View more on these topics

Rate of change

Still on the trail of identifying key issues emanating from this year&#39s Budget and Finance Bill, I would like to turn my attention to the introduction of a minimum rate of corporation tax in respect of profits paid out as distributions (usually in the form of dividends) to other than corporate shareholders, in most cases, individuals and trustees.

Many years ago, there was a principle of apportionment in relation to corporate profits. Before this was abolished in 1989, there was effectively a penalty on undistributed profits. The aim was to make it unattractive to retain profits in a corporate structure where they would bear less tax than had they been distributed.

The latest provision is, in effect, the reverse of this in that it applies a tax penalty to funds distributed – not all distributions, just those made out of a corporate business that is liable to the starting rate of corporation tax (0 per cent on profits up to £10,000) or the first marginal rate (an effective 23.75 per cent on profits between £10,001 and £50,000).

It should be remembered that the latter is an effective rate on profits in excess of £10,000, assuming the first £10,000 is taxed at a zero rate. What actually happens is that the small companies&#39 rate of 19 per cent is applied to the whole of profits up to £50,000, then the tax actually payable is reduced by marginal relief to arrive at the average underlying rate of tax. This underlying rate on all profits will be between 0 per cent on profits up to £10,000 and 19 per cent on profits of £50,000. The nearer actual profits are to £50,000, the nearer to 19 per cent will the underlying rate be.

The problem that the Inland Revenue is seeking to address by imposing the minimum rate is that where dividends are paid out of profits that have borne a rate of less than 19 per cent. Shareholders in receipt of the dividend nevertheless receive a full basic-rate credit.

Of course, even if profits from which the dividend is paid had borne 19 per cent tax, the taxpayer would still receive a credit (22 per cent) that is greater than the tax suffered. However, the Revenue is obviously relaxed about this minor discrepancy. It is clearly less relaxed about what could be a full 19 per cent discrepancy on dividends paid out of profits not exceeding £10,000.

The imposition of the minimum rate is designed to rectify this perceived anomaly.

Ahead of the Budget, there was considerable fear that an NIC charge might be imposed on all dividends so maybe this 19 per cent minimum rate is not so bad. It is, however, evidence of Revenue disquiet over business owners being able to remove funds not subject to NICs and, in the case of companies with profits up to 19 per cent and, consequently, an underlying rate of less than 19 per cent, with insufficient tax deducted at the corporate level.

The minimum rate for dividends paid by these companies was presumably thought to be the easiest way to address the problem. Perhaps it was thought to be too difficult to attempt some kind of recategorisation of dividends as earnings from employment or, in the case of directors, from offices.

Where advisers have corporate clients which will be affected by these provisions, it is important that they are aware of how they will operate. Remember, the provisions are only relevant for companies with profits up to £50,000. For these companies with surplus profits to distribute, the minimum rate needs to be taken into account when determining the relative attraction of taking funds by way of dividend or bonus/salary. The minimum rate only applies in respect of profits distributed to non-corporate shareholders.

How does the minimum rate work? Let us look at two examples – one for a company with profits below £10,000 and one where profits are between £10,000 and £50,000.

Let us assume that profits for an accounting period are £8,000. These are distributed by way of a dividend to individuals. The tax computation would be:

Assume now that profits are £40,000. The distributions made in the accounting period total £35,000, of which £10,000 are made to a company. The tax computation would be:

The new minimum rate will make dividend payments to non-corporate shareholders by affected companies less attractive than before. But the dividend is not subject to primary or secondary NI so it will still be a financially superior method of removing funds from the company than payment by way of salary, regardless of the tax rate of the shareholder/director. The exception is where the recipient is a non-taxpayer and is not made one by virtue of the payment. The payment of salary to such a person would be deductible for the payer and not assessable on the recipient. NICs would also be avoided.


FSA says split-cap debacle is worst case it has seen

The FSA has described the split-capital investment trust debacle as the worst case of misconduct it has seen but is struggling to get the 21 firms involved to sign up to its compensation package. The statement is believed to be a further attempt by the regulator to force the firms to compromise on a compensation […]

John Joseph on Protection

As this column is all about protection I thought I would widen the remit to include protecting our profession. I am sure I am not alone in being bombarded with emails which promise to make me rich beyond my wildest dreams. We have to make a decision as to what we read, as too much […]

Axa in £1m drive for core funds

Axa is rolling out a £1m ad campaign for its core funds, including its distribution fund which is celebrating its 25th anniversary in July. Other funds to be included in the campaign are the deferred distribution fund, the reserve fund, the property fund, the high-yield distribution fund and the higher-income fund. The campaign, which is […]

Rightmove in buoyant mood over prices

Rightmove was again the most upbeat in its report of the house price indices of 2004, stating that last month&#39s strong growth in prices has been repeated again in April, with a 2.8 per cent rise. Rightmove says, so far this year, prices are up by 8 per cent compared with last year&#39s rise of […]

The death of retirement – a boost for protection?

According to our recent report on the death of retirement, changes in workplace pension provision mean that coming generations of retirees could have a radically different experience of retirement from their parents. The average contribution rate into an old-style final salary pension was around 20% of total wages, the statutory minimum for a new automatic […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm