View more on these topics

Rathbones multi-asset head: The sector is a ‘nightmare’

David Coombs 700x450

The multi-asset sector needs clarity in its definition and is a nightmare for investors, argues Rathbones head of multi asset David Coombs.

Coombs, who is at the helm of the firm’s £375 multi-asset range, says the sector has exploded and has no real cohesion. “You’ve got multi manager in there, the derivative type of funds, like GARS for example. So it is a nightmare for buyers and investors.”

Coombs says the term multi-asset itself has become “relatively meaningless” arguing the multi-manager category shouldn’t be included in it.

He says: “Multi-asset has been around for a long time, it used to be called ‘balanced’. It has become a term like hedge fund, it is a relatively meaningless term.”

Coombs argues multi-manager should be taken aside from multi asset.

“A lot of multi-manager funds don’t do asset allocation, they just try to generate alpha from the managers,” Coombs says, stating it is a difficult process. “I’ll never try to do that, I think it is almost impossible.”

In the last year Rathbones has moved from multi-manager to invest directly into large-cap UK and international equities, as well as sterling investment-grade bonds, rather than accessing them through other actively-managed funds.

Coombs says: “I ran multi manager funds for a while, but I converted it because I felt multi-manager was difficult because you don’t have such a great handle on the risk because the underlying managers are doing what they are doing, you find them sometimes at odds to your views.The range also lowered its charges to 0.5 per cent, from 0.75 per cent.

“So I moved to direct because I knew what was in my fund on the daily basis, and how it is performing and position accordingly and I have a much lower total account cost.”

Coombs remarks follow a recent study from consultancy firm Finalytiq which claims “unskillful” multi-asset managers do not add value to their clients’ portfolios and “systematically” damage their returns.

Experts have flagged on the unfairness of comparing funds with different targets as well as those ranging from the lower risk to the higher risk.

Coombs says:”I think a lot of these multi asset funds have come together through all sorts of reasons, mostly commercial and I think they are badly thought through and badly designed.

“You need to design multi-asset funds in a world of zero to negative interest rates which is where we are in the next five years and they are quite hard to run as multi-asset means you have the broadest possible universe.”



IFA’s pension cold calling petition passes 1,000 signatures

A petition started by an IFA to ban pension cold calls has reached 1,000 signatures. Red Circle Financial Planning director Darren Cooke started the petition two weeks ago, and is calling for the ban in order to stop vulnerable individuals being sold unregulated investments or getting taken in by scammers. The petition says: “Cold calling […]

Vanguard John James

Vanguard set to compete with Hargreaves on D2C

Vanguard, one of the world’s largest fund groups, has its sights on the likes of Hargreaves Lansdown and Nutmeg as it prepares to launch a direct-to-consumer offering. Separately, the fund group known for its low-cost passives is also looking to expand its active investments with the launch of a global fund range next year. Speaking […]


Adviser directories challenged over value and quality of referrals

What is the best way to attract new clients? Is it professional connections? Direct marketing? Word of mouth? Whichever way you cut it, any sustainable advice firm needs to have a reliable way to generate leads. Adviser directories Unbiased and VouchedFor have both upped their efforts to convince advisers why their search and ranking engines […]


John Lawson: Why it is time to scrap the lifetime allowance

The factors used in pension tax law to measure defined benefit pensions have become increasingly outdated since the 2006 simplification project. Arguably, the factors used at that time to convert DB into cash amounts for measurement against the annual and lifetime allowances were generous to members. Today, there can be no argument that defined contribution […]

Nigeria cover image - thumbnail

White paper — Nigeria International Insights

Jelf Employee Benefits closely examines healthcare provision and challenges within Nigeria. This will be of particular interest to HR decision makers with employees based in Nigeria, and assesses the environment, risks, facilities and safeguards that are relevant to organisations that are actively deploying expatriate staff in this location.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment