View more on these topics

Passive managers will come out on top in robo-advice battle


Research suggests the fledgling robo-advice market will be dominated by just three to five providers as active managers struggle to turn a profit.

The research consultancy Finalytiq predicts start-up robo-advice firms will “fall by the way side” due to the high cost of acquiring clients and the strength of established passive fund managers.

In its paper, titled ‘Laughing all the way to the bank’, the firm says index fund managers are set to emerge as winners because they will be able to add on between 20 to 40bps to their index funds charges with only a small increase in fixed costs.

It predicts Fidelity – which is planning to launch its proposition Fidelity Go later this year – is most likely to lead the pack, with Vanguard and BlackRock slightly behind because of their lack of direct-to-consumer distribution.

In addition it says despite its strong brand and deep pockets, Hargreaves Lansdown might struggle to break into the market.

The report says: “Costs would have to be lower than its current proposition. Its propensity to push high-margin active funds, rather than low-cost passive, is a big disincentive to entering the robo-advice race.”

Active managers in general will struggle and will need a “significant cultural shift” to cash in, says Finalytiq.

It says: “We don’t see typical asset managers being in a position to cash-in by launching a robo-advice proposition, due to the low-margins and high client acquisition cost typically associated with robo-advice.

“The increasing intermediation we have seen in the last few years means that most asset managers have had little or on direct relationship with retail investors for many years. They have outsourced client services to advisers, platforms and pension providers.

“Many of them don’t even know who the end investors in their own funds are and haven’t engaged with investors for many years.”

The firm adds the trend of established asset managers buying up robo-advice start-ups will continue as the cost of acquisition begins to bite.

In the UK Aberdeen Asset Management acquired Parmenion – which runs robo-adviser WealthHorizon – in September 2015, while in the US BlackRock snapped up FutureAdvisor last year and Invesco bought Jemstep at the start of 2016.

FinalytiQ says start-ups have evolved into “outsourced research and development labs” for traditional wealth managers.

It says: “The cost of client acquisition is one main reason why investment advice is so expensive and while robo-advice start-ups have improved efficiency in the areas of portfolio management, client reporting and the on-boarding process, it’s costing them way more than they have anticipated to acquire clients.”

Finalytiq founding director Abraham Okusanya says: “When the proposals from the Financial Advice Market Review get ironed out, you are likely to see robo-advice propositions growing in the marketplace but not many will be start-ups using new technology, it will be white-labelled propositions taken on by advice firms. There will be a flurry of launches and many of them will fall by the wayside.”

Adviser view

Paul Stocks, director, Dobson and Hodge

Robo-advice is fine for simple things. The minute you get into tax planning or long –term projections, it becomes subjective. It gets messy where things are not straightforward and you become the conscience on the client’s shoulder.

As soon as something complicated comes along I’m not sure how these systems will cope. With all the changes in areas like pensions how will a robo-adviser keep up?



David Ferguson: DFMs set to lose in robo-advice price war

The transparency argument is done, the retirement reforms (part one at least) likewise and the sunset clause is finally set to bring down the guillotine on the kickback-led market of the past. Now it is all about who really cares about the customer and who is then able to execute effectively. It is self-evident the […]

Banks prepare for robo-advice launches

Four major banks are developing robo-advice services aimed at mass market customers, with the first launch expected in the next two months. The Financial Times reports Barclays, Royal Bank of Scotland, Lloyds Banking Group and Santander are all eyeing robo-advice launches. The banks are said to be waiting on the outcome of the Financial Advice […]


Ian McKenna: Give in to the rise of the robots

In a recent study, 41 per cent of those surveyed said they believed obtaining financial advice would be a good way to use artificial intelligence.  The research by Ericsson ConsumerLab further identified one-third would trust the fidelity of an AI interface more than a human for sensitive matters. The study also highlighted that consumer adoption […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm