View more on these topics

Paul Kennedy: The central role of tax in investment planning


While investment performance is generally depicted in terms of gross return, tax habitually dictates what part of that return ends up in the investor’s pocket. Clearly, the investor’s spending possibilities are constrained to the return after tax and one might argue it is this that counts.

Investing in a great performing fund in a tax-inefficient manner may, in fact, ultimately equate to investing in a much poorer performing fund in a tax-efficient manner. Despite this, many facets of investment planning remain almost completely blind to tax.

Modern portfolio theory ordinarily assumes an investor does not consider tax when making decisions and is indifferent to the type of investment return. In real life, the type of return, whether dividend, interest, capital growth or some other form of payment such as pension income, are all fundamental.

Each is often taxed in a differing way and at a different rate. Furthermore, certain types of investment return have annual tax-free allowances, again at differing amounts, and others do not.

If interest will be taxed at 40 per cent, whereas dividends or capital growth at 0 per cent, it surely follows that the underlying risk analysis may be somewhat flawed if tax is ignored. In essence, an investor taking a risk of “X” to invest in equities compared to fixed interest might be seen to be taking somewhat less risk if the dividends and capital growth are tax-free whereas 40 per cent of the fixed interest return is lost in tax.

This equation can be put in many other ways. The fundamental point is that once tax is imported the risk versus reward equation can look different. Arguably, models developed in a pre-tax framework do not necessarily equate to the post-tax framework and asset allocation should encompass tax considerations if it is to be accurate.

The interaction of tax within portfolio diversification and asset allocation theory is a complex subject. There is a number of academic papers on the subject, albeit emanating from foreign jurisdictions not directly considering the hugely (by comparison) complex UK tax system. Maybe there is a thesis in it for me one day. Of course, all of this is largely confined to academia unless and until the investment modelling tools used every day by advisers can incorporate the complexity.

But that is not to say we should ignore things altogether. With a bit of clever thinking, appropriate placing of relevant assets in relevant tax wrappers, and a degree of intuition we can influence the investor’s net return. Indeed, we have known for many years that certain tax wrappers are more or less advantageous for different types of investment return. However, the new tax year will see us having to step up our knowledge and strategies another notch.

From April 2016 we shall see the introduction of a dividend tax allowance and a savings tax allowance. These will operate alongside the normal personal allowance, the annual capital gains tax allowance, and the existing savings tax 0 per cent band for those within the income threshold. Fundamentally, there will exist some form of tax-free allowance for most forms of investment return, whether dividends, interest or capital growth. The sum total of these tax free allowances can amount to a not insubstantial £33,100.

Running alongside, there is the annual Isa allowance and pension allowance, which are two wrappers that operate very differently. The Isa is free from liability to personal tax, while the pension provides some tax-free cash and simply taxes any income payment, both being blind to the amount or type of investment return as such.

To use the tax-free allowances, appropriate assets must be in appropriate wrappers. To use the dividend allowance or the capital gains tax allowance one must use tax wrappers that fire into those regimes. That equity assets might be sitting elsewhere in a tax-free wrapper is not necessarily an optimum position as investors might be better using that tax-free wrapper for different returns that would otherwise be taxed.

Investors who plan to ensure they suffer less tax on their investment return will enjoy their wealth more. Developing an asset allocation model that optimally places assets into appropriate wrappers is not an academic nicety; it is about real pounds and pence. And it is a strategy where professional advisers can add untold benefit for their clients.

Paul Kennedy is head of tax and trust planning at FundsNetwork



Aegon revamps default pension funds

Aegon has launched a new range of default funds for its workplace pension schemes in response to the pension freedoms. The five funds have platform charges of between 0.05 per cent and 0.4 per cent. They all use Aegon’s “flexible target glidepath” which targets three retirement income decisions in the final six years of saving. […]


Stranded: Govt urged to bring self-employed into auto-enrolment

Pensions experts are calling on the Government to avert a savings disaster by bringing self-employed workers into automatic enrolment. The reforms require every employer to enrol staff in workplace pensions by 2018 but exclude people earning less than £10,000, the under-22s, those over state pension age, and people without an employer. At the same time, […]

Nick Bamford: The importance of common sense

“When a client engages you to do their financial plan they pretty much expect it to be delivered there and then.” These were the words of a consultant we saw recently to help us review the systems and processes we use to deliver financial plans to clients. The advice was very apt as we were staggered to learn our […]


Neil Liversidge: Why I never trust management consultants

I always admired the late Lord Weinstock. When he retired from General Electric Company the Financial Times gave him a couple of pages to pass on his accumulated wisdom to anyone aspiring to emulate him. One observation I recall him making was, “Every penny we ever spent on consultants was a complete waste of money.” When […]

Generation Rent

By Denise Wond, marketing manager We’ve heard a great deal about Generation Rent in recent years but what does it actually mean for consumers and advisers and has the face of the typical renter changed? The picture is certainly more diverse than it used to be. Homeownership is at its lowest point in 30 years, […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm