View more on these topics

Rise to the challenge

The sound of a gauntlet hitting the floor reverberated across the financial services industry earlier this month. Sir Callum McCarthy’s speech at the Gleneagles Savings & Pensions Industry Leaders’ Summit was a challenge to the industry to address fundamental questions.

Callum surfaced some contentious issues that we have all deliberated upon from our own perspective. Was he right to speak out? Was he right to address these matters by way of a challenge? Was the thinly veiled promise of FSA action the right way to bring about a sharpening of focus on the issues? Let me give you my answers to these questions.

I believe in market rather than regulatory solutions. While the need to protect consumers from dishonest firms is essential, regulatory action risks distorting the market and is both costly and disruptive.

If we are ever to have a proper relationship with our regulator, it must be based on mutual respect and a recognition that the industry is ultimately the deliverer of change. Indeed, Callum recognised this point on several occasions during his remarks.

Consumer confidence and trust in financial services products are real issues. However, does the industry stand alone in this problem? No. Part of the reason for any loss of confidence must be laid at the door of the regulator.

The FSA plans to address the market problems through work on financial capability, treating customers fairly, a study of “provider/ distributor responsibilities” and a wholesale review of distribution.

Personally, I am an advocate for financial capability as a better informed client makes better decisions based on a deeper understanding of the advice they receive. It also makes them more likely to seek out professional advice rather than dealing with tied salespeople.

TCF we already know about and getting the balance right on “provider/ distributor responsibilities” has occupied Aifa for quite a while. We look forward to the FSA’s comments shortly.

The distribution review presents us with an opportunity to confront and confound some of the myths that have been circulating around the market for some time. I know from my own personal experience of briefing senior policy makers that the scale of the IFA contribution to the market is massively underestimated. We remain by far the biggest player, with 63 per cent of all retail financial services coming via IFA firms.

Finally, I think Callum’s speech is worthy of reflection and a mature response. The regulator doubts that the industry has the will to address issues of consumer trust and reputation. Aifa is more than prepared to do so. The IFA community is increasingly professionalised, trusted by its clients and robust. While we may not have the “high street brands” the regulator has commented favourably on, those who have had these advantages have squandered them.

The regulator has come to the industry with the issues as it sees them. How will your firm respond? Will you stand on the sidelines as others dictate the market or will you support the trade body that the regulator listens to? It is at times like this when we need to pick up the gauntlet and rise to the challenge. Failure to do so means resignation to the whims of others.

Chris Cummings is Aifa director general


Sour taste of sweetener

Scottish Equitable’s veteran pension guru Stewart Ritchie is alarmed that IFAs might find themselves carrying the can for complaints arising from employees who get sweeteners to leave defined-benefit pension schemes early.What’s more, Ritchie has warned the FSA and The Pensions Regulator about the situation where companies want people out of DB schemes to reduce liabilities […]

Pension warning on life expectancy

Pension schemes could be left with tens of millions of pounds of unforeseen liabilities if they underestimate life expectancy among their members, says the Pensions Regulator. In a speech to the UK Pensions and Investment Summit in Brighton, chairman David Norgrove said trustees and their advisers should review their assumptions about life expectancy to ensure […]

Watch out for DB exit ‘bribes’

IFAs must beware of advising clients on “bribes” offered by employers to leave final-salary pension schemes. Syndaxi Financial Planning managing director Robert Reid says firms are effectively trying to bribe staff to quit schemes by offering payouts. He says staff would be worse off and urges the FSA to investigate if employers are carrying out […]

Retirement - thumbnail

Pension freedoms: stop the scams

At the beginning of 2015, we highlighted that the new pension freedoms that come fully online on 6 April also represent a very attractive opportunity for the criminal fraternity to scam savers out of some, or all, of their accumulated retirement savings.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm