View more on these topics

Ros Altmann: Pension tax relief will be left well alone

Ros AltmannRumours are swirling about changes to pension tax relief being announced in the upcoming Budget. Predictions of a shake-up to pension incentives have been touted for many years but, so far, we have only seen tinkering rather than root and branch reform.

The £40bn from pension tax relief would come in pretty handy for a chancellor who needs to raise revenue. But will he go there?

I predict the Treasury will steer clear of radical change. Amid Brexit uncertainty, reforms that could create millions of losers and be vigorously opposed by the tabloid press are unlikely.

Then there is auto-enrolment. Throwing a spanner in the way pensions work while this is still bedding in could be a step too far.

Treasury tipped to cut pension tax relief to fund NHS spending

In any case, pension tax relief reform is fiendishly complicated. With so much resource devoted to Brexit, is there really much appetite for it? As pensions minister, I was deeply involved in the work on reforms in 2015/16. At that time, there was a real appetite for change.

Much work was done on a flat-rate government top-up to everyone’s pension contributions, which was considered fairer than tax relief. A 30p per pound flat-rate bonus would give everyone the same incentive, regardless of their income.

But while the majority of pension savers would receive more than basic rate relief, those earning over £50,000 a year would be worse off. Also, the pension income in retirement would be taxable, which could see some receive 30p per pound top-up on contributions but face 40 per cent tax on their pot. It was considered too risky for the Conservatives.

Another sticking point was how to deal with defined benefit employer contributions or salary sacrifice arrangements, since a flat-rate top-up would not be easy. Changing tax relief for defined contribution schemes only was considered unpalatable.

There was also talk of turning pensions into Isas, with an upfront bonus of around 30p per pound but no tax recovered on withdrawal. This option had fewer losers – aside from the Treasury, for whom it would not have saved much money.

Accommodating DB schemes and salary sacrifice would also still be problematic, potentially putting significant costs on to employers.

Ros Altmann: Good pension not always enough for a good later life

And then there was the behavioural element. Tax-free withdrawals undermine the idea of pensions for retirement income, since most people would just withdraw all their money as soon as possible, just in case a future government changed the rules.

So what might Philip Hammond do? He may just decide to leave pensions alone, which would probably prove quite popular. But if he is determined to cut incentive costs, the simplest way to do so would be in lowering the annual allowance. I hope he is not tempted to lower the lifetime allowance again. It should be abolished altogether but, sadly, it brings in too much revenue.

Another measure often suggested is reducing or abolishing the tax-free lump sum, but I would be shocked to see this. The Treasury appreciates this is a totemic element of the pensions landscape and changes would severely dent confidence.

Ros Altmann is former pensions minister

Recommended

Tapering of annual allowance – adjusted and threshold income

The definitions of adjusted income and threshold income used to determine whether, and to what extent, someone’s annual allowance will be reduced can be confusing.  Here we try to make sense of it all. The annual allowance will be reduced for high income individuals from 6 April 2016.  Our previous article Tapering of annual allowance […]

Focusing on money - Magnifying glass over British pound notes.
9

Aegon wins complaint over forcing transfer client to get advice

A complaint that Aegon unfairly refused to allow a pension transfer valued under £30,000 without advice first has been quashed by The Pensions Ombudsman. In a ruling released this week, the complainant said they had attempted to consolidate multiple small pensions pots into an Aegon Flexible Pension Plan, which were all cleared except for their Credit […]

Inside Fundsmith’s new investment trust

Last month, star manager Terry Smith announced he was throwing £25m of his own money behind a new investment trust, Smithson. Ahead of its launch, Money Marketing editor Justin Cash sat down with Simon Barnard and Will Morgan, the fund’s managers, to talk strategy, as well as their thoughts on some of the hottest topics […]

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up

Comments

There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Why would pension tax relief reform be fiendishly complicated? It wouldn’t if the primary objective was to simplify it, and heaven knows we need that.

Leave a comment

Close

Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm

Email: customerservices@moneymarketing.com