View more on these topics

Poor DC governance hitting confidence

Industry experts say a lack of good governance risks undermining employee confidence in defined-contribution pension schemes.

Speaking at TheCityUK’s pension conference in London last week, Financial Services Consumer Panel chair Kay Blair said that governance levels in defined-contribution schemes continue to lag behind those in defined-benefit schemes.

She said: “I think governance in defined-benefit schemes has been good but governance in defined-contribution schemes is not as good.

“Employees would have more confidence in pensions in general if there was more effective governance in DC schemes.”

National Association of Pension funds chief executive Joanne Segars said DC super trusts with independent trustee boards could help plug the governance deficit.
She said: “The UK market is filled with small DC schemes and small schemes tend to have weak governance.

“In DC, a lot of pension schemes have no clear governance whatsoever. That is a worrying place to be with automatic enrolment just months away.”

The Pensions Regulator chief executive Bill Galvin said that there is a lack of understanding and engagement among trustees of some existing DC schemes.

He said: “In some trust-based, employer-sponsored pension schemes the trustees demonstrate a lack of understanding and engagement with DC issues, particularly if it is a hybrid scheme with a DB element. There is a challenge for us to make sure the people running pension schemes have the right levels of knowledge, understanding and engagement to do a proper job in looking after the members’ interests.”



ABI warns over EU gender pricing implications

The Association of British Insurers has warned a European ruling banning gender pricing in insurance could open the door for similar legislation on age and disability discrimination. In March last year, the European Court of Justice ruled gender pricing for insurance products will be banned from December 21, 2012. The ruling, based on a challenge […]

Portillion closes down

Portillion has withdrawn its FSA application and decided not to pursue becoming a mortgage lender. Its Farnborough office has been closed and all the staff have been made redundant. It first planned to become a lender in 2007 when former GMAC-RFC chairman Stephen Knight revealed plans to launch Checkmate Mortgages. It rebranded to Portillion in […]

Conservative MP calls on SFO to investigate Arch cru

Conservative MP David Davis has written to the Serious Fraud Office in a bid to get them to investigate the suspension of the £400m Arch cru fund range. According to The Financial Mail on Sunday, Davis says there is a number of concerns in the run up to the suspension that he wanted to bring […]

Coventry enters securitisation with £1bn issue

Coventry Building Society has entered the securitisation market for the first time with a £1.1bn issue. The issue, called Leofric No.1, is backed by a pool of prime owner-occupied mortgages originated by the society and its intermediary lending arm Godiva Mortgages. The average loan-to-value ratio of the pool is around 64 per cent. Both Moody’s […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. There is an easy answer to the poor governance prevalent in small OPS DC. They should switch to contract-based schemes where governance is exemplary as a result of TCF, or switch to master trust where the trustees are professional and capable of governing the scheme properly.

    We already have Super Trusts in the UK – we call insurance companies. No need to invent something new – we already have scale providers of administration.

Leave a comment