View more on these topics

Online comments from last week

“Nirvana and Utopia” but en route many have been damned to hell and more will follow.

The concept is laudable but naive and unlikely to encourage the public to seek advice if they consult the FSA website. The home page is totally negative and anti -adviser as is, MAS. Both sites ‘bang on’ about complaining about advice or advisers. There is a need for regulation and professionalism but the FSA/FCA are steering us down the wrong course. How about some positive publicity for IFAs bearing in mind we pay your fees?

Peter Taylor

Hmm, define worse consumer outcomes? If most people cannot afford good advice then presumably they will DIY advice or simply not bother. So it will rather depend on what the FCA measure… products or financial independence from the state. Given automatic enrolment this will be a hard thing to measure anyway.

It is not as though people haven’t offered the FSA advice to mop up the catalogue of unintended consequences, many of them could have and could still be avoided. If they bothered to listen and not simply assume we are self-interested crooks.

Dominic Thomas

No one who thinks RDR is a sound business proposition has a clue about business. RDR starts with limiting consumer choice. It starts with a ludicrous outcome. It first attacks the consumer. It says your IFA might be a twisted immoral individual who might advise an inappropriate product because of the commission on offer.

Even though the commission has been declared to you before you decide, your IFA could be bent. Therefore, you will not be given the choice to pay for this product in this way. You will not be given a choice. The consumer is attacked first. What a crazy set up this is.

Ken Warren

“Utopia” would be a level playing field between commission-only no advice and fee-paying advice

Billy Burrows

RDR will lead to less people being able to afford to take advice. Less advice means less risk for the FSA. Less risk means less exposure to compensation claims being made to the FSCS.

Duncan Cole

I’m tired of bleating on about the catastrophe that the RDR represents. Shortly I’ll be able to say, “told you so” but the prospect doesn’t fill me with any joy.

There can never be a foolproof method of delivering good outcomes because consumers are not logical. If they were they would consult advisers and not banks. They would seek specialist help rather than self-serve by going to bucket shops – the industry equivalent of Poundland.

Maybe Martin Wheatley is cannily positioning himself for the potential U-turn that logic dictates will occur in a few years time.

The problem relates to whether the regulator is actually a politically motivated animal which seeks to reflect ill-informed public opinion or whether it is a free-thinking organisation that is able and willing to hold it collective hands up and admit to being stupid first time around.

Alan Lakey

Online comments relating to article: FSA will have ‘zero-tolerance’ RDR exam stance

We have had years to get these exams and although I feel sorry for the individuals who have not attained the qualifications we have to draw a line somewhere.

I hope the FSA will also crack down not only on people that should be deauthorised because they haven’t obtained the relevant exams, but also on organisations and individuals operating without proper authorisation.

If I have evidence of any organisation operating without registration I will be reporting them and that includes large brands that continue to break regulations laid down to protect consumers.

Peter Herd

The last hurrah of a “dead” regulator? I have zero tolerance for its institutional incompetence and its own deadline missing.

It is less important to me that the regulator has adviser exams (few of which are directly relevant to regulation) far more that the individuals are competent to regulate and based on what we see – they are clearly not. Which is why of course they are being replaced.

Simon Webster



Case study: Making the most of a redundancy pay

The problem: After having been made redundant a few months ago, the client has been able to secure a new job and without drawing heavily upon his substantial redundancy payment. This was obviously a great relief as the client has a young family with a daughter aged 7. The client is a higher-rate taxpayer and […]

UK All Companies Sector: Manager highlight sector opportunities

Earnings-related pressure remains the dominant theme, both in the US, where the fiscal cliff does appear to be acting as a considerable drag on corporates, and in Europe, where politicians continue to put political issues far ahead of any genuine attempt to restore growth. Shorter term respite may come with Spain asking for its bail-out […]

Santander sets aside £232m for ‘customer conduct issues’

antander UK has set aside £232m to deal with undisclosed “historic customer conduct issues”. The bank announced the provision in its quarterly management statement for the nine months to the end of September, published last week. It is unclear what products the provision relates to, although Santander UK says the amount is separate to the […]

Why multi-asset is a key tool for now

Many developed markets are facing a debt overhang on four fronts – private, public, household and pension. In the run-up to 2008, the growth in credit within developed countries was allowed to continue beyond sustainable levels because of a combination of uniquely advantageous economic factors. When the credit bubble finally burst in late 2008 and […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm