View more on these topics

Stephanie Flanders: The ECB is not the only show in town


Never fear, Super Mario is here. That is the conclusion  investors in European markets seem to have come to.

The economic news from the eurozone has not been good at all. But bond and equity prices have rallied, on the perception that the European Central Bank and its president, Mario Draghi, are on the case.

That is an understandable reaction. It may even turn out to have been justified. But it is also disappointing for two reasons.

The first reason is that, nearly five years since the eurozone crisis first erupted, you might have hoped that the real economy would now be setting the pace for markets, not the central banks.

It is a sad reflection of just how long it has taken countries to get moving again that central banks are still front and centre in every major developed economy. The exact timing of the first rise in interest rates in the UK and the US is a constant subject of debate.

That gradual tightening of policy is now firmly on the horizon in Britain and America shows it is at least on the path to less extreme levels of central bank support. There is also a general understanding that tightening in these economies need not be bad for stock prices in the medium term if it comes in response to accelerating growth.

We are still a long way from that in the eurozone. Financial markets have been rising as well but it is not because of any improvement in the economic data. It is because Draghi seemed to suggest at the Jackson Hole meeting of central bank governors in Wyoming last month that the situation was bad enough to warrant further ECB action.

That expectation was rewarded earlier this month, with the surprise cut in the ECB’s key interest rates and the symbolically significant decision to start buying private asset-backed securities outright. That is a form of quantitative easing although by limiting the purchases to certain kinds of private assets rather than government IOUs, the  ECB is ensuring the programme will start out relatively small.

If they help to support lending to European businesses, at the margin, these steps will do more good to the eurozone economy than harm. But helpful though they may be, these measures cannot transform the outlook on their own. That is the second reason to worry. Pushing down the value of the currency is a good start and will help European companies start to deliver the faster growth in corporate profits that investors have been waiting for. 

But no amount of new credit will induce businesses to borrow if they do not believe there is demand for their goods out in the broader economy – or if a mountain of red tape and regulation is standing in their way.

This was one of Draghi’s central points in Wyoming. In that speech he made a pointed reference to needing more growth-friendly budget policies across the eurozone. That contained an implicit suggestion that Germany could be doing more in its fiscal policy to support European growth. He also endorsed a plan by the European Commission president for a big fund to invest in European public infrastructure. But Draghi also said, forcefully, that no amount of stimulus would have a lasting effect on growth in Europe without structural reforms to raise the eurozone’s underlying potential.

Many in the markets seemed to hear only the first part of his message – that the outlook for the recovery was worrying and  the eurozone needed growth to stage a lasting recovery. 

They did not listen so closely to the second part – that economic growth could not come from the ECB alone. Not for the first time, the central bank is being painted as the only show in town. Draghi is supposed to be the master of managing market expectations. But now the expectations around the ECB are high and so are the risks of disappointment.

Stephanie Flanders is chief market strategist at JP Morgan Asset Management 



Ascentric posts loss after £1.6m tech spend

The cost of moving to a new software system forced Ascentric into a £567,000 pre-tax loss for 2013, down from a £1.84m profit in 2012. Money Marketing revealed in April that Royal London-owned Ascentric would move directly onto the Sonata system as part of its deal with Bravura. Rival Nucleus, already a Bravura client, moved […]


Court orders insider dealing ring to pay £3.2m

Members of an insider dealing ring have been ordered to pay £3.2m in confiscation orders after being jailed in a prosecution brought by the FCA. Ali Mustafa, Pardip Saini, Paresh Shah, Neten Shah, Bijal Shah and Truptesh Patel were sentenced to prison in July 2012. They were convicted of making a combined £732,000 on trading […]

Cover 2

Return of the direct salesforce? Aviva eyes protection advice network

At least one major insurer is eyeing a return to the face-to-face advice market as financial services giants rethink their distribution models. The traditional direct salesforce was slashed across a host of high-street banks and life offices both pre- and post-RDR. However, Santander last week reversed that trend when the bank confirmed it had begun […]

Lis David Aviva Investors 2014

People on the move

This month’s moves include changes at Aviva Investors, Fidelity and Ascentric


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm