View more on these topics

Surplus to requirements

I am the owner/director of a small company and am in my early 50s.

I have had a small self-administered scheme for around 15 years.

As a result of some hefty contributions in the early years when business

was good, it is worth around £500,000, including the company premises and

some loans to my company.

However, business has been poor for a few years. As a result, my earnings

have dipped and I do not expect them to recover. I understand this could

cause a major surplus problem in due course and I need some advice.

The surplus issue stems from the link between your pensionable earnings

and the maximum benefits that you may draw in due course.

In calculating your maximum benefits, you can use your highest average

earnings over three or more years ending within 10 years of either:

The date of drawing your benefits, or:

The date of leaving service, if earlier.

Therefore, we can reach back to earnings from five or more years ago,

assuming that you draw benefits at 60.

I would strongly recommend that we conduct a review of your earnings and a

projection of benefits to see which years&#39 earnings are optimal.

If the review finds that your optimal earnings are more than 10 years away

from your normal retirement age, then a number of possibilities arise.

First, you could retire early enough to capture these better earnings

figures. However, you would have to retire as an employee and resign as a

director of the company. This may not fit in with your current plans,

especially bearing in mind the outstanding loans.

Second, you could opt out of pensionable service. This would freeze your

pensionable earnings figures by setting the date of opting out as the point

from which you count back 10 years. However, you would not need to leave

service with the company.

It would not actually guarantee you a surplus-free future as this depends

on investment growth and future annuity rates, among other things.

There is a further alternative which would present you with greater

retirement flexibility and no further problems with earnings levels. This

option is to transfer your fund to a self-invested personal pension plan.

Here, there would be no further risk of surplus following transfer and no

link between drawing benefits and retirement. There are, as usual, some

hurdles to negotiate first.

Before you transfer, there is a funding test to pass, commonly known as

the GN11 test. Only if the SSAS fund is below the transfer test can you

proceed. Even if you pass, you will have to repay the loan before

transferring as a Sipp cannot make loans.

Either of these stages may well present an insurmountable difficulty for you.

However, depending on the current funding position of the SSAS, it may be

possible to arrive at a very convenient solution. An application could be

made to the Pension Schemes Office asking that a refund of surplus be made

now to your company from the SSAS.

At this point, I should stress that there is no laid-down format for

determining and refunding surplus from an SASS prior to retirement and any

approach is a matter for negotiation. Nevertheless such refunds have been

permitted in the past.

The target is to arrange it so that sufficient surplus can be refunded in

order to reduce the value of the SSAS below the Sipp transfer cap. The

refund of surplus received by the company could then assist in repaying the

pension scheme loan, thus freeing the path to a Sipp transfer.

The net effect is that the burden of financing the loan is eliminated and

the prospect of a bigger surplus in the future has also disappeared. Since

the refunded surplus is used to repay the loan, the refund would only have

been taxed once at 40 per cent.

Of course, the procedures in attaining this position are very involved.

There is no guarantee that the refund of surplus will be sufficient to

reduce the scheme&#39s value adequately to allow a transfer to a Sipp or that

the Pension Schemes Office will permit a surplus refund in the first place.

However, bearing in mind the end result, it may well be worth spending

some time exploring this scenario.



Alliance and Leicester settles with former chief executive

The much publicised dispute between Alliance and Leicester and ousted chief executive Peter White has been settled out of court. The deal is allegedly worth £1.9m in straight cash, substantially more than the £1.05m originally offered by the bank and turned down by White. White had initiated legal action, suing the company for unfair dismissal. […]

Sports clubs kick off with pensions

IFAs may face a growing threat to their livelihood as sports clubs areplanning to sell life and pension products to fans, according toDatamonitor.The report highlights a growing trend for sports clubs and associations toget involved in financial services, with over 250 clubs offering over ninemillion fans the opportunity to take an affinity credit card.But Datamonitor […]

Schroder prescribes medicine for new fund

Schroder is kicking off the second Isa season with the launch of a globalhealthcare fund and a European technology fund.The medical discovery fund, supported by cancer research, aims tocapitalise on companies creating new advances in the field of medicine andtakeover activity in pharmaceutical stocks.Half of any retained initial charge together with a percentage of theannual […]

Bill Mott

The investment indus try calls him a star fund manager but stockpickingguru Bill Mott talks about himself in far more disparaging terms.In his late 40s, he descri bes himself as a “geriatric” fund manager in agame played mostly by the younger generation. Such modesty seem typical ofMott, who advises other fund managers never to believe […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm