View more on these topics

OUTSIDE EDGE Robert Reid outside View Robert Reid

After six years on the Sofa board, including two years as the chairman, and a practising IFA since 1985, this new fortnightly column is designed to reflect my views on the challenges IFA&#39s currently face. I cannot guarantee that my views will always be popular but I am certain that they will make you think and hopefully encourage you to debate the issues raised.

While on the board at Sofa, I was one of the small team of directors who prepared our submissions on polarisation. I met with the OFT and the FSA in an attempt to explain why any changes had to keep the consumers&#39 interest as the prime driver for change or for retaining the status quo.

As submission followed submission, it became clear that the reason for the consultation was not improving consumer choice but ensuring that the banks and insurance companies would take part in promoting stakeholder pensions.

The FSA has now issued its consultation paper on Reforming Polarisation and this is one document that all IFAs should take the time to read.

Considering this paper as a whole, I have to comment on the lack of substance in many of the assumptions – that is, no research to support the conclusions. This is very worrying as it is these assumptions which will form the foundations of the suggested changes.

There also seems to be the view that the introduction of multi-ties will automatically result in clients being offered more competitive contracts.

This is either extremely naive or simply heralds the introduction of Catmarks on all products, not just Isa and stakeholder pensions, with non-Catmarked plans only available via IFAs. The limited time for responses will inev itably result in the consultation being less effective than it should be for such a major change.The paper is not all good news for the fans of multi-ties either, given that individual tied agents or franchisees will not be able to be multi-tied as the paper suggests that the “host” must be a provider. This then raises the issue of complaints, especially where the host office no longer has a relationship with the provider who issued the plan.

The logistics of making or dealing with a complaint in that particular circumstance will be immense, especially if the claim is to be dealt with promptly. There is also the risk that the client finds themselves between two parties, with each blaming the other.

The paper states that the objective is to “secure for consumers greater access to and choice of good value products”. It is hard to see how these proposals could truly achieve this without a level of status disclosure that would deter any organisation in taking up the option of multi-ties.

The London Economics report made it clear that any change would require clarity of status given the public&#39s confusion over the current status of the major banks – that is, they assumed they were independent, when they were in the majority tied to a single provider.

One solution would be to refer to all tied and multi-tied advisers as investment/ insurance salesmen, with only independents being able to use the title financial adviser/planner. To make this work, IFA&#39s would probably need to move to a fee-based approach.

The regulator may well prompt this move as they have already stated that they intend to review the various methods used to remunerate the adviser. Change is on the way let us just hope that the FSA does not deal with the consultation process in the most Equitable manner.

Robert Reid is an IFA with Syndaxi Financial Planning


Singer & Friedlander credit ratings increased

The financial ratings for Singer & Friedlander Group and its principal banking subsidiary, Singer & Friedlander Limited have been raised by Fitch IBCA, the independent rating specialists. The short and long term ratings for S&FG and S&FL have been increased to F1 and A from F2 and A- respectively. Fitch IBCA defines a bank rated […]

On the trail of the closed companies

It has become fashionable to attack the payment of ren ewal commission to advisers. Not only have att acks been made in the consumer press of late but a recent art icle in Money Marketing by Lorna Bourke also savaged the payment of renewals. Does this argument have any credence? Consider rec ent events at […]

IF to increase savings rate

Intelligent Finance will increase its top rate for savings to 6.5 per cent from 6.25 per cent from January 16, 2001. The rate is for savings of £100,000 and over. Savers who also have personal loans with IF can receive up to 10.5 per cent on their savings. IF believes that best buy tables should […]

Barclays allies with L&G

Barclays has announced the closure of its life insurance division after signing an alliance with Legal & General to sell its branded life and pension products. The closure will result in the loss of 750 jobs in London and the south east of England. Barclays will become L&G&#39s largest distributor and hopes to double its […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm