View more on these topics

Realisation dawns

With careful planning, tax can be minimised on cashing in an investment

Having considered fund and investor taxation in relation to the most suitable choice of retail investment wrapper in the light (you may recall) of the recent “Dear CEO” FSA letter to the heads of wealth management businesses, let’s look this week at encashment/ realisation strategies.

By implementing appropriate planning, most advisers will be well aware that tax can be minimised on encashment and withdrawal of benefits from a collective or a bond.

With a UK or offshore collective, there is a no gain/ no loss disposal when there is a transfer between spouses/ civil partners living together.

This means it may be possible to avoid capital gains tax by transferring a collective to a spouse or civil partner so that the transferee spouse can use their annual CGT exemption or lower (than 28 per cent) CGT rate – that is, where the transferor spouse is a higher or additional-rate taxpayer and the transferee spouse is not.

With an investment bond, there could be more scope to avoid or reduce tax because (unlike a collective), an investment bond can be assigned to anybody as a gift with no chargeable event occurring and, if subsequent top-sliced gains keep the new owner within the basic-rate tax band, no tax charge will arise on a UK bond.

The 20 per cent basic rate tax charge cannot be avoided under an offshore bond except to the extent that the gain falls within the investor’s personal allowance. Top-slicing can help minimise or avoid higher/additional-rate tax.

As an alternative, the owner could manage their income down so that no higher/ additional-rate tax were due on the realised chargeable-event gain under either a UK or offshore bond, or the offshore income gain under a non-reporting fund.

Although an assignment can look extremely tax-attractive, the assignor has to accept that, once assigned, the asset no longer belongs to them.

Any attempt to use an assignee as a conduit to facilitate lower/no tax should be considered potentially doomed to failure.

If encashment is to take place gradually, that is, through a drawdown strategy, then it will be interesting to compare the relative merits and financial outcome of using the well known and administratively simple 5 per cent a year tax-deferred withdrawal facility in connection with a UK or offshore bond with the making of partial or full encashments under collective investments and using any available annual CGT exemption to take tax-free amounts to supplement income.

So how about portfolio tax management?

By using a UK or offshore investment bond as a wrapper, it is possible to switch between different investment funds with no tax charge.

However, if you switch investment funds underlying a collective (UK or offshore), you are likely to trigger a disposal for CGT with a potential CGT tax charge (an income tax charge on a non-reporting fund).

CGT can therefore be a serious tax constraint to important investment decisions in relation to collectives.

Fund of funds or manager of managers’ approaches may avoid this problem but the investor will not have control over the switch, it having, effectively, been ceded to the fund manager.

On the other hand, as indicated in an earlier article in this series, as a by-product of simple year-by-year investment management (perhaps through rebalancing a portfolio to keep within agreed asset allocation parameters) the base value of the investment can be uplifted at no tax cost through use of the annual CGT exemption.

I will continue on this theme next week by looking the subject of estate planning when considering encashment and product wrapper choice.


Europe committee revives plan for 14-day mortgage cooling-off period

A committee scrutinising the European Union’s mortgage directive has resurrected the idea of a 14-day cooling-off period for borrowers after a mortgage offer has been made. Plans for a 10-day cooling-off period were considered by the European Commission when it first began to formulate draft proposals for the mortgage credit directive. But in January, it […]

Arch Cru cell firms set for multi-million legal fight

The board of the cell companies that make up the Arch cru funds is preparing to launch a multi-million-pound legal claim against Arch Financial Products over its management of the failed range. SPL Private Finance IC Limited chairman Hugh Aldous says the board and its advisers are preparing a claim against Arch FP, which acted […]

Out of context

“Maybe you should offer them some financial advice. They can have that widescreen TV if they save £20 a month for 48 months.” Chartered Insurance Institute media relations manager Lucy Grubb gives PFS president Fay Goddard some suggestions for dealing with rioters. “You’re not in Glasgow now, Billy.” An MM hack berates AJ Bell’s Billy […]


Ford leads £91m attempt to take Lifemark out of administration

Lifemark provisional administrator KPMG Luxemburg has been offered a loan facility of up to £91m, arranged by Keydata founder Stewart Ford, in an effort to take it out of administration. This week’s Money Marketing reveals that KPMG’s Eric Collard was approached with the facility last week. It is being proposed by a US bank which […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Nothing here about ISA’s, which is odd, as I would have thought that for most investment strategies where tax efficiency is important they should be the first port of call.

    Also, top-slicing of gains crystallised upon encashment of an investment bond doesn’t apply as far as potential impingement on age allowance. A nasty one that and easy to overlook.

    In later life, with an eye to IHT planning, an offshore investment bond wrapped in a Discounted Gift Trust is often well worth considering.

    But we’ll see what the writer has to say next week.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm