View more on these topics

Scottish Mutual&#39s new With-Profit Bond reviewed

Scottish Mutual&#39s latest with-profit bond aims to offer a wide choice of flexible income options and potential for additional bonuses.

Most feel the bond fits well in the market although Moorfield says: &#34This compliments existing products but it&#39s not as attractive as the bond from Clerical Medical or Norwich Union on headline bonus rates. It&#39s not likely to be first choice.&#34 However, Macfarlane says: &#34The bond fits into the with-profits market well. Scottish Mutual is a leading provider in this area and name awareness should give it an advantage.&#34

Buswell says: &#34Timing isn&#39t everything I know but this particular launch by Scottish Mutual offering a very attractive 8.75 per cent minimum return couldn&#39t have happened at a better time for the company. Equity markets around the world are in turmoil and a product offering this sort of initial rate will be very popular.&#34

Ison goes on to explain who the bond may be suitable for. She says: &#34With-profit bonds are typically suited to the 50 to 75 year old age group looking for steady growth or income but safe in the knowledge they can sleep easy at night. This is particularly relevant in today&#39s turbulent markets.&#34 Macfarlane says: &#34It&#39s for low risk long term investors.&#34 Bruce and Moorfield mention the appeal of with-profit bonds to traditional building society investors. Buswell adds: &#34Traditionally, with-profit bonds have been popular with the more risk adverse investor. This is typically the more mature person looking for cautious growth. But in the current climate, this may well stretch to younger people as well.&#34

Due to the number of with-profit bonds already on the market, some of the panel are unable to find any specific marketing opportunities for this product. Macfarlane says: &#34The market is already well saturated with this type of product. However, with-profit bonds tend to be useful for providing a regular, high income facility. As such, the maximum income and capital protection option may be attractive to some clients.&#34 Ison agrees adding: &#34The only new twist is in marketing the maximum income option.&#34 But Buswell remains very upbeat about the opportunities. He says: &#34Just compare 8.75 per cent against equity markets and building society accounts over the last year and very little marketing needs to be done.&#34

Moving on to discuss the bond&#39s main useful features, Moorfield says: &#34The main feature I like is the maximum income with capital protection. It will give this product a head start for the older, income seeking investor.&#34 Ison adds: &#34The regular income options provide flexibility to meet most customer needs.&#34 Buswell agrees saying: &#34There is a good, wide choice of income options giving a fixed amount or fixed percentage of the fund. The maximum income with capital protection, ensuring no capital erosion, is a very good additional selling point.&#34

Macfarlane highlights the competitive bonus rate, high allocation rates and the 10 year bonus followed by a continuous five year loyalty bonus. Bruce likes the absence of an initial charge, no charge for withdrawals and no market value adjuster on death or the tenth anniversary of the bond.

Analysing the MVA guarantee further, Macfarlane is more sceptical calling it a marketing gimmick. Most agree that while it&#39s nice to have, for most clients, it becomes irrelevant. Moorfield says: &#34It&#39s useful but not crucial. My experience is that investors retain with-profit bonds and therefore MVAs are not a big issue.&#34 Ison adds: &#34The ability to take withdrawals up to 7.5 per cent a year is standard in the market. But not many competitors offer a guarantee date. Of those that do, most are at 10 years. Scottish Mutual state, however, that the guarantee date can be at any later anniversary date. I question the value of the guarantee date as do many customers retain their investment for 10 years or more? In addition, customers must exercise the MVA free guarantee within 4 weeks following the guarantee date, which is very restrictive.&#34

The panel express diverse views on the bond&#39s flexibility. Moorfield says the flexibility is good while Buswell says: &#34As with all with-profit bonds, there is very limited flexibility.&#34 Macfarlane says: &#34The flexibility is low. With-profit bonds indeed most bonds with high tail end charges tend to be inflexible.&#34 Ison reckons the flexibility is good but says she would like to see clients being allowed to top-up their investment rather than take out a new plan. Bruce says: &#34The bond is not very flexible in the early years, with high early encashment charges.&#34

Discussing Scottish Mutual&#39s past performance track record, Buswell says: &#34This can only be described as average as far as with-profit bonds are concerned.&#34 Macfarlane sees it differently calling its record excellent. Ison adds: &#34Its past performance is average despite the obvious strength provided by its parent company, Abbey National. But we are still to see this come through in improved performance.&#34 Bruce says: &#34The bonus rates have stood up well over the past five years. However, total returns are fairly average.&#34

Most of the panel are happy with Scottish Mutual&#39s reputation, particularly since the acquisition of the company by Abbey National. Bruce says: &#34Scottish Mutual has a good reputation in the market being a financially secure company, part of the Abbey National group. Ison adds: &#34Scottish Mutual&#39s reputation has improved considerably since the acquisition by Abbey National, to a much more forward thinking impulsive company.&#34 Moorfield says: &#34The backing of Abbey National enhances its perception and enables Scottish Mutual to offer quality products.&#34

Most agree the charges are fair although Macfarlane thinks the surrender charges are high. Buswell says: &#34The charging structure is among the best and clearest in the market.&#34

The panel are also impressed with the literature. Moorfield calls it very professional and well presented.

Summing up, Buswell says: &#34In the final analysis, any investment is only as good as its performance. Scottish Mutual is giving this product every chance and I wish it luck.&#34


(Average marks out of 10)

Bonus rate 8.0

Flexibility 6.2

Past performance 6.8

Reputation in market 7.6

Charges 6.4

Commission 8.0

Product literature 8.2


John Bruce, partner, Gillies & Campbell, Richard Moorfield, partner, J Tricketts, Bruce Macfarlane, partner, Capital Trust Financial Management, Jackie Ison, business support manager, Halifax IFA, Alan Buswell, proprietor, Glenburn Financial Services.


Scottish Mutual


Type: Single-premium unitised with-profit bond designed to provide capital growth and/or income over the medium to long term.

Minimum investment: £5,000.

Bonus rate: Annual – 6.75 per cent, terminal – 2 per cent.

Allocation rates: Lives assured of 79 and younger – 100 per cent, over 79 – 98 per cent. Allocation rates can be enhanced by up to 6.67 per cent if full commission is sacrificed.

Charges: Annual – 1.5 per cent, early surrender – 9 per cent in year one decreasing by 2 per cent a year until 1 per cent in year five. Bonuses are paid net of annual charges.

Options: Choice of three income options fixed, percentage or maximum with capital protection.

Loyalty bonus: Bonus units of 1 per cent paid after 10 years and every five years thereafter.

Commission: Initial only – 6.25 per cent. Initial and renewal – ranges from 4 per cent initial and 0.5 per cent renewal, 2.88 per cent initial and 0.75 per cent renewal or 1.75 per cent initial and 1 per cent renewal.

Tel: 0141 565 5600.


AIM pushes six companies

AIM believes that the market slide over 31 per cent in the last six months has thrown up bargain stocks.It is recommending six companies that it believes are undervalued and provide good growth prospects.They are Furlong Homes, Gartland Whalley & Barker, C & B Publishing, VFG, Mears Group and Shalibane.

Pru boasts of with-profits performance

Prudential expects its with profits annuity to continue to register strong levels of growth beating other comparable products.Over the 7-year period between April 1992 and April 1999, the life office expects to outperform its rivals, having outstripped comparable annuities in mid-1997.Prudential&#39s anticipated with profits annuity bonus is 3.5 per cent a year.

Marlborough Stirling cajoles industry on ISAs

Marlborough Stirling is telling the life and investment industries that there is no excuse for delaying ISA products.The software and administration house says that the new standards give managers room for manoeuvre and that only outdated administration systems can prevent providers from being ready.Marlborough Sterling deputy managing director Chris Ryland says: &#34We welcome the Government&#39s […]

Wesleyan unveils ISA plans

Wesleyan Financial Services is planning to offer a &#34no fuss&#34 ISA to compensate for the complexity of the Government&#39s plans.It will offer a maxi ISA consisting of an equity element via the Wesleyan Growth Trust with a cash unit trust for the cash component.The equity-only mini ISA will offer the Wesleyan Growth Trust alone while […]

Oil industry: only the fittest will survive

The actions of OPEC have forced the oil supply to fall and producers to cut costs and rationalise, says Richard Hulf In an interview with journalist Alexis Xydias, Richard Hulf, manager of the Artemis Global Energy Fund, explains the impact of the fall in the oil price on energy companies. Alexis also quizzes Richard on […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm