View more on these topics

They think it&#39s all over…

“Already an endangered species due to market and regulatory pressures, the small IFA may now face extinction at the hands of the dominant service providers.” So concludes a report by consultant Cap Gemini Ernst & Young into the impact of the proposed changes to polarisation.

The research, based on consultation with industry executives, is at odds with the report commissioned by the FSA from London Economics, which concluded that “the IFA channel would not diminish significantly if multi-tied agents came into the market”.

The Cap Gemini Ernst & Young findings, published earlier this month, make grim reading. The report suggests independence may not be the best strategy for IFAs, who will see increased competition, and that smaller IFAs should look to multi-ties as an escape route. As smaller IFAs migrate, it predicts IFAs&#39 market share will shrink and the most successful IFAs will be those specialising at the upper end of the market.

On this basis, networks will be the main casualties of depolarisation. Smaller practices will need more than the regulatory support offered by the networks and will be driven into the bosom of providers.

Cap Gemini Ernst & Young vice-president Shaun Crawford says: “The current FSA proposals will result in a marketplace dominated by powerful providers linked together in multi-tie arrangements, only selling each other&#39s products.”

This bleak scenario is endorsed by some others in the industry. IFAP acting chief executive officer David Elms says: “It is incredibly bad news for IFAs. It is not just the networks but IFAs generally who will suffer if the proposals go ahead.”

However, many of the more war-weary in the industry counsel caution. Scottish Widows head of IFA sales development Robert Wyllie says: “It is easy to grab headlines but it is premature as the second stage of the FSA polarisation consultation has not even started yet. ” Consultation on the first phase of the polarisation review is currently under way, with consultation on the more wide-ranging phase two due to start soon.

But Crawford fears changes to the polarisation regime are driven by political considerations and are inevitable.

He says: “Elections are coming and the last thing the Government wants is for this to fail. It is more likely to be an immediate success if depolarisation is restricted to stakeholder and Isas.” If this goes smoothly, he believes it is inevitable for the Government to roll out further changes.

But IFAs – even the smaller of the species – are not yet willing to accept the status of dodos. Repeated announcements of their impending demise provoke little more than weary stoicism. Misys head of marketing Andrew Bedford says: “We have been hearing a lot about the extinction of the smaller IFA for the last 10 years.”

Likewise, Aifa director general Paul Smee says: “Small IFAs have been written off many times before and they have proved to be extremely resilient. It is dangerous for consultants to decide for themselves what a multi-tie is and then draw conclusions from that when they do not really know the geography at all.”

DBS spokeswoman Sue Lewis points out that the ABI business figures released at the end of last year show IFAs took 69 per cent of new life, pension and collective investment business.

These results were achieved without multimillionpound marketing spends, massive client banks or big branch networks.

IFAs are proud to point out that consumers have consistently voted with their feet. Bedford says: “People are beginning to value advice and that is why the independent sector will continue to get bigger.”

Smee says: “Changes are driven by the market. Without the view of the investor, this research can only be an incomplete piece of work.”

Wyllie puts it another way. “Would consumers suddenly no longer find independent advice attractive after depolarisation?” he asks.

The only finding of the research that Bedford is willing to endorse is the necessity of targeting attention at the upper end of the market. “IFAs do have to move more into investments and the corporate market,” he says.

But he adds that, as many smaller IFAs have low overheads, they can profitably sell Isas, for example, and may not need to reconsider their market.

With 10,000 IFAs out of a total of around 25,000 belonging to networks, how do they react to the predicted exodus of smaller firms? Again, Bedford says: “I cannot see any reason for a fundamental shift. Our members are advisers rather than product sellers.”

There is fighting talk from Lewis, too. She says: “Depolarisation is yet another area of competition, such as telephone and internet services, which IFAs will deal with successfully as they have done before.”

What about the life offices predicted to soak up the ailing IFAs? Clerical Medical pensions strategy manager Nigel Stammers agrees some providers would be looking to buy out some of the smaller IFAs if the stage two proposals go ahead. He says multi-ties would be an easy way for the beleaguered small IFA to remain in business.

But he adds: “Phase one was important to secure supply for stakeholder. Going any further is not warranted. We have a balanced distribution strategy and see no reason to rush into any changes.”

Framlington group marketing director Craig Walton says: “The changes were intended to benefit consumers but the Government is now in danger of throwing out the baby with the bath water.”

He believes good IFAs will continue to thrive, even though there will be new pressures, and thinks there will be no changes to the traditional network structure in the short term.

But Walton does admit the new regime would offer attractive business opportunities. “Ending polarisation will allow us wider distribution. The life houses will be able to add our products to their own line-up,” he says.

In the clouds that surround the debate on polarisation, Lewis sees silver linings. “Financial awareness is growing. The more discussion that takes place, the more that financial awareness develops. This can only work in the favour of the IFA,” she says.

Recommended

It&#39s the end of the road for the Man from the Pru

Prudential is axing its entire 1,400-strong direct salesforce, spelling the end for the traditional Man from the Pru. The salesforce, which once numbered 10,000, is being replaced by a face-to-face financial planning service of only 250 advisers for high-net-worth clients who earn more than £50,000 a year or who have at least £50,000 to invest. […]

Savills&#39 fee deal for IFAs who refer loan business

Savills Private Finance is offering to conduct mortgage business on behalf of IFAs who do not want the hassle of selling mortgages. Savills is asking advisers to refer mortgage clients to the company ins- tead of referring the business to tied agents. It will pay IFAs a percentage of the introducer fee it gets from […]

&#39Widen CGT to end unfair tax system&#39

The Government should extend the £7,200 capital gains tax exemption to all savings products because Isas have failed to extend saving, says Ernst & Young. The move would encourage more people to save than the overly complex Isa regime, E&Y argues in its pre-Budget submission. But it would still ensure that higher earners pay their […]

90 Halifax IFAs go to employment tribunal

More than 90 IFAs whose roles were ditched by Halifax when it shut its IFA division in October last year have lodged redundancy claims with an employment tribunal. Halifax offered to make the IFAs tied agents within its life division, considering it to be a “reasonable change of role”. The IFAs do not agree and […]

The death of retirement – a boost for protection?

According to our recent report on the death of retirement, changes in workplace pension provision mean that coming generations of retirees could have a radically different experience of retirement from their parents. The average contribution rate into an old-style final salary pension was around 20% of total wages, the statutory minimum for a new automatic […]

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up

Comments

    Leave a comment

    Close

    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm

    Email: customerservices@moneymarketing.com