View more on these topics

Phoenix to compensate over automatic disinvestment

General-Business-Contract-Hire-Appointment-700x450.jpgThe Pensions Ombudsman has ruled Phoenix Life should reimburse a client for the financial losses he suffered due to a breach of contract that led to the disinvestment of his funds.

In the case Mr T complained that James Hay made an unauthorised encashment of his savings, formerly held in a Sipp, and that Phoenix Life failed to honour the terms of the original policy.

In August 2000, Mr T signed an application form with Phoenix Life for a flexible income plan to be held in a Sipp with the trustee listed as James Hay Pension Trustees.

The policy term selected on the application form was 15 years and Mr T transferred around £123,000 to the Sipp and invested 100 per cent of this in the Global Care fund.

In June 2015, Phoenix Life wrote to James Hay Pension Trustees to confirm that the policy within the scheme was to mature the next month.

James Hay confirmed the holding had been surrendered.

In July 2015, £216,366 was disinvested and Mr T confirmed he transferred the amount to another Sipp provider, which completed on the following month.

Mr T said he placed orders for new investments on this same date, and he reinvested proportionately into five funds, which were purchased between 19 and 21 August 2018.

He says the maturity was not necessary and it should not have been allowed without his consent as he understands he would have free access to move to other James Hay funds.

He holds both Phoenix Life and James Hay responsible for the automatic disinvestment.

Mr T’s complaint was considered by one of TPO’s adjudicators who said no further action was required by James Hay but concluded Phoenix Life should reimburse Mr T for any loss and pay him £500 for the distress caused.

This was because the original Phoenix Life terms and conditions do not state disinvestment was an automatic requirement upon the maturity date. James Hay bore no responsibility as the trustee as it followed the instructions issued by Phoenix Life and the disinvestment was invoked by Phoenix Life so it bears the liability for any financial loss.

Mr T did not accept the adjudicator’s opinion and the complaint was passed on to ombudsman Anthony Arter who agreed with the reasoning.

Arter says the disinvestment was instigated by Phoenix Life and James Hay as the trustee simply provided the necessary bank account details for transferring the disinvested funds.

Phoenix Life accepted it made an error in instructing James Hay to disinvest the fund and its terms did not in fact require the automatic disinvestment.

It has been told to compensate Mr T for any losses incurred and pay him £500 directly.

Phoenix Life was not able to provide a comment in time for publication.


Pensions Ombudsman sides with Transact over pension transfer complaint

The Pensions Ombudsman has ruled in favour of Transact in a complaint that saw the platform blamed for pension losses of nearly £150,000. Pensions ombudsman Anthony Arter says the loss to the claimant’s pension fund after being transferred to the Bobins Pension Scheme in early 2008 on the recommendation of the now-defunct Fallon Financial Services, […]

Pensions Ombudsman and TPAS in dispute resolution overhaul

The Pensions Ombudsman is to take over all dispute resolution previously handled by it and The Pensions Advisory Service. Under the current system, people can ask TPAS to help settle a dispute before a formal complaint is made to their pension scheme. Or, they can go straight to TPO, which has legal powers to settle […]


Pensions ombudsman rejects complaint over LV= Sipp transfer

The Pensions Ombudsman has rejected a complaint against LV= after a customer lost £16,000 while transferring into a new pensions policy. Mr H complained that LV= failed to act on his instructions to cash in and reinvest his portfolios while in drawdown. The transfer represented an internal transfer from a LV= pension policy to a […]


CDC schemes risk irreversible ‘intergenerational injustice’

Collective defined contribution pension schemes risk creating intergenerational injustice and undermining pension freedoms, warns the Centre for Policy Studies. In a report published today, CPS research fellow Michael Johnson says the evidence on countries that have such schemes, including the Netherlands, Canada, and Germany, is mixed. CDC pensions – which are not yet available in […]


Guide: day-to-day tasks ​— can your system manage?

This guide from Johnson Fleming will take you through the required communication and also give ideas for additional actions that will ensure your auto-enrolment project is a success. As well as highlighting what is required from a system to ensure it is up to the tasks, an overview of the following is also provided: data validation; data categorisation; employee communication; opt-in process; opt-out process; produce contribution schedule; contribution reconciliation process; upload of member data to pension provider; upload contribution to pension provider; manage salary sacrifice process; enrolment process; re-enrolment process; and management of increased employee queries.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm