View more on these topics

Outside edge Robert Reid

Back in 1999, I found myself speaking at the Canadian Financial Planners conference on the topic of regulation. In the room set aside for speakers, I was checking my slides when another speaker entered the room. She introduced herself, then immediately asked if I minded if she was noisy. My reply was lost on her, as is most ironic humour on the other side of the pond. She then lay on the floor doing stretches and apparently replaying that famous scene out of When Harry Met Sally where Meg Ryan fakes the proverbial. Like any good News of the World man, I made my excuses and left in case anyone thought I was the catalyst for this welter of noise.

After this brief encounter, I spoke on the evolution of UK regulation and, as I took delegates&#39 questions, it became clear that the UK model was their worst nightmare. As has been said many times before, as much as 20 per cent of an adviser&#39s time is spent dealing with compliance requirements.

Until now, it seemed that the UK was at the forefront, determining the extremes of regulation ahead of both the US and Europe. But recent moves to align UK regulation with forthcoming EU directives simply serve to underline that the FSA cannot continue to operate in a vacuum and the EU will be the pre-eminent body which will shape regulation far into the future.

The current Treasury consultation on e-business brings this even more sharply into focus as it allows for a regulator in a less stringent regime to trade with UK-based consumers. For those who suggest this means relocating a business, read on, for the Treasury paper makes it clear that a “branch office” could have the same ability to be governed by the country in which it is located or, as it is described in the paper, its country of origin.

The recent news that a group of Independent Insurance policyholders will challenge the FSA&#39s legal immunity through the European Court is further evidence of the influence of the EU in regulation.

Perhaps we now have an opportunity to lobby for a far more consumerand advice-led process as opposed to the current approach, which centres on products and attempts to regulate far too diverse a group of companies.

A long time ago, Garry Heath suggested that compliance should be a function of competence, with the more competent given a lighter touch with regard to compliance. The FSA may argue that this is similar to its risk-based approach but I would disagree.

Some of the aims of the Sandler review are likely to be frustrated unless the cost of compliance can be brought into check.

Many continue to raise fears of social exclusion from independent advice as a reason for allowing the introduction of multi-ties as these will “improve” the choice of those who cannot afford fees. The reason why fees are now out of the reach of many consumers is primarily due to advisers&#39 need to fund for future circumstances.

I recently suggested that we should charge an initial fee, not to cover expenses but to create a reserve for that client&#39s first complaint. This may lead us on to rebating these fees in the form of a no-claims bonus.

If the FSA cannot or will not make significant moves to equate the reach of compliance with competence, then we may do better to concentrate our efforts on Europe, given the EU&#39s undoubted influence on regulation into the future.

Perhaps given this potential emasculation of our esteemed regulator, it, like Meg Ryan, has been faking it too?

Robert Reid is principal of Syndaxi Financial Planning


BBN shareholders back £48m Berkeley buyout

The £47.7m acquisition of Ber-keley Independent network by IFA Berry Birch & Noble gained shareholder approval last week, with about 50 per cent of the network&#39s members taking share options.The move was given the go-ahead at an EGM last week by about 94 per cent of existing shareholders, giving the deal unconditional acceptance.The new company […]

DBS will count the cost of its hike in charges

I refer to the enormous hike in DBS costs and would like to mention a few facts regarding this matter as opposed to the verbiage emanating from DBS.First, I understand from a colleague who joined DBS in l988 that his DBS charge was 8 per cent at that time. Since then it has risen to […]

Pass the portal

The news just before Christmas of Skandia&#39s proposed acquisition of Bankhall, via an unbundling of Lynx, is yet another roll of the dice in the distribution stakes.The deal is an attractive one for both Skandia and Bankhall. Skandia gains ownership of a significant IFA services business and the management. That it can do so without […]

Pink Home Loans – Direct Exclusive 3 Year Stepped Discount

Monday, January 7, 2002.Discounted term: Three years.Discount: 2.4 per cent in year one, 1.4 per cent in year two, 0.4 percent in year three.Payable rate: 3.34 per cent in year one, 4.34 per cent in year two, 5.34per cent in year three.Minimum loan: £25,001.Maximum loan: Loans of up to 80 per cent of valuation subject […]

Guide front cover - thumbnail

Guide: how to… audit your auto-enrolment scheme compliance

As the Pensions Regulator starts to bare its teeth and the changes mentioned in the Budget and Queen’s Speech start to come into force, it is essential that you understand your scheme and the processes you need to undertake to ensure it remains compliant. Our second re-enrolment guide looks at how to audit the key areas of your auto-enrolment scheme.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm