View more on these topics

The simple truth

In response to the article in the June 10 issue of Money Marketing, the situation research carried out for the Which? report, The Protection Question was modelled, implemented and analysed according to our normal rigid research criteria.

The purpose of the research was to establish what advice mortgage advisers based in high-street lenders and estate agents gave to first-time buyers concerning protection insur-ance and to measure this advice against established industry best practice. As always with situation research projects that we carry out, the research was designed to reflect real people&#39s experiences given a certain scenario. In the scen-ario we designed, best advice would have been income prot-ection, provided the right amount of cover could be offered within the customer&#39s budget (which one adviser did offer).

Mortgage payment protection would have been the next best option if income protection was not practical or affordable. Life cover was not required given the fact that the customer had no dependents and was covered by his/her employer for £50,000.

Critical-illness cover should only have been offered in addition to a suitable income protection or (as second choice) mortgage payment protection insurance and only if this did not overstretch the customer&#39s budget. Finally, we looked at how well each adviser explained the reasons for the recommendation and the details of the products.

The results of the research speak for themselves. We disa-gree with Lifesearch&#39s accus-ation that the research was “simplistic”. It was modelled to test a given scenario and the results carefully analysed.As with the majority of Which? reports, an early draft giving our interpretation of best advice was sent to regulators, industry trade bodies and IFAs, none of whom disagreed with the benchmarks applied.

Mike Naylor

Principal researcher

Which?

Martin Chapman

Media relations department,

Consumers&#39 Association,

London W1

Recommended

B&B to shed 600 jobs

Bradford & Bingley announced today in its pre close briefing that it has already shed 150 employees from its core of 3,950, and expects to remove a further 450 by the end of 2005. B&B says its core lending business has continued the strong performance of 2003, revealing its non-core businesses are expected to be […]

&#39Rethink portfolios in closed WP funds&#39

The risk profile of with-profits funds has changed so much that clients&#39 overall portfolio profiles should be revisited, says Investec Fund Managers joint managing director Andy Sowerby. Sowerby told PIMS delegates last week that IFAs should be revaluing the portfolios of clients invested in closed WP funds because many have little equity exposure and may […]

Zurich chief Keogh will head SEI&#39s wealth team

Multi-manager specialist SEI Investments has recruited Zurich director Chris Keogh to head its wealth channel as part of the group&#39s drive to enhance its offering to UK intermediaries. As managing director of wealth, Keogh will spearhead a revamp aimed at broadening SEI&#39s offering to advisers, focusing specifically on creating all-round business solutions rather than the […]

&#39Industry has final chance to woo back the public&#39

The industry has one last chance to bring consumers back into the fold after failing to serve their needs, warns a report by business thinktank Tomorrow&#39s Company. The report, Restoring trust – investment in the 21st Century, is the result of two years&#39 consultation among more than 500 practitioners and investment groups representing all parts […]

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up

Comments

    Leave a comment