View more on these topics

The bond illusion

Stuart Fowler, founder and investment director of Fowler Drew, warns that the risks of non-indexed bonds do not seem to have been recognised

When UK gilt redemption yields on a 10-year duration bond touched 2 per cent unparallelled in more than a century we really should have asked ourselves whether conventional bonds that are not indexed to inflation can possibly play the risk-reducing role given to them in traditional balanced management.

For bonds to perform this role, you have to be suffering from money illusion, meaning you cannot see the transfer of risk from short-term volatility to long-term purchasing power outcomes. A bad trade-off to make at the best of times, it is a shocking one when bonds are priced artificially. It leaves investors defenceless in the face of even modest inflation.

This false market came about partly through Government intervention in the pricing of inflation risk, which is what quantitative easing is all about. It manipulates the price signals that markets rely on to inform the choices that investors make.

The Government is aided and abetted in its intervention in the gilt market by two other externalities:

  • accounting rules that make bonds appear artificially low-risk for hedging insurance and pension liabilities
  • the convention of balanced management that makes it appear rational and good regulatory practice for private-client advisers to hold more bonds to reflect a reduction in a client’s risk appetite.

Ironically, when a central bank buys bonds to drive yields down in order to signal that it is rational to take more risk, these externalities prevent the signal from having the desired effect. Liability-driven investors increase their hedging-demand for bonds to prevent accounting deficits from increasing.

Can bond yields near 2 per cent be rationalised other than by these externalities? To answer this, we need to think in terms of probabilities. Risky assets are those with an uncertain chance of meeting an investor’s expectations. In the absence of foresight, rational investment in risky assets requires a favourable distribution of probable returns.

In nominal terms, 2 per cent nominal yields on 10-year bonds can hardly fall much further but yields could rise severalfold. This is clearly not favourable. But for most private clients, it is purchasing-power outcomes that matter most they can live with volatility but they live off outcomes.

To turn this into a more symmetrical, rational range of future real yields requires equal scope for both deflation and inflation. If the distribution of probable future changes in the general price level is skewed upwards, there is no symmetry in real returns from bonds either.

The price of gold is an indicator of what some investors think about skewness in the inflation process. However, many individual investors also appear to hold the same intuitive view that the combination of paper currencies and democratic elections leads governments to take far greater risks with inflation than they will with deflation. Since they also vote, the chances are that individual investors probably share the same bias. Most households have more to lose from sustained deflation than continued inflation.

In a skewed world, turning the nominal yield distribution into a real one might shift most of the probable range of real yields to minus 6 per cent (2 per cent yield and 8 per cent inflation) as a bad outcome, to 3 per cent (2 per cent yield and 1 per cent deflation) as a good outcome.

These estimates ignore the tail risks, which are also not symmetrical. A higher rate of deflation than 1 per cent per annum over a sustained period is less plausible than a higher rate of inflation than 8 per cent per annum. The real extreme risk is hyperinflation, which has no equivalent in scale of falling prices.

If bond holdings cannot be rationalised in terms of probable nominal and real returns to an investor who has less than perfect foresight, they cannot be relied on as the basis of risk management in a balanced portfolio.

Balanced management relies on diversification to smooth the return path of a portfolio. The bond percentage is the allocation that most contributes to the reduction in volatility. This is because bonds are the only asset with reliably weak correlation with equities and property. In fact, in some economic conditions, they are inversely or negatively correlated. Yet they are also the asset with the greatest unrewarded inflation risk.

The risk-reducing role of non-indexed bonds has never looked so flawed, yet the investment industry and the FSA appear not to have noticed.


Funds for all seasons

UK all companies managers able to identify value are translating unpredictable markets into consistent long-term performance. James Smith reports


Fixed points

There are many factors for advisers to consider on fixed protection

Aviva UK life and pensions sales up 6%

Aviva’s UK life and pensions sales increased 6 per cent from £7.6bn in the first nine months last year to £8bn at September 30, 2011. The increase was driven by strong sales growth in group pensions and individual annuities. Group pensions new business rose 68 per cent in the first nine months of 2011 compared […]


Capital Economics: ‘Debt crisis will lead to demise of euro’

Capital Economics says the crisis engulfing the eurozone will lead to recession and the eventual demise of its single currency in its current form. European equity markets fell today following Monday’s announcement of a Greek referendum on the latest aid package to solve its debt crisis. The FTSE is down 2.5 per cent, while the […]

State of the markets: global growth

In conversation with journalist Alexis Xydias, Artemis Global Growth Fund manager Peter Saacke discusses the state of global markets and how he is positioning his fund. Peter gives his views on the growth potential of US, Europe and emerging markets, each of which is on a different stage of the road to recovery. And with a […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm