View more on these topics

Take the exit

“When Wall Street sneezes, the world catches a cold” is an expression we all have heard. It has certainly proved true in the past. But when it comes to positive developments, why are we so slow to catch up with what is happening in the US?

Financial services history shows that we tend to be 10 years behind the US.

A few years ago, the concept of paying an exit fee rather than an initial charge for an investment product was relatively unheard of in the UK. Yet such products have been available in the US since the late 1980s and have grabbed market share dramatically.

A number of companies are beginning to offer such a share class on their UK Oeic range. In the US and Europe, the term adopted has been B shares. In the UK, Henderson has used the term X shares (X for exit fee).

If the example of the US is followed in the UK – and history would suggest this is a distinct possibility – then this share class could well become the vehicle of choice among investors. It is certainly something that advisers should have on their radar screens.

Our experience would suggest that the UK market is keen to embrace this charging structure. It is now a little over one year since we converted our unit trusts to Oeics. At the same time, we added the X-share structure to all Oeic sub-funds. Since then, we have seen sales of X shares outstrip sales of standard-charging A shares via our Isa offering. If we look at business coming in via Pep transfers, the shift to X shares is even more dramatic.

How does an exit charge work? The X share class adopts a simple charging structure. There is no initial charge for investments. Rather, a declining exit fee is charged over a set time period. For example, redemptions in the first six years of investment attract an exit charge declining annually from 4 per cent in the first and second years to 3 per cent, 2 per cent, 1 per cent and 1 per cent in the following four years.

The exact charging structure may vary between fund management groups but the principle is the same. Initial and annual commission arepaid to the adviser, typically at 3 per cent and 0.5 per cent. The annual management fee will be higher on X shares than the more traditional A shares.

Aha, I hear you cry, the catch is that the investor has to pay a higher annual management fee so they are not better off at all. Well, interestingly, this is not the stumbling block it might at first appear. The client is better off as there has been no initial charge paid so all their money is working for them from day one. This can have a dramatic impact on the returns expected.

Investors will typically be better off buying X shares rather than A shares for just over the first 10 years of investment. This is illustrated in the second table, which gives as an example a typical UK equity fund which has a 1.5 per cent annual management fee on the A shares and 2 per cent on the X shares. Initial and total expense ratios are also reflected.

While exit charging may not be appropriate for every individual, it does provide the consumer with flexibility and choice. It is here to stay and, if past US experience is a guide, to flourish.


Early 1970s Unit-linking Early 1980s Unit-linking

Late 1970s Broker dealerships Late 1980s Networks

Early 1980s Tax incentives for Mid 1980s Peps

equity investments

Mid 1980s Derivative-backed Late 1990s Derivative-backed

investments investments

Mid 1990s Fund supermarkets Late 1990s Fund supermarkets

Early 1990s State 401(k) pensions 2001 Stakeholder pensions

Mid 1990s Multi-ties Early 2000s Same in UK?


All-party MPs attack plan to axe polarisation

Government backbenchers and the Opposition have attacked the FSA&#39s plans to scrap polarisation, warning it will restrict independent advice to the rich and reduce the viability of IFA sector.The Conservatives say the possibility of misselling would be greatly increased and that IFAs could effectively disappear.Labour backbencher and member of the Treasury select committee Jim Cousins […]

David Bailey turns his lens on Scottish Widows

Scottish Widows is screening new TV ads this week directed and produced by veteran photographer David Bailey.Filmed around a lighthouse and featuring the customary widow, the ad will be shown at peak viewing times until the end of January and then from February 17 for four weeks.By the end of its run, Widows claims the […]

FSA claims trees take place of IFAs

The FSA admits the 1 per cent cap is damaging the IFA channel by cutting income and driving advice out of the market.It says the cap for stakeholder and Cat standards “is leading to a squeeze on revenue in cash terms per sale” for IFAs.This follows the decline in direct salesforces, “consumer demand for independent […]

Cap Gemini warns of recreating system flaws

A consultant at the heart of the FSA&#39s polarisation rev-iew has hit out at the pla-nned regime, saying it could have significant adv-erse impact on both consumers and the industry.Cap Gemini Ernst & Young vice-president Shaun Crawford says the proposals are in danger of recreating many of the present flaws in the system and there […]

Graphic Content – August

Given the release of employment data from the US on 5 August, we wanted to focus on employment data in this month’s Graphic Content. The Graphic Content below shows us that young and middle-aged workers were hit the hardest by the Great Recession and have never caught up. Since the job market started to recover […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm