View more on these topics

Would you play a pensions lottery?

Sam Brodbeck 700x450

The UK does not save enough.

It is a plain and simple truth that the savings and investment industry has known for decades. Politicians have finally cottoned on – and they are worried.

Report after dull report has concluded there will be a generation who retires into penury, or cannot afford to retire at all, because they have not squirreled enough away.

The big question is, what can we do now to dodge the diet of Iceland ready meals and food stamps awaiting us when the 2030s roll around?

We already have the automatic enrolment programme, introduced in 2012, which forces millions of employers to offer their staff pensions.

But even once it is fully rolled out, less than 8 per cent of your salary will go into a pension.

One of the more popular ideas is to copy a system used in the US where a portion of any pay rise is automatically added to your pot, the theory being you’re not as likely to notice the cut.

But last week Ros Altmann – the pensions minister – suggested something a lot more fun, a pensions lottery.

She said: “From a marketing standpoint, I’ve always been attracted to having lottery money attached to a pension. The chance that every month someone saving into a pension could win a million pounds. And not a million pounds into their pension but to themselves immediately, that might catch the imagination of young people.

“Premium bonds have been sold quite successfully on that basis – maybe the possibility of jam today will capture the imagination.”

It you were being grand you’d call this behavioural economics, essentially using a bit of basic psychology to jolt people into making choices that are good for their wallets.

So, could the minister’s idea work? If you were entered into a lottery in return for putting aside a bit extra for your pension, would you do it?

Let’s take a look at Premium Bonds, one of the most popular savings plans in history with over £62bn invested.

Provided by state-owned NS&I, you lock your money away – earn no interest at all – but get automatically placed into a prize draw.

According to Moneysavingexpert, the odds of a £1 bond number winning £25 is 30,000 to 1 rising dramatically to 30 billion to 1 for the £1 million top prize.

Yet, despite the long odds and falling attraction (as Isa limits rise) the public’s appetite has not dimmed.

AJ Bell senior analyst Tom Selby says harnessing the thinking behind Premium Bonds could help bridge the savings gap.

But he adds: “It’s important any new incentive is available to all and complements the existing pension system, rather than seeking to replace it. Furthermore, it must retain simplicity at its heart because the last thing savers or businesses need is any added complexity.”

Financial communication firm AHC head of engagement Karen Bolan says adopting the idea would have practical challenges if added to the auto-enrolment system. And she adds it would have to be designed so wealthier people were not more likely to win because they have bigger savings.

But these are minor niggles.

All that’s needed now is a charismatic host and a prime time Saturday night slot on BBC One for the live draw.

With any luck we’ll be gambling, not with but using our pensions, very soon.

This article first appeared in The Spectator.

Sam Brodbeck is head of news at Money Marketing



Former adviser’s free pension review business exposed

A firm run by a former financial adviser is the subject of a Panorama investigation into free pension reviews and Cape Verde investments. The BBC programme, which aired last night, investigated the Resort Group, run by chief executive Robert Jarrett – who previously worked at Prudential. It sent an undercover reporter to a call centre […]


Finalists revealed in Growth Investor Awards

The finalists have been revealed in the Growth Investor Awards, with advisers, wealth managers, platforms and investment managers making the shortlists. The awards recognise firms and individuals aiding investment in small to medium enterprises. A total of 56 entries were shortlisted, across 13 awards, including Best Investment Platform, Financial Adviser of the Year, Wealth Manager of the Year, Best […]

State of the markets: UK equity income

Artemis Income Fund manager Nick Shenton discusses the state of the UK equity income market with journalist Alexis Xydias. With the first three months of 2015 showing strong returns for both the Artemis Income Fund and UK markets generally, Nick Shenton discusses the fund’s top contributors – including overseas holdings Novartis and Bayer – and […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 2 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Iceland ready meals are frigging expensive. Anyone who can afford ready meals cannot be too badly off, especially if they are a pensioner who can’t exactly use the “I haven’t got time to cook” excuse.

    As for a pension version of Premium Bonds, £62bn may sound impressive but despite going for 60 years, £62bn is about £1,200 for every working- and pension-age adult in the country. Which doesn’t exactly suggest that if we introduce a pension version, the UK population will flood into it to the extent necessary to allow a comfortable retirement.

    For perspective, Buffet’s Berkshire Hathaway holds three times as much of investors’ money and he didn’t need any government subsidy to achieve that. And he’s just a tiny fraction of the overall investment market. If Premium Bonds was set up today we’d all be denouncing it as another useless folly along the lines of the MAS.

    Enough people mistakenly believe that saving and investing is a “lottery” or a “casino” without confirming their prejudices for them.

  2. She should go, no ideas, no use, no good. Concentrate on the here and now, like consolidation providers ‘rising from the flames’ ripping off members who want slightly early access to their pension monies! 34%+ MVRS, you’re having a laugh. Come on Theresa, find someone with some pension knowledge and that can see what the person in the street wants NOW! Bl…..dy Lottery my a….se

    nsion fund

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm