prospects voluntarily. But first the Government should stop messing about with the rules. Compulsion is never kindly received as it is taken to be a tax – which AE is in fact. If you are going to tax people – at least be honest and call it a tax – and then don’t rely on private enterprise to do your work for you.

Leave a comment