View more on these topics

Platform ticket

Fidelity&#39s move to offer financial incentives to IFAs and their clients for re-registering investments on FundsNetwork has unsurprisingly come under fire from its fund supermarket rivals.

Their main criticism is that Fidelity&#39s decision – which will see it pay IFAs £50 and their clients £25 for consolidating holdings on its platform – is tantamount to buying business that it would be unable to attract otherwise.

There is little doubt that in terms of re-registration, Fidelity is well behind fiercest rival Cofunds. A respectable £224m of Fidelity&#39s business last year came from consolidation but this was less than half of Cofunds&#39 £462m.

Cofunds was quick to see re-registration opportunities and has, according to a number of brokers, done better to develop relationships with many of the major mailing houses which put most of their consolidation business Cofunds&#39 way.

Fidelity, although conceding that its offer makes its re-registration proposition “more compelling”, argues that it is simply trying to ease the financial burden on IFAs, who it says are increasingly realising the benefits of consolidation.

Head of IFA business Stuart Holah says: “More advisers than we thought see re-registration as a way of helping them but many say they cannot spare staff from their business-gathering activities to undertake re-registration work. The offer will help them reduce the operational costs of the administration involved.”

As re-registration pays no initial commission, there is little doubt that £50 a case would be attractive to smaller IFAs in particular. Keen to avoid targets, Fidelity will only say it would like to be “pleasantly surprised” by demand. But its rivals point out that, in most cases, its offer will be uneconomic, as FundsNetwork will only get 0.25 per cent of the annual management charge of re-registration cases which average £5,000-£7,000.

Selestia director Bill Vasil-ieff says: “£75 is a lot of money to give away for the business. On a £5,000 case, it would make £12.50 a year. It seems odd and I do not think £25 will be sufficient to make an impact on what is an important investment decision for clients. I recommend Fidelity tries giving away a carriage clock or a kettle.”

Vasilieff says he believes the offer may work in the short term but once it expires on June 30, he expects FundsNet-work&#39s re-registration streams to revert to their normal level. As a result, he does not expect other supermarkets to try and match the offer, even if, as seems likely, demand proves strong and Fidelity extends it beyond the current deadline.

Cofunds says it has no intention of following Fidelity&#39s lead, arguing that it would rather put resources into other areas which help IFAs. Marketing director Rick Andrews says: “We believe in investing in systems and training to help make each consolidation exercise a success. This is the approach we apply consistently on an ongoing basis throughout the year, not just as a short-term promotional offer. There is absolutely no way we would make the same offer.”

Not all fund supermarkets are keen to attract re-registration business anyway. Skandia says it will not follow Fidelity&#39s lead simply because re-registration business is, in its eyes, unprofitable. Investment marketing manager Ian Thomas says: “We are not actively trying to chase re-registrations because we are trying to maintain a financially stable business model. Re-registration is essentially loss-making business and it is not something that is part of our key strategy. I hope Fidelity&#39s offer will not form part of IFAs&#39 decision-making criteria.”

Thomas argues that re-registration does not particularly help people with a “hotpotch” of investments to sort out their portfolios.

It is a view that is supported by other industry observers, who point out that offering money for investors&#39 business is only likely to appeal to those with small portfolios.

An industry source says: “Fidelity&#39s decision smacks of desperation about its failure to break into this market properly. Are clients going to be bothered by £25? If you have a £100,000 portfolio, are you really going to re-register it for that amount of money?” This is obviously open to question but there is little doubt – even among some of the supermarkets – that the £50 incentive will have an impact, in particular for smaller IFAs looking to shave costs. With most IFAs under intense pressure for a host of insurance and regulatory reasons, £50 a case will ease their admin costs at a time when they most need help. But it is a different story for the major players which tend to select supermarkets on the basis of historic support.

Chelsea Financial Services managing director Darius McDermott says: “Cofunds has bypassed Fidelity in terms of re-registration and Fidelity, as we have come to expect, is fighting back. But the offer certainly will not make any difference to us – apart from financial help, Cofunds gives support to us in many ways.”

McDermott says Cofunds has gained an advantage by recognising the potential within re-registration and making strides to secure brokers&#39 business. Given that Cofunds pulled in twice as much re-registration business as FundsNework last year, it is an argument hard to refute.

But Fidelity&#39s move could, at a lower level at least, threaten its current dominance in this area of the market. Cofunds has the head start but Fidelity undoubtedly has the financial clout to give it a serious run for its money.

Recommended

Kane makes it plain

If anyone was under the misapprehension that Scottish Widows had been put under the command of a mealy-mouthed faceless banking man, think again. The new chief executive Archie Kane does not mince his words. With-profits will diminish still further. The FSA is actively seeking to corral IFAs into bigger groups – an accusation often made, […]

Distance directive bring in new rules for pre-disclosure

Advisers selling investment products over the phone, internet or post will have to provide greater levels of pre-disclosure under a new European directive aimed at guarding consumer rights when buying financial products remotely. The FSA is setting out its rules for implementing the distance marketing directive, due to be enacted on October 9. FSA spokeswoman […]

No Abbey apology

I would like to highlight the wonderful service that Abbey Group is providing in helping me to advise clients. Yesterday, I received a letter from the mortgage division without date, reference or name of the sender. The letter advised me that they did not hold a copy of my MCCB certificate and requested that I […]

Isa sales March at the double

Net Isa sales in March were more than double February&#39s level at £496m and 21 per cent higher than March 2003, according to IMA figures. Net retail sales through tied agents accounted for 46 per cent compared with 36 per cent from intermediaries. The balance was made up of direct-offer sales at 12 per cent […]

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up

Comments

    Leave a comment

    Close

    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm

    Email: customerservices@moneymarketing.com