View more on these topics

The cap fits

As an MP, John McFall was an excellent chairman of the Treasury select committee, regularly putting banks and officials in the firing line. So the pillorying that McFall has endured for his proposal (from his seat in the House of Lords) to cap pension charges at 1.5 per cent a year seems a bit unfair.

Like many serious analysts, McFall has done the numbers. He knows that a 1.5 per cent charge out of a possible 6 per cent return for a cautious fund consumes a quarter or a third of the pension pot. He thinks that is excessive and unreasonable. Do you disagree?

Of course, if you are running an aggressive strategy with your Sipp, you may make returns of 12 per cent a year and not feel too worried about charges at 1.5 per cent. That is not the point. Most people will run relatively cautious strategies with their pension funds that are unlikely to return more than 6 to 7 per cent a year. And advisers will have to recommend such strategies if they are to follow the FSA’s injunction to pay attention to their clients’ capacity for loss.

Just because many low-earning savers will have the opportunity to save in Nest at low charges does not absolve the industry from its responsibility to try to offer value for money. Providers that continue to offer plans at high charges (and, yes, 1.5 per cent a year is a high charge for a long-term pension plan) should be put under pressure. By whom? The FSA? Dream on. McFall does not have a bazooka but at least he has fired an airgun.

The usual suspects whinge that regulators have no right to set or control charges. This is nonsense. Charges are a fundamental feature of saving and investment products. Many other features of these plans are controlled by regulations. Why not charges?

People often make a flawed comparison between control of the rate of charge and control of prices. Yes, controlling the price of petrol or bread is a bad idea – many Third World government finances are in a mess partly because they control these prices or subsidise them or both.

But capping the rate of charge is different from controlling prices. The actual monetary amounts taken from a percentage charge will depend on investment returns. Actual profitability can only be known many years down the road.

Providers are almost certain to use low estimates of returns in deciding whether a given rate of charge will prove profitable, giving them an incentive to set charges too high. And they have all spent years promoting commission-driven churning, with the result that the average duration of long-term contracts has plummeted. Yet they use this shorter duration as justification for even higher charges.

None of this justifies providers’ freedom to set high charges. On the contrary, what it provides is evidence that you need Nest-style arrangements delivering scale and mutuality benefits to deliver value for money.

What I find really objectionable is the attitude that the poor deserve to pay more. The unit trust industry, under the controlled charges regime of the 1970s, delivered investment management to modest savers at a cost less than that paid by millionaires for discretionary investment management and unit trust management companies made good profits. The removal of charge controls has meant higher costs with negligible benefits for investors and much higher profits for managers.

Independent financial advice may be a social service for the rich but there is no reason why financial products should fleece the poor.

Chris Gilchrist is director of Churchill Investments and editor of The IRS Report



True Potential offers legacy pension transfer aid

True Potential is offering a transfer toolkit which aims to help advisers transfer legacy pension and investment assets into more suitable products that match clients’ updated risk profiles. The toolkit allows advisers to view legacy assets in pie chart or tabular format and analyse suitability based on clients’ attitudes to risk. It also enables advisers […]

Plain English Campaign backs bid to demystify insurance plans

Income protection provider Unum is calling on insurers to simplify their customer product information after it emerged that the insurance sector is the worst at making product literature easy to understand. Unum, backed by the Plain English Campaign, commissioned research into how easy consumers find it to understand product information. Of the 2,016 consumers surveyed […]


Roger Edwards: Help us decide the future for CI cover

Bright Grey and Scottish Provident are holding a critical illness summit meeting in London next month to discuss why CI sales have been falling in recent years and what can be done to ensure more people protect themselves and their families. They are looking for IFAs to attend the meeting, to be held on September […]

Barclays cuts fixed rates by up to 0.41%

Barclays has cut the rates on its range of Woolwich fixed rate mortgages by up to 0.41 per cent. The lender says the cuts affect around 60 per cent of Woolwich’s range of fixed rate mortgages. Its two-year fixed rate up to 75 per cent loan-to-value mortgage sees the largest fall, from 3.79 per cent […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm