View more on these topics

Steve Webb: Don’t let clients fall into the taper reporting trap

Advisers must be on the lookout for clients inadvertently failing to report an annual allowance breach on their tax return

How many of your clients are inadvertently lying to HM Revenue & Customs? Probably more than you think if they are affected by the complexities of the tapered annual allowance when it comes to pension tax relief.

Since April 2016, higher earners have faced a potentially reduced level of annual allowance for pension tax relief.

Those with total taxable income, including the value of any employer pension contribution, in excess of £210,000 can find their annual allowance reduced from £40,000 to as little as £10,000.

Steve Webb: A perfect storm for DB transfer complaints

But the rules around the tapered annual allowance are so complex that whole seminars are devoted to helping advisers understand how it actually works.

Given that clients are expected to self-declare on their tax return whether they have breached the annual allowance, and given they may consult an accountant (if anyone) rather than a financial adviser before completing that return, how many are actually getting it right? And if they get it wrong, and it is subsequently discovered, how many will face tax bills running into many thousands of pounds?

Difficult questions

The level of knowledge required to fill in this one innocent question on the tax return is staggering. The first stage is to work out the level of annual allowance after the tapering has been applied.

To calculate the extent of tapering, people first have to calculate their net income, then their threshold income: that is, net income adjusted for pension contributions and salary sacrifice arrangements.

If this figure is over £110,000, they proceed to the next stage, which is to work out adjusted income: net income plus employer contributions plus some adjustments for tax relief. If the adjusted income exceeds £150,000, they face a 50p in the pound deduction from their maximum annual allowance until it reaches a floor of £10,000.

Annual allowance tax take take triples in year after taper

But the poor taxpayer is not finished there. They then have to work out how much pension contribution to test against the revised annual allowance figure. For defined contribution pensions, this is relatively straightforward; basically, the total amount contributed (gross) by employer and employee. But for taxpayers with defined benefit accrual, the rules are very involved.

In simple terms, the calculation is to look at the change in the value of DB benefits between the start of the year and the end of the year, adjusted for a measure of inflation and multiplied by 16. This complexity means the issue of failing to report a breach of the tapered annual allowance may be a particular problem for higher earning members of DB schemes, such as senior NHS professionals, civil servants and others.

By this point, even taxpayers who had heard of the tapered annual allowance would probably have lost the will to live. And we have not even got onto the issue of carry forward of unused allowances from previous years, including those in which the tapered annual allowance would potentially have also applied.

Be on the lookout

An adviser might well respond to all of this by saying such complexity is precisely why advice is so valuable. And they would be right.

But what if your clients do not use your services to complete their tax return? What if they do it on their own or use an accountant who may not be on top of the subtleties of pension tax relief? Are you confident your clients are not inadvertently storing up future tax bills or worse?

Claire Trott: Pension schemes and the annual allowance charge

Where DB scheme members incur tax charges because of a breach of the annual allowance, they may be able to benefit from a scheme pays arrangement which avoids a short-term cash flow hit, albeit at the expense of a lower final pension. But it is not yet clear whether DB schemes will be happy to apply scheme pays in cases where the annual allowance breach occurred a year or more earlier and has only just come to light.

In an ideal world, we would not have a tapered annual allowance. If we did, high income in one year would affect the ability to contribute in the next year, which would give more time to work out there was a problem and do something about it.

But, for as long as we retain this absurd in-year tapering of annual allowances, advisers must be on the lookout for clients who may be caught unawares and help them make sure they are not inadvertently failing to report this on their tax return.

Steve Webb is director of policy at Royal London



FCA wins fee complaint over regulatory return

A complaint the FCA unfairly issued a late fee to a firm that failed to submit its Gabriel report on time has been rejected by the Complaints Commissioner. The firm was due to file its Gabriel report on 12 February this year and says it did not do so as it was not reminded. Information […]


FCA: Tell clients about post-Brexit changes to service

The FCA has told firms to make clients aware of changes to products and services that will come about after Brexit. Speaking at the Third UK Brexit summit, FCA international director Nausicaa Delfas said while the regulator is preparing for all the possible scenarios, they expect individual firms to do the same. Delfas (pictured) says: […]


FOS hit with 300 pension transfer complaints since freedoms

The Financial Ombudsman Service has revealed it received 300 complaints relating to defined benefit to defined contribution pension transfers since 2015. However, this currently makes up 2 per cent of all pension complaints between April 2015 and March 2018, when the FOS received a total of just under 15,000 complaints on pensions and 1,700 complaints […]


The anatomy of long-term asset allocation

Parit Jakhria, Head of Long-Term Investment Strategy at Prudential, explains how his team operates to determine our long-term investment strategy to ultimately deliver outcomes for your clients. Recommendations & critical yieldThe Long-Term Investment Strategy Team (LTIS) determines the optimal strategic asset allocation (SAA) and the strategic hedging policies for Prudential’s multi-asset portfolio. As part of […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm