View more on these topics

Standard life edge

Long-time favourite of the IFA community, Standard Life has finally capitulated to what many saw as the inevitable but only after it was pressurised into doing so by the FSA.

The Government&#39s embarrassment over the Equitable Life fiasco was never going to allow a similar problem again and Standard Life has ended up as the whipping boy.

Ever since the Baird report, the writing was probably on the wall if anyone took long enough to read it. The FSA report made a number of recommendations about the regulation of life insurance and, in particular, it called for improved standards of solvency and disclosure.

All very well, you might think. But what does it mean in practice? Leaving aside the possible short-term sweetener of demutualisation bonuses for policyholders – which might average only £1,500 – the company has been forced to sell £7.5bn of equities at a time when markets are a long way below their peak.

Many policyholders who bought with-profits on the strength of Standard Life&#39s undisputed investment pedigree will never find out how well they would have fared over the full term. Having their assets switched heavily into bonds, they are doomed to lower returns.

Bonds are looking cheap at the moment. Was that what Standard Life would have done if it had been left to manage its own affairs? Moreover, did the policyholders want to switch to bonds and did they have any say in the matter?

In being forced to adopt the FSA&#39s new realistic valuation approach – also known as, let&#39s not have another Equitable Life, thank you – Standard Life policyholders have been forced into doing what every IFA knows is wrong, that is, selling at the bottom of one market and immediately buying at the top of another.

Although Sandy Crombie is putting a brave face on matters, claiming there was a certain inevitability about demutualisation, that is not what Standard Life was saying just a few months earlier when it claimed that as a strong, well run mutual, it had the ability to provide better with-profits returns than its competitors.

When Fred Woollard tried to force a demutualisation in 2000, less than half the policyholders were in favour. That was at a time when demutualisation bonuses would have been very handsome indeed. But demutualisation is now an inevitability and although there is to be a vote in 2006, without support from the management for continuing its mutual status, the chances of the vote going against the proposals are nil.

Fundamental to the whole problem is managing risk on the one hand and managing expectations on the other. Unfortunately, the Government has allowed people&#39s expectations to be raised to an unrealistic level and, in the claims&#39 culture that has now emerged, losing money is intolerable and demands compensation. The reality is that if we factor out risk altogether, then everything costs more simply because investment returns are bound to be lower. That is why low-cost endowments became popular in the first place and, equally, why traditional guaranteed annuities are currently so unpopular.

For years, with-profits policyholders have enjoyed attractive long-term returns. Based on a recent ABI report, the average 25-year endowment that matured in August 2002 produced a net annual return of 10.72 per cent and that was having reached maturity in the middle of the stockmarket slump. Achieving good returns must involve some risk but, spread over the longer term, just how much risk were Standard&#39s with-profits policyholders really exposed to? Now, they will get lower returns and many will think the trade-off has not been in their best interests.

Sadly, the political cards are stacked against with-profits and mutuality but I cannot help feeling that we will live to regret allowing these concepts to wither away.

Steve Patterson is managing director of Intelligent Pensions


Tomas Carruthers

The glory days of the 1990&#39s technology boom might seem a world away but after an absence from the limelight, Tomas Carruthers, the one-time chief executive of Interactive Investor International, is making his move back into the marketplace. Carruthers has again taken the reins of the consumer fund supermarket Ample and will be developing it […]

Wise Investment – CF Wise Investment

Type: Oeic fund of funds Aim: Growth by investing in collective investment schemes, UK shares and cash Minimum investment: Lump sum £1,000 Investment split: 100% unit trusts, Oeics, investment trusts, UK shares and cash Isa link: Yes Pep transfers: Yes Charges: Initial 4%, annual 1.65% Commission: Initial 3%, renewal 0.5% Tel: 01608 642233 L

Place bet

The Diary assumes that insurance is a far cry from the frenzied world of gambling and spread betting. But not if one were to read the launch edition of betting magazine Inside Edge, edited by James Hipwell, previously co-author of the Daily Mirror&#39s City Slicker column. What is this we read in the letters page? […]

Wise Investment – Wise Active Growth

Type: Oeic fund of funds Aim: Growth by investing in collective investment funds Minimum investment: Lump sum £1,000 Investment split: 30% UK equity, 21% UK growth, 20% managed mix, 10% European equity, 10% UK equity income, 8% Japanese equity, 1% cash Isa link: Yes Pep transfers: Yes Charges Initial 4%, annual 1.65% Commission:Initial 3%, renewal […]

Europe outlook: Greek gridlock and Italian banks

By Rob Burnett, Investment Director, Head of European Equities As investors await a resolution of Greece’s repayment difficulties, we anticipate a period of consolidation in the European market over the next few weeks. Our base case is that the Greek government and the European Central Bank (ECB) will come to a solution, particularly given the […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm