View more on these topics

Outside Edge – Garry Heath

The financial services world is becoming increasingly surreal. Gone is the old image of a staid and sober industry with commonly held views, which encouraged thrift and temperance and created a world in which wealth creation was real, if a little slow. In its stead is a fashion industry in which views change almost on a weekly basis with the minimum of thought, let alone intellectual vigour.

In CP121, the regulator invents a number of “market failings” as its reasons for executing its political masters&#39 wishes. In one breath, it claims that “too few consumers are making adequate financial provision for their financial future” and in the next that “remuneration systems give advisers an incentive to sell”.

Wait a minute, we have underinvesting consumers on one hand and nasty, filthy salesmen on the other. Apparently, the regulator does not want its industry to be a commercial venture but wants the investor to mystically invest without anyone, except perhaps the FSA, explaining to them why it might be a good idea. We should get Sir Howard on one of those cookery programmes and he could show Ainsley how to cook omelettes without breaking eggs.

While the regulator fiddles with the ticklish problem of encouraging people with no money to invest their way into a poverty trap, may I point out to the industry&#39s fire brigade that there is a hell of a fire in the city which might need their attention. Money is flooding out of product providers.

First, we have the ticklish problem of with-profits, with much of the debate concentrated on its lack of transparency. Frankly, I do not care whether a with-profits policy achieves its results with the help of witchcraft and a coven of Trappist monks as long as it achieves. The real question is whether it still works in a market of continued poor investment returns.

Many product providers have been overdeclaring on bonuses for some time and the phrase “glide path” is whispered at actuarial gatherings. The providers are on actuarial methadone, slowing down bonus declarations until the bonuses match the reality of the returns. Funding the gap is expensive.

Second, the cost of the pension review has not been properly appreciated, with £11bn of redress and a total bill upwards of £16bn. These are massive numbers and do not include much of the administrative time spent.

Third, we have stakeholder pensions, which must be proof positive that magic mushrooms are served in industry boardrooms. The most enthusiastic provider claims that stakeholder will become profitable to them in seven years, with many companies opting beyond 12. I am sorry but who in business creates a product that will not show a profit for a decade? Thank God it has been a flop.

Finally, there is the problem of profitable new sales. There are few providers which are making a profit on new sales. This will increase with the introduction of multi-ties.

Anyone who lives in the real world must believe that multi-tied clients will be offered products from providers which have been selected on the basis of the highest possible income to the multi-tied firm. Increased costs for the same business. They do not teach you that at Harvard, fortunately.

Time for a reality check. Shouldn&#39t regulation be about consumer protection rather than social engineering?

Shouldn&#39t providers be creating products that work rather than pandering to a civil servant&#39s fantasies?

Shouldn&#39t we give more thought to market stability and prudential regulation? And shouldn&#39t we all admit that we are in commerce and stop pretending that we are financial social workers?

Garry Heath is chairman of Impartial


Website to cut service costs for IFAs

Software company CCL is setting up an IFA website that provides a range of services at a reduced cost or free of charge.The website offers IFAs access to calculators for pensions, investments, tax and mortgages and provides generic illustrations on the costs of products at also allows IFAs to print reason-why letters,the latest FSA […]

IFAs warned not to sell their firms too cheaply

IFAs should beware of selling equity in their firms too early, too cheaply and to people that cannot add value to the business, founder of Skandia UK Paul Bradshaw has warned.Bradshaw told the Money Marketing G80 summit, near Newport, Wales last week, that the financial advice market was far from mature and said he expected […]

BA shuts final salary schemes

British Airways has announced that it is shutting its two defined benefit pension schemes to new members blaming FRS17, poor stock market returns and increases in life expectancy.BA found that under the new calculation the shortfall was £394m in the two schemes which have combined assets of around £10bn. It has yet to release details […]

Coventry Building Society – Two Year Fixed Rate Bond

Friday, May 10, 2002 Type: High interest account Minimum-maximum investment: £1,000-£250,000 Interest rate: 5.1% gross a year Term: Until September 30, 2004 Offer period: Until further notice Withdrawal penalties: 90 days&#39 loss of interest on amount withdrawn Tel 0845 7665522

2016 Global Survey of Individual Investors: How is investor behaviour rewriting the job description for financial professionals?

Trapped between expectations for near double-digit returns and strong apprehensions about investing in persistently volatile markets, investors worldwide are of the opinion that professional financial advice is worth the fee. But even though they believe individuals who work with a financial professional are more likely to achieve their goals, investors have a clear vision of […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm