View more on these topics

Shock therapy may not be the cure for ailing pension savings

The impact of nearly 10 million people discovering their pensions are worth up to 60 per cent less than expected is set to challenge the industry.

The Department for Work and Pensions plans to make it compulsory from April 2003 for money-purchase pension scheme members to receive an annual statement showing the benefits they will receive at retirement.

But the proposed combined benefit statements are on course to give the 9.4 million people in money-purchase schemes a rude awakening.

According to the actuarial working party set up to decide how the illustrations will be calculated, the figures will be only 40 per cent of what people have been led to expect from point-of-sale documents using FSA projection rates. This is because, unlike the FSA figures, the DWP illustrations are based on real rates of return including inflation.

The FSA suggests people should not be too alarmed by the differences, pointing out that its point-of-sale projections are aimed at showing the effect of charges on a policy rather than any guaranteed benefits.

Spokeswoman Jackie Blyth says: “We cannot change our projection rates until we have consulted with the industry on it but we do want consistency with the DWP. The main reason for projections at point of sale is to help people understand what the effect of charges is. No projections show what you will definitely get.”

The FSA projections are set to be the subject of consultation in April, once the DWP working party has put together its proposals.

A DWP spokesman says: “Consistency with the FSA point-of-sale documents is very important and we are working with the FSA to produce consistent results before introducing the illustrations.”

While policyholders may be in for a shock when they discover the true value of their pension expectations, some people in the industry say it is for the long-term good.

Clerical Medical pensions strategy manager Nigel Stammers says: “The ultimate benefit is a more realistic view for planning purposes, going by real-value figures adjusted for inflation. This is for longer-term good and may be a step in closing the savings gap.”

But some IFAs expect few consumers to be aware of the difference. Richard Jacobs Pensions & Trustee Services director Richard Jacobs says: “Ninety per cent of people in money-purchase schemes have no idea of the value of their expected benefits in real terms. Most quotations given at point of sale are totally meaningless. If people did understand the quotations and the benefits they would get, no one would be paying less than £100 into a plan.”

Working party chairman Stewart Ritchie points out that a significant number of people in money-purchase schemes do not receive FSA projections in the first instance. Many have projections provided by consulting actuaries instead.

But the confusion these statements could induce is causing considerable concern and many in the industry believe they may serve to shock people out of saving altogether.

Jacobs says: “After being ahead of the pension game in this country, we are just at the point of going into the reverse. Yet again, consumers will just view the pension industry as just being in a big mess and this will give them another reason to turn away.

“The reality of stakeholder is that no one has confidence in the pension industry. If people are going to see projections at less than half the return they were expecting, people will just not continue to bother.”

Scottish Life also voices concerns that these statements will give advisers and providers a very difficult job in encouraging new savers. Head of communications Alasdair Buchanan says: “The reality of this is that it might make it more difficult to persuade people to take steps and demotivate people who are already saving.”

Communication is obviously going to be key to ensure consumers are not misled by the information they receive in the statements.

Stammers says: “For someone who has recently taken out a pension plan based on current projections and then on first renewal sees a 60 per cent drop, they are going to wonder what on earth has happened. The industry is going to have to do a lot of explaining.”

Skandia senior group marketing manager Peter Jordan says: “It is really down to how the information is presented. We are in a low-inflation environment and equity returns are being pegged back. If it is all kept in step with inflation, it should not be a massive issue.

“As quotation rates are dragged down, as long as targets are brought down in line with reduced wage earnings, people should not panic. But the Government seems concerned with frightening the life out of people who are not necessarily committed to loading up with pensions.”

Questions are now being raised about all illustrations and whether the FSA will have to bring its projections on to the same basis for all products.

Buchanan says: “The FSA has got to look at all illustrations and the impact of the DWP basis for all products. If there are different basis for different products, it might suggest one product is better than another.”


ScotMut urges axing defined payment

Scottish Mutual is calling on the FSA to drop the defined payment rules from its depolarisation proposals. It says these has been unnecessarily bundled in and are not required to introduce greater competition. Many IFAs will carry on as before merely dropping the independent epithet, it claims. Pensions and investments development director Leslie Gray says […]

Collins Stewart launches Zero recovery fund

Collins Stewart Fund Management Limited is seeking regulatory approval for the launch of a new Zero Dividend Recovery Fund.The Fund is designed to allow investors the opportunity to exploit potential of capital growth from an asset class that has already fallen heavily. The Fund aims to raise £20 million to invest into a concentrated portfolio […]

Adverse credit major cause of stress

One in five women see a poor credit history as the greatest cause of stress according to a survey from lender Kensington Mortgage Company. Across the whole population 17 per cent are most stressed about adverse credit than anything else.

HomeLoan Partnership adds Cheshire to lender panel

Mortgage network, HomeLoan Partnership, has added Cheshire Building Society to its lender panel. HLP says by joining forces with one of the strongest regional players in the UK it is allowing its intermediaries to offer the full range of Cheshire&#39s mortgage products to clients. A maximum procuration fee of 3 per cent has been brokered […]

Choose life…

Sarah Scott  – Marketing Consultant, Royal London  This month sees the return of Renton, Sickboy, Begbie and Spud in the sequel to the film Trainspotting. Just over 20 years later, we return to see exactly how life treated the characters whose lifestyle was less than ideal back in 1996. Did they choose a job, choose […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Jackson Osbourne 6th December 2010 at 5:47 am

    The reality is that even if you squeezed the rich until the pips squeak that doesn’t go anywhere near filling the gap.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm