View more on these topics

OVERSEAS MATTERS

In the recent case of Gschwind v Finanzamt Aachen-Aussenstadt the taxpayer and his wife were resident in the Netherlands. He claimed that the conditions imposed on the availability of the “splitting procedure” to couples not resident in Germany constituted discrimination contrary to Article 48 (now Article 39) of the EC Treaty; the German tax advantage would be denied and the taxpayer`s personal and family circumstances would not be taken into account.



The splitting procedure involves each spouse being taxable on half their total income. It does not apply where one spouse was not resident in Germany unless 90% of the total taxable income is taxable in Germany or, if less, their income from foreign sources not subject to tax in Germany did not exceed a specified amount. The taxpayer was a Netherlands national and worked in Germany. His income accounted for 58% of the couple`s total income. His wife worked in the Netherlands.



The European Court of Justice (ECJ) ruled that there was no discrimination as the splitting procedure conditions were not contrary to article 48 (now article 39) of the EC Treaty. The conditions imposed on non-residents reflected the position where the couple`s tax base was in another member state. The couple`s personal and family circumstances would be taken into account in their state of residence.



COMMENTARY



In the earlier case of Finanzamt Koln-Altstadt v Schumaker the taxpayer was resident in Belgium but employed in Germany and he did not receive relief in either state. The German legislation was held to be discriminatory, and it was subsequently changed. However, in the present case the taxpayer would receive the relief allowable to his circumstances in the Netherlands.

Recommended

Standard Life spend £1m on Savings and Mortgage IT System

Standard Life Bank is updating its existing IT systems for mortgages and savings in a move to penetrate new markets.The bank has signed a contract for £1,000,000 with Lynx Financial Systems, and intends to add to its portfolio of telephone banking products.

Insurance Ombudsman appointed

Tony Boorman has been appointed as principle Insurance Ombudsman with the Financial Services Ombudsman Scheme and takes up the post from March 2000.The appointment has made jointly by the FSOS and the Insurance Ombudsman Bureau.IOB Council chairman Maurice Healy says: &#34Tony Boorman brings substantial experience in consumer affairs to the Bureau. He will lead the […]

Northern Rock to close 29 branches

Northern Rock is closing 29 of its 105 branches by the end of the year.The building society says 250 jobs will be lost from branches with declining business volumes, but expects to create jobs through the extension of internet and telephone banking.

First Quadrant expands London team

Investment managers First Quadrant has appointed Eoin Murray as senior Portfolio manager.His role will involve investment implementation for the firm&#39s equity and asset allocation products, and business development in the UK, Continental Europe and Middle East.Murray was previously head of Asset Allocation at PanAgora Asset Management in London.

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up

Comments

    Leave a comment