View more on these topics

Richard Parkin: What is not to love about the Lifetime Isa?

Richard Parkin

Those of us in the pensions world were waiting to see if there would be a sting in the tail of the Chancellor’s assurance he was not going for a full-scale reform of pension tax relief in last week’s Budget. Would he cut the lifetime and annual allowances further? Would he abolish salary sacrifice for pensions? Would he launch a pension Isa despite not going for full-blown reform?

On the first two there is no change. But we did get the pension Isa in a slightly different form to what we were expecting.

For a basic rate taxpayer, the Lifetime Isa offers the same level of tax incentive as saving into a pension but has two distinct advantages. First, funds can be withdrawn to purchase the saver’s first home and, second, funds can be withdrawn completely free of tax if held to age 60.

The naysayers were quick to suggest the Lifetime Isa would undermine automatic enrolment and criticised it for further complicating the savings landscape. Of course, more products bring more complexity but the choice between workplace pensions and the Lifetime Isa is pretty straightforward. It will be driven by two things: savings priorities and tax rate expectations.

It has also been suggested the Lifetime Isa will tempt young people out of workplace pensions because they will prefer the ability to buy their first home. However, this seems to have cause and effect the wrong way round.

Those who are determined to buy their own home but cannot afford to do so and contribute to their workplace pension will surely opt out of the pension in any case. The Lifetime Isa just gives them a product they can save in more tax-effectively. The younger generation need all the help they can get to get on the property ladder, so this seems like a welcome boost.

Obviously, the availability of the employer contribution under auto- enrolment means it is generally best advice for people to stay in the scheme and maximise their personal contributions to the extent these are matched by the employer. But what then? Simple maths shows for most basic rate taxpayers additional pension saving is far less attractive than saving into a Lifetime Isa.

A basic rate taxpayer putting £800 into a pension will get £200 relief, giving them £1,000. When this is taken out, 25 per cent is tax-free and the rest is taxed as income. If the individual is still a basic rate taxpayer in retirement they will get £850 out of the pension overall, giving a measly 6 per cent uplift on their original £800 investment. Worse still, if they are a higher rate taxpayer they will get only £700, meaning they have lost 12.5 per cent of their investment.

Under a Lifetime Isa, both would have got £1,000 at retirement, giving a 25 per cent uplift on the original investment. Compared with a pension, the basic rate taxpayer is nearly 18 per cent better off and the higher rate taxpayer is 43 per cent better off. So the Lifetime Isa wins hands down.

For people that are higher rate taxpayers today, the choice is more complicated. If they expect to be basic rate taxpayers in retirement, then the pension is the better option, delivering a 42 per cent uplift on any personal contribution. If they remain a higher rate taxpayer, then the Lifetime Isa wins again, offering a 7 per cent better outcome than the pension.

In summary, then, while employer-sponsored pensions are very much worth having, the Lifetime Isa offers a very attractive alternative for additional saving. Yes you cannot get at it until you are 60 but remember the minimum pension age will be at least 58 by the time any Lifetime Isa investors retire, so this is a non-issue.

Can you trust the Government not to renege on the promise to pay benefits tax-free? It would be a lot harder politically to introduce a tax where none previously existed than to fiddle around with existing allowances and rates. After all, this is what we have seen in almost every Budget for the past 10 years.

So let’s welcome the Lifetime Isa for what it is: a really valuable way of saving for those who do not currently get significant benefits from pensions tax relief. Does it spell the end of pensions? I doubt it. But it certainly points the way to how we can make saving more than the minimum for retirement the norm.

Richard Parkin is head of pensions at Fidelity International



Govt scraps 45% tax on dependants drawdown

A rule that forced dependants to take inherited pension funds as a lump sum at 23 has been scrapped by the Government. The Budget documents reveal technical changes that mean dependants’ flexi-access drawdown accounts get converted into nominees’ accounts. As a result they will no longer have to take any remaining funds as a lump […]


Osborne’s Lifetime Isa points to £7bn pension tax grab

Make no mistake about it – George Osborne’s Lifetime Isa is more than just a neat little wheeze designed to woo low-earners to vote Tory in 2020. It is a clear signal to the pensions industry that the current tax relief system is on its way out. The Chancellor was blocked from pursuing the radical […]

MPs weigh early state pension access plan

An influential committee of MPs is to consider recommending early access to state pensions for both men and women early next week. The Work and Pensions committee has been examining the issue as part of its investigation into the new state pension, and in particular, the changes to the state retirement age of women. Campaigners […]


Osborne cuts CGT to 20%

Chancellor George Osborne has moved to reduce capital gains tax from 28 per cent to 20 per cent. For basic rate taxpayers, CGT will fall from 18 per cent to 10 per cent. The changes will come into effect in three weeks’ time. However rates will remain at the current levels for residential property and […]

Boosting our annuity strategies

Targeting annuity purchase in lifestyle strategies isn’t anything new but we’ve just lifted the bonnet and injected an enhancement shot into the end-point of these solutions. The recent volatility has shot short-term volatility into equity markets and painted a very turbulent backdrop but we’re also equally faced with a stressed fixed interest environment. This can […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. What is not to love about them:

    1. Tax uplift is limited
    2. Unless purchasing a home you are locked in until age 60
    3. 5% tax charge if fund is accessed before age 60 other than home purchase
    4. Assessable to IHT on death
    5. Rules no doubt will change in the future

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm